Abstract
The displacement of conventional generation by converter connected resources reduces the available rotational inertia in the power system, which leads to faster frequency dynamics and consequently a less stable frequency behaviour. This study aims at presenting the current requirements and challenges that transmission system operators are facing due to the high integration of inertia-less resources. The manuscript presents a review of the various solutions and technologies that could potentially compensate for reduction in system inertia. The solutions are categorized into two groups, namely synchronous inertia and emulated inertia employing fast acting reserve (FAR). Meanwhile, FAR is divided into three groups based on the applied control approach, namely virtual synchronous machines, synthetic inertia control and fast frequency control. The analytical interdependency between the applied control approaches and the frequency gradient is also presented. It highlights the key parameters that can influence the units’ response and limit their ability in participating in such services. The manuscript presents also a trade-off analysis among the most prominent control approaches and technologies guiding the reader through benefits and drawbacks of each solution.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
The ELECTRA Integrated Research Program on Smart Grids brings together the partners of the EERA Joint Program on Smart Grids to reinforce and accelerate Europe’s medium to long-term research cooperation in this area and to drive a closer integration of the research programmes of the participating organizations and of the related national programmes.
References
Ackermann T (2011) Wind power in power systems. Wiley, New York
Marinelli M, Massucco S, Mansoldo A, Norton M (2011) Analysis of inertial response and primary power-frequency control provision by doubly fed induction generator wind turbines in a small power system. In: 17th Power systems computation conference, pp 1–7
Christensen PW, Tarnowski GT (2011) Inertia of wind power plants state of the art review. In: The 10th international workshop on large-scale of wind power, Aarhus, Denmark
Muljadi E, Gevorgian V, Singh M, Santoso S (2012) Understanding inertial and frequency response of wind power plants. In: 2012 IEEE power electronics and machines in wind applications, pp 1–8
Sharma S, Huang SH, Sarma N (2011) System inertial frequency response estimation and impact of renewable resources in ERCOT interconnection. In: 2011 IEEE power and energy society general meeting, pp 1–6
Pertl M, Weckesser T, Rezkalla M, Marinelli M (2017) Transient stability improvement: a review and comparison of conventional and renewable-based techniques for preventive and emergency control. Electr Eng 100(3):1–18
Mancarella P, Puschel S, Wang H, Brear M, Jones T, Jeppesen M, Batterham R, Evans R, Mareels I (2017) Power system security assessment of the future National Electricity Market. Technical report June, Melbourne Energy Institute, Melbourne
EIRGRID, SONI (2016) RoCoF alternative and complementary solutions project. Technical report March, EIRGRID
Martini L, Radaelli L, Brunner H, Caerts C, Morch A, Hänninen S, Tornelli C (2015) ELECTRA IRP approach to voltage and frequency control for future power systems with high DER penetration. In: 23rd International conference on electricity distribution (CIRED)
Rezkalla M, Heussen K, Marinelli M, Hu J, Bindner HW (2015) Identification of requirements for distribution management systems in the smart grid context. In: Power engineering conference (UPEC), 2015 50th international universities, pp 1–6
The Commission for Energy Regulation (2014) Rate of change of frequency (RoCoF) modification to the grid code. Technical report, CER
EirGrid, SONI (2015) DS3 RoCoF alternative solutions phase 1 concluding note. Technical report, EirGrid
DNV GL Energy Advisory (2015) RoCoF alternative solutions technology assessment. Technical report, DNVGL
