Abstract
For decades, the promise of refractory alloys (robust structural materials for use above 1500 K (1200 °C)) has been hampered by concurrent requirements for fabricability via ingot metallurgy and oxidation resistance. These constraints have thus far proven impossible to meet in a single material. The work herein demonstrates that the advent of economical powder feedstocks and consolidation methods, such as additive manufacturing (AM), effectively removes the constraints preventing widespread utilization of high-strength refractory alloys into aerospace, defense, and space access applications. High-purity, spherical refractory-alloy powders (e.g. the Nb-10Hf-1Ti alloy ATI C103™) were made via both atomization and plasma spheroidization and consolidated using a variety of methods. Consolidated material shows comparable and sometimes superior high temperature performance to equivalent wrought material. The availability of cost-effective powder synthesis techniques enables the elimination of critical barriers in fabrication: namely the requirement for hot and cold working. The availability of AM and hot isostatic pressing expands the design space for high-strength refractory alloys and makes the adoption of new paradigms in alloy design, such as refractory complex concentrated alloys, plausible. Going forward, the most difficult challenge, oxidation, can be tackled with the new approaches that are now available.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
The C103 alloy, comprising Nb-10Hf-1Ti, was the third “Cb” alloy in an extensive alloy development campaign by ATI (then Wah Chang) and Boeing from 1959-1967 that included Mo, W, Ta and Nb alloys.
Castheon, Inc., Thousand Oaks, CA.
N.B. Niobium alloys are Class I solid solutions wherein creep rate is dominated by dislocation glide and thus is insensitive to grain size.[113] Unfortunately, there is then no obvious performance benefit to achieving the directionally solidified structure in creep dominated high temperature service.
References
T.A. Moss, R.L. Davies, and G.J. Barna: in Report No. NASA-SP-245, NASA, Cleveland, OH, 1970.
R.A. Perkins and G.H. Meier: JOM, 1990, vol. 42, pp. 17–21.
R.E. Engler: Atomic Power in Space: A History, Washington, DC, 1987.
R.A. Perkins: Proc. Symp. Adv. Compact React. Syst., 1983, pp. 282–325.
V.G. Grigorovich and E.N. Sheftel: Metal Science and Heat Treatment, 1982, vol. 24, pp. 472–8.
R.W. Buckman: JOM, 2000, vol. 52, pp. 40–1.
L. Schweikart: The Hypersonic Revolution - Case Studies in the History of Hypersonic Technology - Volume III - The Quest for the Orbital Jet: The National Aero-Space Plane Program, Vol. 3, Air Force History and Museums Program, Bolling AFB, 1998.
W.B. Gero: in Control of Crystal Development in Refractory Metals US 1602526, United States Patent and Trademark Office, USA, 1926.
Z. Jeffries: Trans. AIME, 1924, vol. 70, p. 303.
T.E. Tietz and J.W. Wilson: Behavior and Properties of Refractory Metals, Standford University Press, Standford, CA, 1965.
J.R. Hughes: in Materials Research Society Symposium Proceedings, vol. 322, 1994, pp. 363–75.
E.A. Loria: JOM, 1987, vol. 39, pp. 22–6.
J. Wittenauer: JOM, 1990, vol. 42, pp. 7–7.
D.C. Goldberg, G. Dicker, and S.A. Worcester: Nuclear Engineering and Design, 1972, vol. 22, pp. 124–37.
T.G. Nieh and J. Wadsworth: in MRS Proceedings, vol. 322, 1993, p. 315.
R. Smith: Journal of The Less-Common Metals, 1960, vol. 2, pp. 191–206.
J. Wadsworth, T.G. Nieh, and J.J. Stephens: International Materials Reviews, 1988, vol. 33, pp. 131–50.
R.G. Frank: in Refractory Metal Alloys Metallurgy and Technology, I. Machlin, R.T. Begley, and E.D. Weisert, eds., Springer, Boston, MA, 1968, pp. 325–72.
J.J. Harwood: in The Metal Molybdenum, J. Hardwood, Julius, ed., American Society for Metals, Detroit, Michigan, 1958, pp. 420–59.
I.L. Shabalin: in Ultra-High Temperature Materials I, Springer Netherlands, Dordrecht, 2014, pp. 531–607.
R.E. Bedford, G. Bonnier, H. Maas, and F. Pavese: Metrologia, 1996, vol. 33, pp. 133–54.
L.P. Jahnke: in High temperature materials II, G.M. Ault, W.F. Barclay, and H.P. Munger, eds., American Institute of Mining, Metallurgical, and Petroleum Engineers, Cleveland, OH, 1963, pp. 284–306.
M.G. Hebsur and R.H. Titran: in Report No. NASA-TM-101954, NASA Lewis Research Center, Cleveland, OH, 1988.
J. Wadsworth, C.A. Roberts, and E.H. Rennhack: Journal of Materials Science, 1982, vol. 17, pp. 2539–46.
C.C. Wojcik: in International Powder Metallurgy, vol. 103, 1988, pp. 187–200.
