Abstract
The declining availability of grazing land and the increasing prices of commercial dairy feed threaten the sustainability of traditional smallholder livestock farmer (SLF) practices across sub-Saharan Africa. Fodder tree technology (FTT), an agroforestry approach that entails the cultivation of multipurpose fodder trees on farmlands, could help address such challenges. However, the adoption rate of FTT has been low, especially in Malawi, where dairy processing plants usually operate at 20% capacity and milk consumption is less than half the African average. This paper investigates the role of 20 possible determinants of FTT adoption. It uses binary logistic regression to analyze primary data collected through two extensive household surveys conducted during the Agroforestry Food Security Program (AFSP) in different regions of Malawi. This data is complemented with qualitative information extracted through in-depth interviews with SLF. The general lack of knowledge regarding FTT was identified as the largest constraint to adoption. It was further confounded by other factors such as the lack of market access, inconsistent emphasis of training organizations during extension efforts, gender disparities, poor land quality, and issues of land tenure. The “extension environment” created by the AFSP influenced the perceptions of SLF for some adoption determinants. In particular it reduced the influence of sociological and geographic factors such as relationships with lead farmers, and shifted financial focus from the cost and availability of inputs, to the means of capitalizing on outputs (such as market access). This improved FTT adoption by 53% overall. Some suggestions for future extension efforts on how to improve the perceptions of the expected utility of FTT include the careful evaluation of farmer-led extension models, assurance of seed supply, and the consideration of institutional/sociological factors in project design. Examples of such factors include divorce rates, conflicts between formal and customary laws/rules, and infrastructure.
Similar content being viewed by others
Abbreviations
- AFSP:
-
Agroforestry Food Security Program
- BLA:
-
Binary logistic regression
- CIE:
-
Center for independent evaluations
- FTT:
-
Fodder tree technology
- SLF:
-
Smallholder livestock farmer
- ICRAF:
-
World agroforestry centre
References
Adesina AA, Chianu J (2002) Determinants of farmers’ adoption and adaptation of alley farming technology in Nigeria. Agrofor Syst 55(2):99–112
Ajayi OC, Akinnifesi FK, Mullila-Mitti J, DeWolf JJ, Matakala PW, Kwesiga FR (2008) Adoption, profitability, impacts and scaling-up of agroforestry technologies in Sourthern African countries. In: Batish D, Kohli R, Jose S, Singh H (eds) Ecological basis of agroforestry. CRC Press, Boca Raton, pp 344–357
Ajayi OC, Akinnifesi FK, Sileshi GW, Mn’gomba S, Place F, Gondwe F, Chaula K (2010) Report of the baseline survey of agroforestry food security programme (AFSP) districts of Malawi. ICRAF, Lilongwe
Akinnifesi FK (2010) Agroforestry food security programme (AFSP) in Malawi. ICRAF, Lilongwe
Alavalapati JRR, Luckert MK, Gill DS (1995) Adoption of agroforestry practices: a case study from Andhra Pradesh, India. Agrofor Syst 32(1):1–14
Allison P (2012) When can you safely ignore multicollinearity? Retrieved from statistical horizons. http://statisticalhorizons.com/multicollinearity. Accessed 15 Feb 2017
Ayuk ET (1997) Adoption of agroforestry technology: the case of live hedges in the Central Plateau of Burkina Faso. Agric Syst 54(2):189–206
Bach A (2012) Nourishing and managing the dam and postnatal calf for optimal lactation, reproduction, and immunity. J Anim Sci 90(6):1835–1845
Baidu-Forson J (1999) Factors influencing adoption of land-enhancing technology in the Sahel: lessons from a case study in Niger. Agric Econ 20(3):231–239
Banda LJ, Kamwanja LA, Chagunda MG, Ashworth CJ, Roberts DJ (2012) Status of dairy cow management and fertility in smallholder farms in Malawi. Trop Anim Health Prod 44(4):715–727
Batz FJ, Peters KJ, Janseen W (1999) The influence of technology characteristics on the rate and speed of adoption. Agric Econ 21(2):121–130