National Grid (2013) Fast reserve service description. Technical report April, National Grid
Brisebois J, Aubut N (2011) Wind farm inertia emulation to fulfill Hydro-Québec’s specific need. In: Power and energy society general meeting IEEE, vol 7, pp 1–7
Palermo J (2016) International review of frequency control adaptation. Technical report, DGA
Serway R, Beichner R, Jewett J (2000) Physics for scientists and engineers, 5th edn. Holt Rinehart & Winston, Philadelphia
Cheng M, Zhu Y (2014) The state of the art of wind energy conversion systems and technologies: a review. Energy Convers Manag 88:332–347
Licari J, Ekanayake J, Moore I (2013) Inertia response from full-power converter-based permanent magnet wind generators. J Mod Power Syst Clean Energy 1:26–33
Gonzalez-longatt FM (2016) Impact of emulated inertia from wind power on under-frequency protection schemes of future power systems. J Mod Power Syst Clean Energy 4(2):211–218
Tamrakar U, Galipeau D, Tonkoski R, Tamrakar I (2015) Improving transient stability of photovoltaic-hydro microgrids using virtual synchronous machines. In: PowerTech. IEEE, Eindhoven
Tamrakar U, Shrestha D, Maharjan M, Bhattarai BP, Hansen TM, Tonkoski R (2017) Virtual inertia: current trends and future directions. Appl Sci 7:1–29
Beck HP, Hesse R (2007) Virtual synchronous machine. In: 9th International conference on electrical power quality and utilisation, Barcelona, Spain
D’Arco S, Suul J (2013) Virtual synchronous machines classification of implementations and analysis of equivalence to droop controllers for microgrids. In: PowerTech. IEEE, Grenoble
Machowski J, Bialek JW, Bumby JR (1997) Power system dynamics and stability. Wiley, Chichester
Kimbark EW (1956) Power system stability volume III synchronous machines. Wiley, New York
Van Wesenbeeck MPN, De Haan SWH, Varela P, Visscher K (2009) Grid tied converter with virtual kinetic storage. In: IEEE Bucharest PowerTech: innovative ideas toward the electrical grid of the future
Driesen J, Visscher K (2008) Virtual synchronous generators. In: Power and energy society general meeting, pp 1–3, Pittsburgh, PA, USA
Karapanos V, Haan S, Zwetsloot K (2011) Real time simulation of a power system with VSG hardware in the loop. In: IECON: 37th annual conference on IEEE industrial electronics society, pp 1–7, Melbourne, VIC, Australia
Thong V, Woyte A, Albu M, Hest M, Bozelie J, Diaz J, Loix T, Stanculescu D, Visscher K (2009) Virtual synchronous generator: laboratory scale results and field demonstration. In: PowerTech. IEEE, Bucharest, pp 1–6
Chen Y, Hesse R, Turschner D, Beck HP (2012) Comparison of methods for implementing virtual synchronous machine on inverters. In: International conference on renewable energies and power quality, pp 1–6, Santiago de Compostela
Pelczar C (2012) Mobile virtual synchronous machine for vehicle-to-grid applications. PhD thesis, Clausthal University of Technology
Marinelli M, Martinenas S, Knezovi K, Andersen PB (2016) Validating a centralized approach to primary frequency control with series-produced electric vehicles. J Energy Storage 7:63–73
Rezkalla M, Zecchino A, Martinenas S, Prostejovsky AM, Marinelli M (2018) Comparison between synthetic inertia and fast frequency containment control based on single phase EVs in a microgrid. Appl Energy 210:764–775
Xue S, Kasztenny B, Voloh I, Oyenuga D (2007) Power system frequency measurement for frequency relaying. In: Western protective relay conference, At Spokane, WA
BegoviC MM, DjuriC PM, Dunlap S, Phadke AG (1993) Frequency tracking ih power networks in the presence of harmonics. IEEE Trans Power Deliv 8(2):480–486
Asnin L, Backmutsky V, Gankin M, Blashka J, Sedlachek M (2001) DSP methods for dynamic estimation of frequency and magnitude parameters in power system transients. In: IEEE Power Tech conference, pp 1–6, Porto
Nguyen CT, Srinivasan K (1984) A new technique for rapid tracking of frequency deviations based on level crossings. IEEE Trans Power Appar Syst 8(8):2230–2236
Hart D, Novosel D, Hu Y, Smith B, Egolf M (1997) A new frequency tracking and phasor estimation algorithm for generator protection. IEEE Trans Power Deliv 12(3):1064–1073
