Abstract
In the course of investigating the living world, biologists regularly attribute semantic content to the phenomena they study. In this paper, I examine the case of a contemporary research program studying the navigation behaviors of ants and develop an account of the norms governing researchers’ ascriptions of semantic content in their research practices. The account holds that researchers assign semantic content to behaviors that reliably achieve a difficult goal-directed function, and it also suggests a productive role for attributions of semantic content in the process of animal behavior research.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
Within the functions debate, some philosophers have argued the stronger claim that biological usage warrants a totally ahistorical theory of function, not just a non-etiological theory of function (Amundson and Lauder 1994; Walsh 1996, 558; Boorse 2002, 73). However, Garson (2019) has recently argued that there are no ahistorical theories of biological function on the grounds that purportedly ahistorical theories actually retain a historical dimension. Garson’s point that theories of function can reference history in nonobvious ways is well taken, and this paper addresses the question of how history figures into researchers’ ascriptions of content in “The stilts and stumps experiment justifies a goal-directed notion of function” section.
Neander (2016) concedes that Kitcher’s hybrid account of function has the potential to ground the crucial function/malfunction distinction in objective phenomena, but she critiques Kitcher’s account for leaving important questions unanswered. Namely, how are adaptive capacities assigned to trait types? Within what environmental contexts must a trait type be adaptive? And how are those trait types individuated? A major point of this paper is that researchers do not require comprehensive answers to such questions for their ascriptions of content-bearing functions to play a productive role in the development of a successful research program. Still, as the next section demonstrates, the evidential norms governing researcher’s ascriptions of content-bearing functions suggest partial answers to such questions.
Again, as with researchers’ individuation of trait types, researchers seem to lack an explicit, comprehensive account of how they individuate naturally-occurring contexts. Still, it is clear that researchers recognize the distinction between naturally-occurring and non-naturally occurring circumstances.
References
Allen C (1992) Mental content and evolutionary explanation. Biol Philos 7(1):1–12
Allen C (2017) On (not) defining cognition. Synthese 194(11):4233–4249
Allen C, Bekoff M (1997) Species of mind. MIT Press, Cambridge
Allen C, Hauser M (1991) Concept attribution in nonhuman animals: theoretical and methodological problems in ascribing complex mental processes. Philos Sci 58(2):221–240
Amundson R, Lauder G (1994) Function without purpose: the uses of causal role function in evolutionary biology. Biol Philos 9(4):443–469
Bechtel W (2016) Investigating neural representations: the tale of place cells. Synthese 193(5):1287–1321
Bechtel W, Richardson R (1992/2010) Discovering complexity: decomposition and localization as strategies in scientific research. MIT Press, Cambridge
Bergstrom C, Rosvall M (2011a) The transmission sense of information. Biol Philos 26(2):159–176
Bergstrom C, Rosvall M (2011b) Response to commentaries on ‘the transmission sense of information’. Biol Philos 26(2):195–200
Bigelow J, Pargetter R (1987) Functions. J Philos 84(4):181–196
Boorse C (1976) Wright on functions. Philos Rev 85(1):70–86
Boorse C (2002) A rebuttal on functions. In: Ariew A, Cummins R, Perlman M (eds) Functions: new essays in the philosophy of psychology and biology. Clarendon Press, New York, pp 63–112
Braithwaite R (1953) Scientific explanation: a study of the functions of theory, probability, and law in science. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Buckner C (2013) Morgan’s Canon, meet Hume’s Dictum: avoiding anthropofabulation in cross-species comparisons. Biol Philos 28(5):853–871
Burghardt G (2007) Critical anthropomorphism, uncritical anthropocentrism, and Naïve nominalism. Comp Cogn Behav Rev 2:136–138
Dennett D (1988) Out of the armchair and into the field. Poet Today 9(1):205–221
Duelli P, Wehner R (1973) The spectral sensitivity of polarized light orientation in Cataglyphis bicolor (Formicidae, Hymenoptera). J Comp Physiol A 86(1):37–53
Garson J (2019) There are no ahistorical theories of function. Philos Sci 86(5):1146–1156
Godfrey-Smith P (1993) Functions: consensus without unity. Pac Philos Q 74:196–208
Gordon D (1992) Wittgenstein and ant-watching. Biol Philos 7(1):13–25
Gould JL, Gould CG (1982) The insect mind: physics or metaphysics? In: Griffin D (ed) Animal mind—human mind. Springer, Berlin, pp 269–297
Griffiths P, Stotz K (2013) Genetics and philosophy. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Heran H, Wanke L (1952) Beobachtungen über die Entfernungsmeldung der Sammelbienen. Zeitschrift für Vergleichende Physiologie 34:383–393
Herrling P (1976) Regional distribution of three ultrastructural retinula types in the retina of Cataglyphis bicolor Fabr. (Formicidae, Hymenoptera). Cell Tissue Res 169(2):247–266
Hinde RA (1982) Ethology: its nature and relations with other sciences. Oxford University Press, New York
Kitcher P (1993) Function and Design. Midwest Stud Philos 18:379–397
