Abstract
A classification theorem for voting rules on a smooth choice space W of dimension w is presented. It is shown that, for any non-collegial voting rule, σ, there exist integers v *(σ), w *(σ) (with v *(σ)<w *(σ)) such that
-
(i)
structurally stable σ-voting cycles may always be constructed when w ⪴ v *(σ) + 1
-
(ii)
a structurally stable σ-core (or voting equilibrium) may be constructed when w ⪴ v *(σ) − 1
Finally, it is shown that for an anonymous q-rule, a structurally stable core exists in dimension \(\frac{{n - 2}}{{n - q}}\), where n is the cardinality of the society.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Berge C (1963) Topological spaces. Oliver and Boyd, London
Brown DJ (1973) Acyclic choice. Working Paper, Cowles Foundation, Yale University
Cohen L (1979) Cyclic sets in multidimensional voting models. J Econ Theory 20:1–12
Cohen L, Matthews SA (1980) Constrained Plott equilibria, directional equilibria and global cycling sets. Rev Econ Stud 47:975–986
Cox G (1981) Non-collegial simple games and the nowhere denseness of the set of preference profiles having a core. Soc Choice Welfare 1:159–164
Craven J (1971) Majority voting and social choice. Rev Econ Stud 38:265–267
D'Asprement C, Tulkers H (1980) Commodity exchanges as gradient processes. Econometrica 48:387–400
Downs A (1957) Economic theory of democracy. Harper and Row, New York
Enelow JM, Hinich MJ (1983) On Plott's pairwise symmetry conditions for majority rule equilibrium. Public Choice 40:317–321
Ferejohn JA, Grether DM (1974) On a class of rational social decision procedures. J Econ Theory 8:471–482
Ferejohn JA, Grether DM, McKelvey RD (1982) Implementation of democratic social choice functions. Rev Econ Stud 49:439–446
Golubitsky M, Guillemin V (1973) Stable mappings and their singularities. Springer, Berlin Heidelberg New York
Greenberg J (1979) Consistent majority rules over compact sets of alternatives. Econometrica 41:285–297
Koford K (1982) An optimistic view of the possibility of rational legislative decisionmaking. Public Choice 38:3–19
Kramer GH (1973) On a class of equilibrium conditions for majority rule. Econometrica 41:285–297
Kramer GH, Klevorick AK (1974) Existence of a “local” cooperative equilibrium in a class of voting games. Rev Econ Stud 41:539–548
McKelvey RD (1976) Intransitivities in multidimensional voting models and some implications for agenda control. J Econ Theory 12:472–482
McKelvey RD (1979) General conditions for global intransitivities in formal voting models. Econometrica 47:1085–1111
McKelvey RD, Schofield N (1984) Structural instability of the core. Social Science Working paper no. 535. California Institute of Technology
Matthews SA (1979) A simple directional model of electoral competition. Public Choice 34:141–156
Matthews SA (1980) Pairwise symmetry conditions for voting equilibria. Int J Game Theory 9:141–156
Matthews SA (1982) Local simple games in public choice mechanisms. Int Econ Rev 23:623–645
Nakamura K (1978) The vetoers in a simple game with ordinal preferences. Int J Game Theory 8:55–61
Ordeshook PC, Shepsle KA eds. (1982) Political equilibrium. Kluwer-Nijhoff, The Hague
Peleg B (1978) Consistent voting systems. Econometrica 46:153–161
Plott CR (1967) A notion of equilibrium and its possibility under majority rule. Am Econ Rev 57:787–806
Rubinstein A (1979) A note about the “nowhere denseness” of societies having an equilibrium under majority rule. Econometrica 47:512–514
Salles M, Wendell RE (1977) A further result on the core of voting games. Int J Game Theory 6:35–40
Schofield N (1977) Transitivity of preferences on a smooth manifold of alternatives. J Econ Theory 14:149–171
Schofield N (1978) Instability of simple dynamic games. Rev Econ Stud 45:575–594
Schofield N (1980) Generic properties of simple Bergson-Samuelson welfare functions. J Math Econ 7:175–192
Schofield N (1980) Catastrophe theory and dynamic games. Quality Quantity 14:519–545
Schofield N (1980) Individual and collective rationality. In: Lewin L, Vedung E (eds) Politics as Rational Action. Reidel, Dordrecht, Holland
Schofield N (1983) Generic instability of majority rule. Rev Econ Stud 50:695–705
Schofield N (1983) Equilibria in simple dynamic games. In: Pattanaik PK, Salles M (eds) Social Choice and Welfare. North-Holland, Amsterdam New York
Schofield N (1984) Social equilibrium and cycles on compact sets. J Econ Theory 33:59–71
Schofield N (1984) Existence of equilibrium on a manifold. Math Oper Res (forthcoming)
Sen AK (1973) Colletive choice and social welfare. North-Holland, Amsterdam New York
Slutsky S (1979) Equilibrium under α-majority voting. Econometrica 47:1113–1127
Strnad J (1981) The structure of continuous neutral monotonic social functions. Soc Choice Welfare (forthcoming)
Tullock G (1981) Why so much stability? Public Choice 37:189–205
Weymark J (1981) Undominated directions of tax reform. J Public Econ 16:343–369
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Schofield, N. Classification theorem for smooth social choice on a manifold. Soc Choice Welfare 1, 187–210 (1984). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00433516
Received:
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00433516