In 2013, Surgical Neurology International published a protocol for the GEMINI procedure, the world’s first human head transplant surgery. With the assumption that head transplants are possible in the future, we introduce a legal thought experiment that calls the current criteria of death under the United States UDDA into question. Utilizing case law and examples of contemporary medical interventions, we analyze how neurological and circulatory systems can be reversed and challenge the UDDA criteria of death. We favor the definition of death that includes the irreversibility of the brain and brainstem, but recommend the Uniform Law Commission strike irreversible respiratory and circulatory functions as indicators of death. We also recommend that a congressional bill should be proposed for the definition of death, allowing Article Six to supersede the current legal landscape.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Uniform Law Commission. “Legislative Fact Sheet – Determination of Death Act,” https://www.uniformlaws.org/HigherLogic/System/DownloadDocumentFile.ashx?DocumentFileKey=341343fa-1efe-706c-043a-9290fdcfd909&forceDialog=0. (1980).
D. Barmakian, “Uniform Laws and Model Acts,” Harvard Law School Library. https://guides.library.harvard.edu/law/unifmodelacts. (2018).
Uniform Law Commission. “Determination of Death Act,” https://www.uniformlaws.org/committees/community-home?CommunityKey=155faf5d-03c2-4027-99ba-ee4c99019d6c. (2019).
S. Canavero, “HEAVEN: The head anastomosis venture Project outline for the first human head transplantation with spinal linkage (GEMINI),” Surg. Neurol. Int., 4, Suppl. 1, 335–342 (2013).
X. Ren and S. Canavero, “Human head transplantation. Where do we stand and a call to arms,” Surg. Neurol. Int.,7, 11 (2016).
C. C. Guthrie, Blood Vessel Surgery and Its Applications, UK Arnold, London (1912).
M. Roach, The Curious Lives of Human Cadavers, WW Norton and Company, New York (2004).
R. J. White, “Hypothermic preservation and transplantation of brain,” Resuscitation,4, No. 3, 197–210 (1975)
R. J. White, L. R. Wolin, L. C. Massopust Jr, et al., “Primate cephalic transplantation: neurogenic separation, vascular association,” Transplant. Proc., 3, No. 1, 602–604 (1971).
F. L. Delmonico, “The concept of death and deceased organ donation,” Int. J. Organ Transplant. Med., 1, No. 1, 15–20 (2010).
W. H. Sweet, “Brain death,” N. Engl. J. Med., 299, No. 8, 410–412 (1978).
Fonseca v. Smith; Life Legal Defense Foundation, Plaintiffs, v Karen Smith, M.D., No. 2 16-cv-00889-KJM-EFB; E.D. Cal (2017).
Fonseca v Kaiser Permanente Med. Ctr. Roseville; 222 F. Supp. 3d 850; E.D. Cal (2016).
H. C. Black, Black’s Law Dictionary (4th Edition), West Publishing Company, Minnesota (1951).
H. K. Beecher, “A definition of irreversible coma. Report of the Ad Hoc Committee of the Harvard Medical School to examine the definition of brain death,” JAMA, 205, No. 6, 337–340 (1968).
B. A. Garner, Black’s Law Dictionary (11th Edition), Thomson Reuters, Ontario (2019).
C. Pallis, On the Brainstem Criterion of Death, The Johns Hopkins University Press, Maryland, pp. 93–100 (1999).
C. Shamlin, Defining Death: A Report on the Medical, Legal and Ethical Issues in the Determination of Death, U.S. Government Printing Office (1981).
In re Bowman; In the Matter of the Welfare of William Matthew Bowman, 617 P.2d 731; 94 Wash. 407 (1980).
L. C. Griffin, and J. H. Krause, Practicing Bioethics Law, West Academic, Minnesota, pp. 524-528 (2016).
B. Nipper, “Legislating death: A review and proposed refinement of the uniform determination of death act,” Houston. J. Health Law Policy,17, 429 (2017).
In re Guardianship of Hailu; In the Matter of Guardianship of Person and Estate of Hailu, 131 Nev. Adv. Op. 89 (2015).
C. E. Wasmuth Jr., “The concept of death,” Ohio State Law J., 30, 32 (1969).
J. L. Bernat, C. M. Culver, and B. Gert, “Defining death in theory and practice,” Hastings Cent. Rep., 12, No. 1, 5–8 (1982).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Choi, P., Pirzada, N. How Human Head Transplantation Could Alter the Legal Definition of Death. Neurophysiology 52, 89–92 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11062-020-09855-4
Received:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11062-020-09855-4