Kitcher P (2016) Reply to Neander. In: Couch M, Pfeiffer J (eds) The philosophy of Phillip Kitcher. Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp 68–73
Lehner PN (1996) Handbook of ethological methods. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Lenoir A, Aron S, Cerda X, Hefetz A (2009) Cataglyphis desert ants: a good model for evolutionary biology in Darwin’s anniversary year—a review. Isr J Entomol 39:1–32
Lorenz K (1950) The comparative method in studying innate behaviour patterns. Symp Soc Exp Biol 4:221–254
Love A (2009) Typology reconfigured: from the metaphysics of essentialism to the epistemology of representation. Acta Biotheor 57(1–2):51–75
Maclaurin J (2011) Commentary on ‘The Transmission Sense of Information” by Carl T. Bergstrom and Martin Rosvall. Biol Philos 26(2):191–194
Millikan R (1989) An ambiguity in the notion ‘function’. Biol Philos 4(2):172–176
Millikan R (1990) Compare and contrast Dretske, Fodor, and Millikan on teleosemantics. Philos Top 18(2):151–161
Neander K (2016) Kitcher’s two design stances. In: Couch M, Pfeiffer J (eds) The philosophy of Phillip Kitcher. Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp 44–67
Neander K (2017) A mark of the mental: in defense of informational teleosemantics. MIT Press, Cambridge
Newen A, Bartels A (2007) Animal minds and the possession of concepts. Philos Psychol 20(3):283–308
Ronacher B (2008) Path integration as the basic navigation mechanism of the desert ant Cataglyphis fortis. Myrmecol News 11:53–62
Ronacher B, Gallizzi K, Wohlgemuth S, Wehner R (2000) Lateral optic flow does not influence distance estimation in the desert ant Cataglyphis fortis. J Exp Biol 203(7):1113–1121
Rossel S, Wehner R (1984a) Celestial orientation in bees: the use of spectral cues. J Comp Physiol A 155(5):605–613
Rossel S, Wehner R (1984b) How bees analyse the polarization patterns in the sky. J Comp Physiol A 154(5):607–615
Sarkar S (1996) Biological information: a skeptical look at some central dogmas of molecular biology. In: Sarkar S (ed) The philosophy and history of molecular biology: new perspectives. Kluwer, Dordrecht, pp 187–231
Shea N (2011) What’s transmitted? Inherited information. Biol Philos 26(2):183–189
Shea N (2018) Representation in the cognitive sciences. University of Oxford Press, Oxford
Skinner B (1977) Why I am not a cognitive psychologist. Behaviorism 5(2):1–10
Sommerhoff G (1969) The abstract characteristics of living systems. In: Emery FE (ed) Systems thinking. Penguin Books, Baltimore, pp 147–202
Steck K, Hansson BS, Knaden M (2009) Smells like home: desert ants, Cataglyphis fortis, use olfactory landmarks to pinpoint the nest. Front Zool 6(1):5
Sterner B (2014) The practical value of biological information for research. Philos Sci 81(2):175–194
Thomson E, Piccinini G (2018) Neural representations observed. Mind Mach 28(1):191–235
Tinbergen, N. (1963). On aims and methods of ethology. Zeitschrift für tierpsychologie. 20(4):410-433.
von Frisch K (1949) Die Polarisation des Himmelslichts als orientierender Faktor bei den Tänzen der Bienen. Experientia 5:142–148
Walsh D (1996) Fitness and function. Br J Philos Sci 47:553–574
Watson J (1913) Psychology as the behaviorist views it. Psychol Rev 20(2):158–177
Wehner R (1987) ‘Matched-Filters’—neural models of the external world. J Comp Physiol A 161(4):511–531
Wehner R (1997) The ant’s celestial compass system: spectral and polarization channels. In: Lehrer M (ed) Orientation and communication in arthropods. Birkhäuser, Basel, pp 145–185
Wehner R (2013) Life as a cataglyphologist—and beyond. Annu Rev Entomol 58:1–18
Wehner R (2016) Early ant trajectories: spatial behavior before behaviourism. J Comp Physiol A 202(4):247–266
Wehner R (2020) Desert navigator: the journey of the ant. Harvard University Press, Cambridge
Wehner R, Müller M (2006) The significance of direct sunlight and polarized skylight in the ant’s celestial system of navigation. Proc Natl Acad Sci 103(33):12575–12579
Wehner R, Rössler W (2013) Bounded plasticity in the desert ant’s navigational tool kit. In: Menzel R, Benjamin PR (eds) Handbook of behavioral neuroscience, vol 22. Elsevier, San Diego, pp 514–529
Wehner R, Srinivasan M (1981) Searching behaviour of desert ants, genus Cataglyphis (Formicidae, Hymenoptera). J Comp Physiol 142(3):315–338
Wehner R, Bernard G, Geiger E (1975) Twisted and non-twisted rhabdoms and their significance for polarization detection in the bee. J Comp Physiol 104(3):225–245
Wittlinger M, Wehner R, Wolf H (2006) The ant odometer: stepping on stilts and stumps. Science 312(5782):1965–1967
Wittlinger M, Wehner R, Wolf H (2007) The desert ant odometer: a stride integrator that accounts for stride length and walking speed. J Exp Biol 210(2):198–207
Wouters A (2003) Four notions of biological function. Stud Hist Philos Biol Biomed Sci 34:633–668
Wynne CD (2004) The perils of anthropomorphism. Nature 428:606
Acknowledgements
This paper has greatly benefited from feedback provided by Beckett Sterner and Steve Elliot. Alan Love, Colin Allen, Max Dresow, Yoshinari Yoshida, and Jeremy Wideman also provided helpful comments on later versions of the paper. I researched and wrote this paper while funded by the Ford Foundation’s Pre-doctoral and Dissertation Fellowships.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Dhein, K. What makes neurophysiology meaningful? Semantic content ascriptions in insect navigation research. Biol Philos 35, 52 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10539-020-09768-w
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10539-020-09768-w