Abstract
In this article, we investigate the implications of the philosophical considerations presented in Nozick’s Anarchy, State, and Utopia, by examining group formation in a laboratory setting where subjects engage in both cooperative and conflictual interactions. We endow participants with a commodity used to generate earnings, plunder others, or protect against plunder. In our primary treatment, we allow participants to form groups to pool their resources. We conduct a baseline comparison treatment that does not allow group formation. We find that allowing subjects to organize themselves into groups does not lead to more cooperation and may in fact exacerbate tendencies towards conflict.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Anderson T, Hill PJ (2004) The not so wild, wild west: property rights on the frontier. Stanford University Press
Bavetta S, Peragine V (2006) Measuring autonomy freedom. Soc Choice Welf 26: 31–45
Becker G, Stigler G (1974) Law enforcement, malfeasance, and compensation of enforcers. J Leg Stud 3: 1–18
Benson B (1990) The enterprise of law: justice without the state. Pacific Research Institute for Public Policy
Buchanan J (1975) The limits of liberty. Liberty Fund, Indianapolis
Caplan B, Stringham E (2002) Networks, law, and the paradox of cooperation. Rev Austrian Econ 16: 309–326
Carter J, Anderton C (2001) An experimental test of a predator-prey model of appropriation. J Econ Behav Org 45: 83–97
Cherry T, Frykblom P, Shogren J (2002) Hardnose the dictator. Am Econ Rev 92: 1218–1221
Childs R (1977) The invisible hand strikes back. J Lib Stud 1: 22–33
Cowen T (1992) Law as a public good: the economics of anarchy. Econ Philos 8: 249–267
Duffy J, Kim M (2005) Anarchy in the laboratory (and the role of the state). J Econ Behav Org 56: 297–329
Durham Y, Hirshleifer J, Smith VL (1998) Do the rich get richer and the poor poorer? Experimental tests of a model of power. Am Econ Rev 88(4): 970–983
Ellickson R (1991) Order without law: how neighbors settle disputes. Cambridge University Press, New York
Esteban J, Sakovics J (2003) Olson vs. coase: coalitional worth in conflict. Theory Decis 55: 339–357
Fleurbaey M, Manique F (1999) Cooperative production with unequal skills: the solidarity approach to unequal production. Soc Choice Welf 16: 569–583
Friedman D (1973/1989) The machinery of freedom. Open Court Publishing Company, La Salle
Friedman D (1994) Law as a private good: a response to Tyler Cowen on the economics of anarchy. Econ Philos 10: 319–327
Grief A (1993) Contract enforceability and economic institutions in early trade: the Maghribi traders’ coalition. Am Econ Rev 83(3):525-548
Hirshleifer J (1995) Anarchy and its breakdown. J Political Econ 103(1): 26–52
Hirshleifer J (2001) The dark side of the force. Cambridge University Press, New York
Hoffman E, Spitzer M (1982) The coase theorem: some experimental tests. J Law Econ 25(1): 73–98
Hoffman E, Spitzer M (1985) Entitlements, rights, and fairness: an experimental examination of subjects’ concepts of distributive justice. J Legal Studies 14(2): 259–297
Hoffman E, McCabe K, Shachat K, Smith VL (1994) Preferences, property rights, and anonymity in bargaining games. Games Econ Behav 7: 346–380
Hume D (1740/2000) In: Norton D, Norton M (eds) A treatise of human nature. Oxford University Press, New York, NY
Kimbrough E, Smith VL, Wilson BJ (2008) Historical property rights, sociality, and the emergence of impersonal exchange in long-distance trade. Am Econ Rev 98(3): 1009–1039
Landes W, Posner R (1979) Adjudication as a private good. J Leg Stud 8: 235–284
Leeson P (2007a) One more time with feeling: the law merchant, arbitration, and international trade. Indian Jour of Econ and Bus (Special Issue):29-34
Leeson P (2007b) Trading with bandits. J Law Econ:303-321
Leeson P (2008) How important is state enforcement for trade?. Am Law and Econ Rev 10(1): 61–89
Mezzetti C (1987) Paretian efficiency, Rawlsian justice, and the Nozick theory of rights. Soc Choice Welf 4: 25–37
Miller G (1992) Managerial dilemmas. Cambridge University Press, New York
Mokyr J (1990) The lever of riches. Oxford University Press, New York
Moss L (1980) Optimal jurisdictions and the economic theory of the state: or, anarchy and one-world government are corner solutions. Public Choice 35(1): 17–26
Noh SJ (2002) Resource distribution and stable alliances with endogenous sharing rules. Eur J Political Econ 18: 129–151
Nozick R (1974) Anarchy, state and Utopia. Basic Books, New York
Ostrom V (1997) The meaning of democracy and the vulnerability of democracy: a response to Tocqueville’s challenge. University of Michigan Press, Ann Arbor
Ostrom E, Walker J (1991) Communication in a commons: cooperation without external enforcement. Laboratory Research in Political Economy, University of Michigan Press, Ann Arbor
Ostrom E, Walker J, Gardner R (1992) Covenants with and without a sword: self-governance is possible. Am Pol Sci Rev 86(2): 404–417
Powell B, Stringham E (2009) Public choice and the economic analysis of anarchy: a survey. Public Choice 140: 503–538
Powell B, Wilson BJ (2008) An experimental investigation of Hobbesian jungles. J Behav Econ Org 66(3–4): 669–686
Ridley M (1997) The origins of virtue. Viking Penguin, New York
Rothbard M (1973/2006) For a new liberty: the libertarian manifesto. Ludwig Von Mises Institute, Auburn
Schelling T (1960) The strategy of conflict. Harvard University Press
Skaperdas S (1992) Cooperation, conflict, and power in the absence of property rights. Am Econ Rev 80: 720–739
Skaperdas S (1998) On the formation of alliances in conflict and contests. Public Choice 96: 25–42
Smith VL (1982) Microeconomic systems as an experimental science. Am Econ Rev 72: 923–955
Smith VL (2002) Method in experiment: rhetoric and reality. Exp Econ 5: 91–110
Smith VL (2008) Rationality in economics: constructivist and ecological forms. Cambridge University Press, New York
Stringham E (2007) Anarchy and the law: the political economy of choice. Transaction Publishers
Sutter D (1995) Asymmetric power relations and cooperation in anarchy. South Econ J 61: 602–613
Tajfel H, Turner J (1979) An integrative theory of group conflict. In: Henri Tajfel (ed) Differentiation between social groups: studies in the social psychology of intergroup relations. Academic Press, London, pp 33–47
Tullock G (1967) The welfare cost of tariffs, monopolies, and theft. Econ Inq 5(3): 224–232
Williamson C (2009) Informal institutions rule: institutional arrangements and economic performance. Public Choice 139(3–4): 371–387
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Smith, A.C., Skarbek, D.B. & Wilson, B.J. Anarchy, groups, and conflict: an experiment on the emergence of protective associations. Soc Choice Welf 38, 325–353 (2012). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00355-011-0534-5
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00355-011-0534-5