Abstract
In this paper, we introduce a notion of ‘disjunctive ignorance’, which is a weak combination of two forms of ignorance in the literature. We propose a logical language with ‘disjunctive ignorance’ as a sole modality, explore the logical properties of this notion and its related notions, and axiomatize it over various frame classes. By finding suitable reduction axioms, we extend the results to the case of public announcements and apply it to Moore-like sentences.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Brogaard, B., & Salerno, J. (2019). Fitch’s paradox of knowability. In Zalta, E.N. (Ed.) The stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. Metaphysics Research Lab Stanford University Fall 2019 edition.
Brogan, A. (1967). Aristotle’s logic of statements about contingency. Mind, 76(301), 49–61.
Bromberger, S. (1992). On what we know we don’t know: explanation, theory, linguistics, and how questions shape them. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.
Cresswell, M. (1988). Necessity and contingency. Studia Logica, 47, 145–149.
del Cerro, L.F., & Herzig, A. (2011). Logics of contingency. In AAAI Spring symposium: logical formalizations of commonsense reasoning.
Driver, J. (1989). Virtues of ignorance. The Journal of Philosophy, 86, 373–384.
Driver, J. (2001). Uneasy virtue. Cambridge University Press: Cambridge.
Fan, J. (2015). Logics of essence and accident. arXiv preprint arXiv:1506.01872 unpublished manuscript.
Fan, J. (2016). Removing your ignorance by announcing group ignorance: a group announcement logic for ignorance. Studies in Logic, 9(4), 4–33.
Fan, J. (2018). Neighborhood contingency logic: a new perspective. Studies in Logic, 11(4), 37–55.
Fan, J. (2019). Bimodal logics with contingency and accident. Journal of Philosophical Logic, 48, 425–445.
Fan, J. (2019). A family of neighborhood contingency logics. Notre Dame Journal of Formal Logic, 60(4), 683–699.
Fan, J. (2019). Strong noncontingency: on the modal logics of an operator expressively weaker than necessity. Notre Dame Journal of Formal Logic, 60(3), 407–435.
Fan, J. (2019). Symmetric contingency logic with unlimitedly many modalities. Journal of Philosophical Logic, 48(5), 851–866.
Fan, J., & van Ditmarsch, H. (2015). Neighborhood contingency logic. In Banerjee, M., & Krishna, S. (Eds.) Logic and its application, volume 8923 of Lecture Notes in Computer Science (pp. 88–99): Springer.
Fan, J., Wang, Y., & van Ditmarsch, H. (2014). Almost necessary. In Advances in modal logic, (Vol. 10 pp. 178–196).
Fan, J., Wang, Y., & van Ditmarsch, H. (2015). Contingency and knowing whether. The Review of Symbolic Logic, 8(1), 75–107.
Fine, K. (2018). Ignorance of ignorance. Synthese, 195, 4031–4045. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11229-017-1406-z.
Firestein, S. (2012). Ignorance: how it drives science. Oxford University Press.
Fitch, F.B. (1963). A logical analysis of some value concepts. The Journal of Symbolic Logic, 28(2), 135–142.
Flanagan, O. (1990). Virtue and ignorance. The Journal of Philosophy, 87(8), 420–428.
Gilbert, D., & Venturi, G. (2017). Neighborhood semantics for logics of unknown truths and false beliefs. The Australasian Journal of Logic, 14(1), 246–267.
Gilbert, D.R., & Venturi, G. (2016). Reflexive-insensitive modal logics. The Review of Symbolic Logic, 9(1), 167–180.
Goldman, A., & Olsson, E. (2009). Reliabilism and the value of knowledge. In Haddock, A., Millar, A., & Pritchard, D. (Eds.) Epistemic value (pp. 19–41). Oxford University Press: Oxford.
Gulley, N. (1968). The philosophy of socrates.
Hintikka, J. (1962). Knowledge and belief. Cornell University Press, Ithaca, NY.
Humberstone, L. (1995). The logic of non-contingency. Notre Dame Journal of Formal Logic, 36(2), 214–229.
Humberstone, L. (2002). The modal logic of agreement and noncontingency. Notre Dame Journal of Formal Logic, 43(2), 95–127.
Humberstone, L. (2013). Zolin and Pizzi: defining necessity from noncontingency. Erkenntnis, 78, 1275–1302.
Konolige, K. (1982). Circumscriptive ignorance. In AAAI (pp. 202–204).