Benson T, Mabiso A, Nankhuni F (2016) Detailed crop suitability maps and an agricultural zonation scheme for Malawi: spatial information for agricultural planning purposes. Food Security Policy Innovation Lab Research Paper 17. East Lansing, MI: Michigan State University and International Food Policy Research Institute
Bernet T, Oritz O, Estrada RD, Quiroz R, Swinton SM (2001) Tailoring agricultural extension to different production contexts: a user-friendly farmhousehold model to improve decision-making for participatory research. Agric Syst 69(3):183–198
Blatner KA, Bonongwe CSL, Carroll MS (2000) Adopting agroforestry: evidence from Central and Northern Malawi. J Sustain For 11(3):41–69
Bohringer A, Ayuk E, Katanga R, Ruvuga S (2003) Farmer nurseries as a catalyst for developing sustainable land use systems in southern Africa. Part A: nursery productivity and organization. Agric Syst 77:187–201
Brazys S, Heaney P, Walsh PP (2015) Fertilizer and votes: does strategic economic policy explain the 2009 Malawi election? Elect Stud 39:39–55
Chakeredza S, Hove L, Akinnifesi FK, Franzel S, Ajayi OC, Sileshi G (2007) Managing fodder trees as a solution to human-livestock food conflicts and their contribution to income generation for smallholder farmers in Southern Africa. Nat Resour Forum 31(4):286–296
Changunda MGG, Gondwe TN, Banda L, Mayuni P, Mtimuni JP, Chimbaza T, Nikwanda A (2011) Smallholder dairy production in Malawi: current status and future solutions. Scottish Agricultural College (International Development Fund), Lilongwe
Cherchye L, De Rock B, Walther ST, Vermeulen F (2016) Where did it go wrong? Marriage and divorce in Malawi. Ku Leuven Department of Economics Discussion Paper Series March 2016
Chirwa E (2008) Land tenure, farm investments, and food production in Malawi. IPPG Discussion Paper Series 18: 1–22. Research Consortium on Improving Institutions for Pro-Poor Growth, London
Chirwa E, Dorward A, Matita M (2012) Thinking about ‘Graduation’ from the farm input subsidy programme in Malawi. ICRAF, Nairobi
C.I.E. (2011) Evaluation of ICRAF’s Agroforestry Food Security Program (AFSP) 2007–2011. Center for Independent Evaluations, Lilongwe
DAHLD (2005) Policy document on Livestock in Malawi. Agriculture Communication Branch, Ministry of Agriculture, Malawi
Dawson IK, Carsan S, Franzel S, Kindt R, van Breugel P, Graudal L, Lillesø J-PB, Orwa C, Jamnadass R (2014) Agroforestry, livestock, fodder production and climate change adaptation and mitigation in East Africa: issues and options. ICRAF Working Paper No. 178. Nairobi, World Agroforestry Centre
De Wolf JJ (2010) Innovative farmers, non-adapting institutions: a case study of the organization of agroforestry research in Malawi. In: German L, Ramisch JJ, Verma R (eds) Beyond the biophysical: knowledge, culture, and power in agriculture and natural resource management. Springer, London, pp 217–239
Degrande A, Franzel S, Yeptiep YS, Asaah E, Tsobeng A, Tchoundjeu Z (2012) Effectiveness of grassroots organisations in the dissemination of agroforestry innovation. In: Kaonga M (ed) Agroforestry for biodiversity and ecosystem services—science and practice. INTECH, Rijeka, pp 141–164
Dionne KY, Horowitz J (2013) The political effects of anti-poverty initiatives: an analysis of malawi’s agricultural input subsidy program. Paper presented at the Midwest Group in African Political Economy Meeting. Indians University, Bloomington
Doss CR (2003) Understanding farm level technology adoption: lessons learned from CIMMYT’s micro surveys in Eastern Africa. CIMMYT Economics Working Paper 03–07, Mexico City
Douglas M (1985) Risk acceptance according to the social sciences. Russel Sage Foundation, New York
ECA (2004) Land tenure systems and their impacts on food security and sustainable development in Africa. Economic Commission for Africa, Addis Ababa
Feder G, Anderson JR, Birner R, Deininger K (2010) Promises and realities of community-based agricultural extension. International Food Policy Research Institute, Washington DC
Franzel S (2004) Financial analysis of agroforestry practices: fodder shrubs in Kenya, woodlots in Tanzania, and improved fallows in Zambia. In: Alavalapati JRR, Mercer DE (eds) Valuing agroforestry systems: methods and applications. Advances in agroforestry 2. Kluwer Academic Publishing, London, pp 9–37