Kasztenny B, Rosolowski E (1998) Two new measuring algorithms for generator and transformer relaying. IEEE Trans Power Deliv 13(4):1053–1059
Wang M, Sun Y (2004) A practical, precise method for frequency tracking and phasor estimation. IEEE Trans Power Deliv 19(4):1547–1552
Eckhardt V, Hippe P, Hosemann G (1989) Dynamic measuring of frequency and frequency oscillations in multiphase power systems. IEEE Trans Power Deliv 4(1):95–102
Karimi-Ghartemani M, Iravani MR (2003) Wide-range, fast and robust estimation of power system frequency. Electr Power Syst Res 65(2):109–117
Karimi H, Karimi-Ghartemani M, Iravani MR (2004) Estimation of frequency and its rate of change for applications in power systems. IEEE Trans Power Deliv
Moore PJ, Carranza RD, Johns AT (1994) A new numeric technique for high-speed evaluation of power system frequency. IEE Proc Gener Transm Distrib 141(5):529–536
Sidhu TS (1999) Accurate measurement of power system frequency using a digital signal processing technique. IEEE Trans Instrum Meas 48(1):75–81
Dash PK, Panda G, Pradhan AK, Routray A, Duttagupta B (2000) An extended complex Kalman filter for frequency measurement of distorted signals. In: 2000 IEEE power engineering society, conference proceedings
Lin HC (2007) Fast tracking of time-varying power system frequency and harmonics using iterative-loop approaching algorithm. IEEE Trans Industr Electron 54(2):974–983
Salcic Z, Li Z, Annakkage UD, Pahalawaththa N (1998) A comparison of frequency measurement methods for underfrequency load shedding. Electr Power Syst Res 45(3):209–219
Patra JP, Dash PK (2012) Fast frequency and harmonic estimation in power systems using a new optimized adaptive filter. Electr Eng 95:171–184
Wu J, Long J, Wang J (2005) High-accuracy, wide-range frequency estimation methods for power system signals under nonsinusoidal conditions. IEEE Trans Power Deliv 20(1):366–374
Duric MB, Terzija VV, Skokljev IA (1994) Power system frequency estimation utilizing the Newton–Raphson method. Electr Eng 77:221–226
Dash PK, Panda SK, Mishra B, Swain DP (1997) Fast estimation of voltage and current phasors in power networks using an adaptive neural network. IEEE Trans Power Syst 12(4):1494–1499
El-Naggar KM, Youssef HKM (2000) Genetic based algorithm for frequency-relaying applications. Electr Power Syst Res 55(3):173–178
Kostyla P, Lobos T, Waclawek Z (1996) Neural networks for real-time estimation of signal parameters. In: Proceedings of IEEE international symposium on industrial electronics
Kundur P, Paserba J, Ajjarapu V, Andersson G, Bose A, Canizares C, Hatziargyriou N, Hill D, Stankovic A, Taylor C, Van Cutsem T, Vittal V (2004) Definition and classification of power system stability. IEEE Trans Power Syst 21(3):1387–1401
Temtem K, Creighton S (2012) Summary of studies on rate of change of frequency events on the all-Island system. Technical report August 2012, Entso-E
EirGrid (2012) RoCoF modification proposal: TSOs recommendations. Technical report September, EirGrid
Xu W, Mauch K, Martel S (2004) An assessment of distributed generation islanding detection methods and issues for Canada. Technical report, CETC, Canada
Ding X, Crossley PA, Morrow DJ (2007) Islanding detection for distributed generation. J Electr Eng Technol 2(1):19–28
Beddoes A, Thomas P, Gosden M (2005) Loss of mains protection relay performances when subjected to network disturbances/events. In: 18th International conference on electricity distribution CIRED, pp 1–5
CHUI FEN TEN (2010) Loss of mains detection and amelioration on electrical distribution networks. PhD thesis, University of Manchester
Hassan AAM, Kandeel TA (2015) Effectiveness of frequency relays on networks with multiple distributed generation. J Electr Syst Inf Technol
Uijlings W (2013) An independent analysis on the ability of Generators to ride through Rate of Change of Frequency values up to 2Hz/s. Technical report, Uijlings