B.P. Bewlay, M.R. Jackson, J.-C. Zhao, P.R. Subramanian, M.G. Mendiratta, and J.J. Lewandowski: MRS Bulletin, 2011, vol. 28, pp. 646–53.
B.P. Bewlay, M.R. Jackson, P.R. Subramanian, and J.C. Zhao: Metallurgical and Materials Transactions A, 2003, vol. 34, pp. 2043–52.
D.L. Anton, D.B. Snow, L.H. Favrow, and A.F. Giamei: in Report No. R89-917437-3, United Technologies Research Center, East Hartford, CT, 1989.
E.N. Sheftel and O.A. Bannykh: International Journal of Refractory Metals and Hard Materials, 1993, vol. 12, pp. 303–14.
I.E. Anderson, E.M.H. White, and R. Dehoff: Current Opinion in Solid State and Materials Science, 2018, vol. 22, pp. 8–15.
J. Dawes, R. Bowerman, and R. Trepleton: Johnson Matthey Technology Review, 2015, vol. 59, pp. 243–56.
P. Sun, Z.Z. Fang, Y. Zhang, and Y. Xia: Jom, 2017, vol. 69, pp. 1853–60.
W.E. Frazier: Journal of Materials Engineering and Performance, 2014, vol. 23, pp. 1917–28.
T. DebRoy, H.L. Wei, J.S. Zuback, T. Mukherjee, J.W. Elmer, J.O. Milewski, A.M. Beese, A. Wilson-Heid, A. De, and W. Zhang: Progress in Materials Science, 2018, vol. 92, pp. 112–224.
D.P. Barbis, R.M. Gasior, G.P. Walker, J.A. Capone, and T.S. Schaeffer: in Titanium Powder Metallurgy, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 2015, pp. 101–16.
M. Boulos: Metal Powder Report, 2004, vol. 59, pp. 16–21.
G. Lütjering and J.C. Williams: Titanium, 2nd edn., Springer Berlin Heidelberg, Berlin, Heidelberg, 2007.
P.L. Fauchais, J.V.R. Heberlein, and M.I. Boulos: Thermal Spray Fundamentals: From Powder to Part, Springer, New York, 2014.
D.K. Bose: Mineral Processing and Extractive Metallurgy Review, 1992, vol. 10, pp. 217–37.
M. Hohmann and N. Ludwig: in System for the Production of Powders from Metals US 5284329A, United States Patent and Trademark Office, City, 1994.
S. Pleier, W. Goy, B. Schaub, M. Hohmann, M. Mede, and R. Schumann: Advances in Powder Metallurgy and Particulate Materials, 2004, vol. 1, pp. 2–49.
R. Gerling, M. Hohmann, and F.P. Schimansky: in Materials science forum, vol. 539, Trans Tech Publ, 2007, pp. 2693–98.
M. Entezarian, F. Allaire, P. Tsantrizos, and R.A.L. Drew: JOM, 1996, vol. 48, pp. 53–5.
P. Gradl, O. Mireles, and N. Andrews: in Report No. M19-7605, NASA Marshall Space Flight Center, Huntsville, AL, 2019.
A. Bose, C.A. Schuh, J.C. Tobia, N. Tuncer, N.M. Mykulowycz, A. Preston, A.C. Barbati, B. Kernan, M.A. Gibson, and D. Krause: International Journal of Refractory Metals and Hard Materials, 2018, vol. 73, pp. 22–8.
A. Iveković, N. Omidvari, B. Vrancken, K. Lietaert, L. Thijs, K. Vanmeensel, J. Vleugels, and J.-P. Kruth: International Journal of Refractory Metals and Hard Materials, 2018, vol. 72, pp. 27–32.
A. V Müller, G. Schlick, R. Neu, C. Anstätt, T. Klimkait, J. Lee, B. Pascher, M. Schmitt, and C. Seidel: Nuclear Materials and Energy, 2019, vol. 19, pp. 184–8.
C. Sungail and A.D. Abid: Met. Powder Rep., 2019, vol. 75, pp. 28-33.
V. Livescu, C.M. Knapp, G.T. Gray III, R.M. Martinez, B.M. Morrow, and B.G. Ndefru: Materialia, 2018, vol. 1, pp. 15–24.
D. Faidel, D. Jonas, G. Natour, and W. Behr: Additive Manufacturing, 2015, vol. 8, pp. 88–94.
L. Kaserer, J. Braun, J. Stajkovic, K.-H. Leitz, B. Tabernig, P. Singer, I. Letofsky-Papst, H. Kestler, and G. Leichtfried: International Journal of Refractory Metals and Hard Materials, 2019, vol. 84, p. 105000.
C.A. Terrazas, J. Mireles, S.M. Gaytan, P.A. Morton, A. Hinojos, P. Frigola, and R.B. Wicker: The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology, 2016, vol. 84, pp. 1115–26.