Franzel S, Scherr SJ (2002) Introduction. In: Franzel S, Scherr S (eds) Trees on the farm: assessing the adoption potential of agroforestry practices in Africa. CABI, Wallingford
Franzel S, Wambugu C (2007) The uptake of fodder shrubs among smallholders in East Africa: key elements that facilitate widespread adoption. In: Hare M, Wongpichet K (eds) Forages: a pathway to prosperity for smallholder farmers. Ubon Ratchathani University, Ratchathani, pp 203–222
Franzel S, Wambugu C, Tuwei P (2003) The adoption and dissemination of fodder shrubs in central Kenya. Agricultural Research and Extension Network (AgREN). Network paper No. 131
Franzel S, Carsan S, Lukuyu B, Sinja B, Sinja J, Wambugu C (2014) Fodder trees for improving livestock productivity and smallholder livelihoods in Africa. Curr Opin Environ Sustain 6(1):98–103
Franzel S, Degrande A, Kiptot E, Kirui J, Kugonza J, Preissing J, Simpson B (2015) Farmer-to-farmer extension. Note 7. GFRAS good practice notes for extension and advisory services. Global Forum for Rural Advisory Services, Lindau
German G, Akinnifesi FK, Edriss AK, Sileshi GW, Masangano C, Ajayi OC (2009) Influences of property rights on farmer’s willingness to plant indigenous fruit trees in Malawi and Zambia. Afr J Agric Res 4(5):427–437
Giger M, Liniger H, Sauter C, Schwilch G (2015) Economic benefits and costs of sustainable land management technologies: an analysis of WOCAT’s global data. Land Degrad Dev 1–13. doi:10.1002/ldr.2429
Gould B, Saupe W, Klemme R (1989) ConservationTillage: the role of farm and operator characteristics and the perception of soil erosion. Land Econ 65(2):167–182
Gurung B (2010) Framing participation in agricultural and natural resource management research. In: German L, Ramisch JJ, Verma R (eds) Beyond the biophysical: knowledge, culture, and power in agriculture and natural resource management. Springer, London, pp 241–256
ICRAF (2016) Species profiles, world agroforestry database. http://www.worldagroforestry.org/treedb2/speciesprofile.php?Spid=1069. Accessed 19 Jan 2016
Jamison DT, Moock PR (1984) Farmer education and farm efficiency in Nepal: the role of schooling, extension services and cognitive skills. World Dev 12(1):67–86
Jayne TS, Chamberlin J, Headey DD (2014) Land pressures, the evolution of farming systems, and development strategies in Africa: a synthesis. Food Policy 48:1–17
Kabirizi J (2009) Integrating Calliandra calothyrsus trees in smallholder crop-livestock farming systems: effect on milk yield and household income. Unpublished paper presented at the second World Congress on Agroforestry, Nairobi
Kebreab E, Smith T, Tanner J, Osuji P (2005) Review of under nutrition in smallholder ruminant production systems in the tropics. In: Ayantunde AA, Fernandez-Rivera S, McGrabb G (eds) Coping with feed scarcity in smallholder livestock systems in developing countries. Int’l Livestock Research Institute, Nairobi, pp 3–96
Kindt R, John I, Ordonez J, Smith E, Orwa C, Mosoti B, Chege J, Dawson I, Harja D, Kehlenbeck K, Luedeling E, Lillesø J-PB, Muchugi A, Munjuga M, Mwanzia L, Sinclair F, Graudal L, Jamnadass R (2016) Agroforestry species switchboard: a synthesis of information sources to support tree research and development activities. Version 1.3. World Agroforestry Centre, Nairobi, Kenya. http://www.worldagroforestry.org/output/agroforestree-database. Accessed 11 Oct 2016
Kiptot E, Franzel S (2011) Gender and agroforestry in Africa: are women participating? ICRAF Occasional Paper No. 13. World Agroforestry Centre, Nairobi
Kiptot E, Franzel S (2014) Voluntarism as an investment in human, social and financial capital: evidence from a farmer-to-farmer extension program in Kenya. Agric Hum Values 31(2):231–243
Kiptot E, Hebinck P, Franzel S, Richards P (2007) Adopters, testers or pseudo-adopters? Dynamics of the use of improved tree fallows by farmers in western Kenya. Agric Syst 94(2):509–519
Kwesiga F, Akinnifesi FK, Mafongoya PL, McDermott MH, Agumya A (2003) Agroforestry research and development in southern Africa during the 1990s: review and challenges ahead. Agrofor Syst 59(3):173–186
Makoka D, Ajayi OC, Phiri A, Gama S, Phula M, Dakamau M, Kambauwa G, Mkwinda S, Jumbe C, Kayuni F (2010) Agroforestry policy working group 2010 review of natural resources management policies in Malawi: an overview of findings. World Agroforestry Centre (ICRAF), Zomba, Malawi, p 42