Mccartan T (2016) Rate of change of frequency (RoCoF) project six monthly report for November 2016. Technical report November, ForskEl Project
Knezović K, Marinelli M, Zecchino A, Andersen PB, Traeholt C (2017) Supporting involvement of electric vehicles in distribution grids: lowering the barriers for a proactive integration. Energy 134:458–468
Rezkalla M, Marinelli M, Pertl M, Heussen K (2016) Trade-off analysis of virtual inertia and fast primary frequency control during frequency transients in a converter dominated network. In: Innovative smart grid technologies: Asia (ISGT-Asia), IEEE, pp 1–6, Melbourne, VIC, Australia
Pereira L, Undrill J, Kosterev D, Davies D, Patterson S (2003) A new thermal governor modeling approach in the WECC. IEEE Trans Power Syst 18(2):819–829
Miller NW, Shao M, Pajic S, Aquila RD (2013) Eastern frequency response study. Technical report May, NREL
Energinet DK (2012) Ancillary services to be delivered in Denmark Tender conditions. Technical report, Energinet, Fredericia
ENTSO-E (2016) Frequency stability evaluation criteria for the synchronous zone of continental Europe. Technical report, ENTSOE
Schifreen CS, Marble WC (1956) Charging current limitations in operation or high-voltage cable lines [includes discussion]. Trans Am Inst Electr Eng Part III Power Appar Syst 75(3):803–817
Chen L, Zheng T, Mei S, Xue X, Liu B, Lu Q (2016) Review and prospect of compressed air energy storage system. J Mod Power Syst Clean Energy 4(4):529–541
Elmegaard B, Markussen Brix W (2011) Efficiency of compressed air energy storage. In: The 24th International conference on efficiency, cost, optimization, simulation and environmental impact of energy systems
Vaahedi E (2014) Practical power system operation, 1st edn. Wiley, New York
Tønnesen AE, Pedersen AH, Elmegaard B, Rasmussen J, Vium JH, Reinholdt L, Pedersen AS (2010) Electricity storage technologies for short term power system services at transmission level. Technical report October, ForskEl Project
Macak J (2014) Evaluation of gas turbine startup and shutdown emissions for new source permitting. Technical report, Mostardi Platt Environmental, Florida
Rehman S, Al-Hadhrami LM, Alam MM (2015) Pumped hydro energy storage system: a technological review. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 44:586–598
Mohanpurkar M, Ouroua A, Hovsapian R, Luo Y, Singh M, Muljadi E, Gevorgian V, Donalek P (2018) Real-time co-simulation of adjustable-speed pumped storage hydro for transient stability analysis. Electr Power Syst Res 154:276–286
Ela E, Kirby B, Botterud A, Milostan C, Krad I, Koritarov V (2013) Role of pumped storage hydro resources in electricity markets and system operation. In: HydroVision International Denver, Colorado, 23–26 July 2013
NHA Pumped storage council (2012) Challenges and opportunities for new pumped storage development. Technical report, NHA
Luo X, Wang J, Dooner M, Clarke J (2015) Overview of current development in electrical energy storage technologies and the application potential in power system operation. Appl Energy 137:551–536
Nakamura S, Yamada T, Nomura T, Iwamoto M, Shindo Y, Nose S, Fujino H, Ishihara A (1985) 30 MVA superconducting synchronous condenser: design and it’s performance test results. IEEE Trans Magn 21(2):783–790
Oliver JA, Ware BJ, Carruth RC (1971) 345 MVA fully water-cooled synchronous condenser for dumont station part I. Application considerations. IEEE Trans Power Appar Syst PAS 90(6):2758–2764
Nguyen HT, Yang G, Nielsen AH, Jensen V (2016) Frequency stability improvement of low inertia systems using synchronous condensers. In: 2016 IEEE international conference on smart grid communications, SmartGridComm 2016
Kueck J, Kirby B, Rizy T, Li F, Fall N (2006) Reactive power from distributed energy. Electr J
Muljadi E, Ellis A (2008) Validation of wind power plant models. In: IEEE power and energy society general meeting, pp 1–7
Singh M, Santoso S (2011) Dynamic models for wind turbines and wind power plants dynamic models for wind turbines and wind power plants. Technical report May, NREL