Kubyshkina, E., & Petrolo, M. (2019). A logic for factive ignorance. Synthese, 1–12.
Kuhn, S. (1995). Minimal non-contingency logic. Notre Dame Journal of Formal Logic, 36(2), 230–234.
Kyle, B.G. (2015). The new and old ignorance puzzles: how badly do we need closure? Synthese, 192(5), 1–31.
Marcos, J. (2005). Logics of essence and accident. Bulletin of the Section of Logic, 34(1), 43–56.
Montgomery, H., & Routley, R. (1966). Contingency and non-contingency bases for normal modal logics. Logique et Analyse, 9, 318–328.
Moore, G.E. (1942). A reply to my critics. In Schilpp, P.A. (Ed.) The philosophy of G.E. Moore. The Library of Living Philosophers (volume 4) (pp. 535–677). Evanston: Northwestern University.
Le Morvan, P. (2011). Knowledge, ignorance, and true belief. Theoria, 77(1), 32–41.
Le Morvan, P. (2011). On ignorance: a reply to Peels. Philosophia, 39(2), 335–344.
Le Morvan, P. (2012). On ignorance: a vindication of the standard view. Philosophia, 40(2), 379–393.
Le Morvan, P. (2013). Why the standard view of ignorance prevails. Philosophia, 41(1), 239–256.
Olsson, E.J., & Proietti, C. (2015). Explicating ignorance and doubt: a possible worlds approach. The Epistemic Dimensions of Ignorance.
Peels, R. (2010). What is ignorance? Philosophia, 38, 57–67.
Peels, R. (2011). Ignorance is lack of true belief: a rejoinder to Le Morvan. Philosophia, 39(2), 344–355.
Peels, R. (2012). The new view on ignorance undefeated. Philosophia, 40, 741–750.
Pizzi, C. (1999). Contingency logics and propositional quantifications. Manuscrito, 22, 283–303.
Pizzi, C. (2006). A logic of contingency with a propositional constant. Logic and Philosophy in Italy, 141–154.
Pizzi, C. (2007). Necessity and relative contingency. Studia Logica, 85(3), 395–410.
Plaza, J. (1989). Logics of public communications. In Proc. of the 4th ISMIS (pp. 201–216): Oak Ridge National Laboratory.
Shoham, Y. (1986). Chronological ignorance. In Proceedings of the fifth national conference on artificial intelligence (pp. 389–393).
Steinsvold, C. (2008). Completeness for various logics of essence and accident. Bulletin of the Section of Logic, 37(2), 93–101.
Steinsvold, C. (2008). A note on logics of ignorance and borders. Notre Dame Journal of Formal Logic, 49(4), 385–392.
Steinsvold, C. (2011). The boxdot conjecture and the language of essence and accident. Australasian Journal of Logic, 10, 18–35.
Unger, P. (1975). Ignorance: a case for skepticism. Oxford University Press: Oxford.
van der Hoek, W., & Lomuscio, A. (2003). Ignore at your peril - towards a logic for ignorance. In Proc. of 2nd AAMAS (pp. 1148–1149): ACM.
van der Hoek, W., & Lomuscio, A. (2004). A logic for ignorance. Electronic Notes in Theoretical Computer Science, 85(2), 117–133.
van Ditmarsch, H., van der Hoek, W., & Kooi, B. (2007). Dynamic epistemic logic, volume 337 of Synthese Library. Springer.
Vlastos, G. (1985). Socrates’ disavowal of knowledge. The Philosophical Quarterly.
Zimmerman, M. (2008). Living with uncertainty: the moral significance of ignorance. Cambridge University Press.
Zolin, E. (1999). Completeness and definability in the logic of noncontingency. Notre Dame Journal of Formal Logic, 40(4), 533–547.
Zolin, E. (2001). Infinitary expressibility of necessity in terms of contingency. Proceedings of the Sixth ESSLLI Student Session, 325–334.
Zolin, E. (2002). Sequential reflexive logics with noncontingency operator. Mathematical Notes, 72(6), 784–798. (translation from Matematicheskie Zametki, Russian Academy of Sciences).
Acknowledgements
This research is supported by the project 17CZX053 of National Social Science Fundation of China. The author would like to thank two anonymous referees and the editor Reinhard Muskens of this journal for their invaluable comments, which help improve the paper substantially.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Publisher’s Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Fan, J. A Logic for Disjunctive Ignorance. J Philos Logic 50, 1293–1312 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10992-021-09599-4
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10992-021-09599-4