Marra M, Pannell DJ, Ghadim AA (2003) The economics of risk, uncertainty and learning in the adoption of new agricultural technologies: where are we on the teaming curve? Agric Syst 75(2):215–234
Meijer SS, Catacutan D, Ajayi OC, Sileshi GW, Nieuwenhuis M (2015) The role of knowledge, attitudes and perceptions in the uptake of agricultural and agroforestry innovations among smallholder farmers in sub-Saharan Africa. Int J Agric Sustain 13(1):40–54
Mercer DE (2004) Adoption of agroforestry innovations in the tropics: a review. Agrofor Syst 61(1):311–328
Mercer DE, Pattanayak SK (2010) Agroforestry adoption by smallholders. In: Sills E, Abt K (eds) Forests in a market economy. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, pp 283–299
Mignouna B, Manyong M, Rusike J, Mutabazi S, Senkondo M (2011) Determinants of adopting Imazapyr-resistant maize technology and its impact on household income in Western Kenya. AgBioforum 14(3):158–163
Mloza-Banda H (2005) Integrating new trends in farming systems approaches in Malawi. Afr Crop Sci Conf Proc 7:961–966
Mpofu IDT (2005) Coping with feed scarcity in Zimbabwe: causes and consequences of undernutrition. In: Ayantunde AA, Fernandez-Rivera S, McGrabb G (eds) Coping with feed scarcity in smallholder livestock systems in developing countries. International Livestock Research Institute, Nairobi, pp 121–129
Muraguri GR, McLeed A, Taylor N (2004) Estimation of milk production from smallholder dairy cattle in the coastal lowlands of Kenya. Trop Anim Health Prod 36(7):673–684
Nair PKR (1993) An introduction to agroforestry. Kluwer Academic, Dordrecht
Nair PKR, Toth GG (2016) Measuring agricultural sustainability in agroforestry systems. In: Lal R, Kraybill D, Hansen DO, Singh BR, Mosogoya T, Eik LO (eds) Climate change and multi-dimensional sustainability in African agriculture. Springer International Publishing, Cham, pp 365–394
Ngwira A, Johnsen FH, Aune JB, Mekuria M, Thierfelder C (2014) Adoption and extent of conservation agriculture practices among smallholder farmers in Malawi. J Soil Water Conserv 69(2):107–119
NORAD (2014) Malawi—National Census of Agriculture and Livestock 2006–2007. (Norwegian Agency for Development Cooperation), International Household Survey Network. http://catalog.ihsn.org/index.php/catalog/4578. Accessed 14 Feb 2017
Oino P, Mugure A (2013) Farmer-oriented factors that influence adoption of agroforestry practices in Kenya: experiences from Nambale District, Busia County. Int J Sci Res 2(4):450–456
Pattanayak SK, Mercer DE, Sills E, Yang JC (2003) Taking stock of agroforestry adoption studies. Agrofor Syst 57(3):173–186
Place F (2009) Land tenure and agricultural productivity in africa: a comparative analysis of the economics literature and recent policy strategies and reforms. World Dev 37(8):1326–1336
Place F, Otsuka K (2001) Tenure, agricultural investment, and productivity in the customary tenure sector of Malawi. Econ Dev Cult Change 50(1):77–99
Place F, Adato M, Hebinck P, Omosa M (2005) The impact of agroforestry-based soil fertility replenishment practices on the poor in western Kenya. Washington/Nairobi: International Food policy Research Institute in Collaboration with the World Agroforestry Centre. Research Report No. 142
Place F, Roothaert R, Maina L, Franzel S, Sinja J, Wanjiku J (2009) The impact of fodder trees on milk production and income amoung smallholder dairy farmers in East Africa and the role of research. ICRAF, Nairobi
Polson RA, Spencer DSC (1992) The technology adoption process in subsistence agriculture: the case of Cassava in South-western Nigeria. Agric Syst 36(1):65–78
Poppy GM, Jepson PC, Pickett JA, Birkett MA (2014) Achieving food and environmental security: new approaches to close the gap. Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci 369:1639–1645
Reniers G (2003) Divorce and remarriage in rural Malawi. Demogr Res 1(1):175–206
Revoredo-Giha C, Arakelyan I, Chalmers N (2015) Processors pricing and smallholders’ milk supply response in Malawi: an application of the nonlinear autoregressive distributed lag model. Agriculture in an Interconnected World. International Conference of Agricultural Economists 9–14 August 2015, Milano