Zhang YC, Gevorgian V, Ela E (2013) Role of wind power in primary frequency response of an interconnection preprint. In: International workshop on large-scale integration of wind power into power systems as well as on transmission networks for offshore wind power plants
Ruttledge L, Flynn D (2012) Emulated inertial response from wind turbines: the case for bespoke power system optimisation. In: International workshop on large-scale integration of wind power into power systems as well as on transmission networks for offshore wind power plants
Morren J, Pierik J, De Haana SWH (2006) Inertial response of variable speed wind turbines. Electr Power Syst Res 76(11):980–987
IRENA (2016) Wind power: technology brief. Technical report, IRENA
Syed MH, Crolla P, Burt GM, Kok JK (2015) Ancillary service provision by demand side management: a real-time power hardware-in-the-loop co-simulation demonstration. In: Smart electric distribution systems and technologies, pp 1–7
EirGrid (2016) DS3 demand side management workstream plan. Technical report May, EIRGRID
Haque ANMM, Nguyen PH, Vo TH, Bliek FW (2017) Agent-based unified approach for thermal and voltage constraint management in LV distribution network. Electr Power Syst Res 143:462–473
Zecchino A, Marinelli M (2018) Analytical assessment of voltage support via reactive power from new electric vehicles supply equipment in radial distribution grids with voltage-dependent loads. Int J Electr Power Energy Syst 97:17–27
Lu N, Weimar MR, Makarov YV, Rudolph FJ, Murthy SN, Arseneaux J (2010) An evaluation of the flywheel potential for providing regulation service in California. In: Power and energy society general meeting, pp 1–6
Mazzanti G, Marzinotto M (2013) Fundamentals of HVDC cable transmission. In: Extruded cables for high-voltage direct-current transmission: advances in research and development, chapter 2. Wiley-IEEE Press
Georgantzis GJ, Vovos NA, Giannakopoulos GB (1992) A suboptimal static controller for HVDC links supplying isolated AC networks. Electr Eng 75(6):451–458
Silva B, Moreira CL, Seca L, Phulpin Y, Peças Lopes JA (2012) Provision of inertial and primary frequency control services using offshore multiterminal HVDC networks. IEEE Trans Sustain Energy 3(4):800–808
Andreasson M, Wiget R, Dimarogonas DV, Johansson KH, Andersson G (2015) Distributed primary frequency control through multi-terminal HVDC transmission systems. In: American control conference (ACC), pp 1–6, Chicago, IL, USA
Du C, Agneholm E, Olsson G (2008) Comparison of different frequency controllers for a VSC-HVDC supplied system. IEEE Trans Power Deliv 23(4):2224–2232
Eriksson K, Graham J (2000) HVDC light a transmission vehicle with potential for ancillary services. In: VII SEPOPE-Conference, pp 1–6
ENTSO-E (2014) ENTSO-E draft network code on high voltage direct current connections and DC-connected power park modules. Technical report April, ENTSO
Phulpin Y, Ernst D (2011) Ancillary services and operation of multi-terminal HVDC systems. In: International workshop on transmission networks for offshore wind power plants as well as on transmission networks for offshore wind power farms, pp 1–6
NGK Insulators (2008) Structure of NAS energy storage system principle of NAS battery. Technical report, NGK Insulators
International Electrotechnical Commission (2015) Electrical energy storage. Technical report, IEC
US Department of Energy (2013) Grid energy storage. Technical report December, U.S. Department of Energy
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
This work is supported by the EU FP7 Project ELECTRA (Grant: 609687; http://electrairp.eu) and the Danish Research Project ELECTRA Top-up (Grant: 3594756936313).
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Rezkalla, M., Pertl, M. & Marinelli, M. Electric power system inertia: requirements, challenges and solutions. Electr Eng 100, 2677–2693 (2018). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00202-018-0739-z
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00202-018-0739-z