Roothaert RL, Franzel S, Kiura M (2003) On-farm evaluation of fodder trees and shrubs preferred by farmers in central Kenya. Exp Agric 39:423–440
Rukkwansuk T (2011) Effect of nutrition on reproductive performance of postparturient dairy cows in the tropics: a review. Thai J Vet Med 1:3–107
Shideed KH (2005) Theoretical framework for assessing adoption and impact of improved technologies. In: Shideed KH, Mourid ME (eds) Adoption and impact assessment of improved technologies in crop and livestock production systems in the WANA region. International Center for Agricultural Research in the Dry Areas, Aleppo, pp 1–30
Sirrine D, Shennan C, Sirrine JR (2010) Comparing agroforestry systems’ ex ante adoption potential and ex post adoption: on-farm participatory research from southern Malawi. Agrofor Syst 79(2):253–266
Sitko NJ, Jayne TS (2014) Structural transformation or elite land capture? The growth of “emergent” farmers in Zambia. Food Policy 48:194–202
Stern PC (2000) Toward a coherent theory of environmentally significant behavior. J Soc Issues 56(3):407–424. doi:10.1111/0022-4537.00175
Takane T (2009) Disparities and diversities among female-headed households in rural Malawi after 20 years of economic liberalization. Singap J Trop Geogr 30(3):358–372
Tebug SF, Chikagwa-Malunga S, Wiedeman S (2012a) On-farm evaluation of dairy farming innovations uptake in northern Malawi. Livest Res Rural Dev 24(5):1–9
Tebug SF, Kasulo V, Chikagwa-Malunga S, Wiedemann S, Roberts DJ, Chagunda MG (2012b) Smallholder dairy production in Northern Malawi: production practices and constraints. Trop Anim Health 44(1):55–62. doi:10.1007/s11250-011-9887-0
Thangata P, Alavapati JPR (2003) Agroforestry adoption in Southern Malawi: a case study of Gliricidia sepium and Maize. Agric Syst 78(1):57–71
Thorpe WR, Mullins G, Reynolds L, Maloo SH, Muinga RW, Mureithi J, Njuni M, Ramadhan A (1993) Research on smallholder dairy production in coastal lowland Kenya. In: Future of livestock industries in East and Southern Africa. International Livestock Centre for Africa, Addis Ababa, pp 33–45
Toth GG (2016) Evaluation of factors influencing agroforestry adoption: case studies from Malawi. Doctoral Dissertation, University of Florida
UNICEF (2013) Improving child nutrition: the achievable imperatives for global progress. UNICEF, New York
UNPD (2015) Department of Economic and Social Affairs, United Nations Population Division. http://esa.un.org/unpd/wpp/DataQuery/. Accessed 24 Dec 2015
Useche P, Bradford BL, Foltz JD (2012) Trait based adoption models using ex-ante and ex-post approaches. Am J Agric Econ 44:1–7
van Raaji F (2002) Implicit expected utility theory for decision making and choice. APAC Adv Consum Res 5:343–348
Wambugu C, Franzel S, Cordero J, Stewart J (2006) Fodder shrubs for dairy farmers in East Africa: making extension decisions and putting them into practice. World Agroforestry Centre, Nairobi
Wambugu C, Place F, Franzel S (2011) Research and development and scaling up the adoption of fodder shrub innovations in East Africa. Int J Agric Sustain 9(1):100–109
Wanyoike FN (2005) Dissemination and adoption of improved fodder trees: the case of Calliandra calothyrsus in Embu District, Kenya. Dissertation, University of Nairobi
Ward PS, Bell AR, Parkhurst GM, Droppelmann K, Mapemba L (2016) Heterogeneous preferences and the effects of incentives in promoting conservation agriculture in Malawi. Agric Ecosyst Environ 222:67–79
Wejnert B (2002) Integrating models of diffusion of innovations: a conceptual framework. Annu Rev Sociol 28:297–326
World Bank (2007) Agriculture for development. IBRD, Washington DC
Zerihun MF, Muchie M, Worku Z (2014) Determinants of agroforestry technologyadoption in Eastern Cape Province, South Africa. Dev Stud Res 1(1):382–394
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Handled by Alexandros Gasparatos, The University of Tokyo, Japan.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Toth, G.G., Nair, P.K.R., Duffy, C.P. et al. Constraints to the adoption of fodder tree technology in Malawi. Sustain Sci 12, 641–656 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11625-017-0460-2
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11625-017-0460-2