R. Ebert, F. Ullmann, D. Hildebrandt, J. Schille, L. Hartwig, S. Kloetzer, A. Streek, and H. Exner: Journal of Laser Micro Nanoengineering, 2012, vol. 7, p. 38.
K. Deprez, S. Vandenberghe, K. Van Audenhaege, J. Van Vaerenbergh, and R. Van Holen: Medical physics, 2013, vol. 40, p. 12501.
X. Zhou, X. Liu, D. Zhang, Z. Shen, and W. Liu: Journal of Materials Processing Technology, 2015, vol. 222, pp. 33–42.
C. Tan, K. Zhou, W. Ma, B. Attard, P. Zhang, and T. Kuang: Science and Technology of Advanced Materials, 2018, vol. 19, pp. 370–80.
D. Wang, C. Yu, X. Zhou, J. Ma, W. Liu, and Z. Shen: Applied Sciences, 2017, vol. 7, p. 430.
A.T. Sidambe, Y. Tian, P.B. Prangnell, and P. Fox: International Journal of Refractory Metals and Hard Materials, 2019, vol. 78, pp. 254–63.
J. Braun, L. Kaserer, J. Stajkovic, K.-H. Leitz, B. Tabernig, P. Singer, P. Leibenguth, C. Gspan, H. Kestler, and G. Leichtfried: International Journal of Refractory Metals and Hard Materials, 2019, vol. 84, p. 104999.
D.-Z. Wang, K.-L. Li, C.-F. Yu, J. Ma, W. Liu, and Z.-J. Shen: Acta Metallurgica Sinica (English Letters), 2019, vol. 32, pp. 127–35.
D. Wang, Z. Wang, K. Li, J. Ma, W. Liu, and Z. Shen: Materials & Design, 2019, vol. 162, pp. 384–93.
D. Gu, D. Dai, W. Chen, and H. Chen: Journal of Manufacturing Science and Engineering, 2016, vol. 138, p. 81003.
B. Vrancken, W.E. King, and M.J. Matthews: Procedia CIRP, 2018, vol. 74, pp. 107–10.
J.L. Johnson and T. Palmer: International Journal of Refractory Metals and Hard Materials, 2019, vol. 84, p. 105029.
E. Martinez, L.E. Murr, J. Hernandez, X. Pan, K. Amato, P. Frigola, C. Terrazas, S. Gaytan, E. Rodriguez, F. Medina, and R.B. Wicker: Metallography, Microstructure, and Analysis, 2013, vol. 2, pp. 183–9.
O.R. Terrazas, M.E. Zaun, R.S. Minisandram, and M.L. Lasonde: in Proceedings of the 9th International Symposium on Superalloy 718 & Derivatives: Energy, Aerospace, and Industrial Applications, Springer, 2018, pp. 977–86.
L. Thijs, M.L.M. Sistiaga, R. Wauthle, Q. Xie, J.-P. Kruth, and J. Van Humbeeck: Acta Materialia, 2013, vol. 61, pp. 4657–68.
L. Zhou, T. Yuan, R. Li, J. Tang, G. Wang, and K. Guo: Materials Science and Engineering: A, 2017, vol. 707, pp. 443–51.
R. Wauthle, J. Van Der Stok, S.A. Yavari, J. Van Humbeeck, J.-P. Kruth, A.A. Zadpoor, H. Weinans, M. Mulier, and J. Schrooten: Acta biomaterialia, 2015, vol. 14, pp. 217–25.
V.K. Balla, S. Bodhak, S. Bose, and A. Bandyopadhyay: Acta biomaterialia, 2010, vol. 6, pp. 3349–59.
J. OH, T. ISHIMOTO, S. SUN, and T. NAKANO: Journal of Smart Processing, 2019, vol. 8, pp. 151–4.
H. Dobbelstein, M. Thiele, E.L. Gurevich, E.P. George, and A. Ostendorf: Physics Procedia, 2016, vol. 83, pp. 624–33.
H. Dobbelstein, E.L. Gurevich, E.P. George, A. Ostendorf, and G. Laplanche: Additive Manufacturing, 2018, vol. 24, pp. 386–90.
H. Dobbelstein, E.L. Gurevich, E.P. George, A. Ostendorf, and G. Laplanche: Additive Manufacturing, 2019, vol. 25, pp. 252–62.
H. Zhang, W. Xu, Y. Xu, Z. Lu, and D. Li: The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology, 2018, vol. 96, pp. 461–74.
V. V Popov, A. Katz-Demyanetz, A. Koptyug, and M. Bamberger: Heliyon, 2019, vol. 5, p. e01188.
B. Dutta and F.H.S. Froes: Advanced Materials & Processes, 2014, vol. 172, pp. 18–23.
O.N. Senkov, D.B. Miracle, K.J. Chaput, and J.-P.P. Couzinie: Journal of Materials Research, 2018, vol. 33, pp. 1–37.
D.B. Miracle and O.N. Senkov: Acta Materialia, 2017, vol. 122, pp. 448–511.
J. Gao, C. Li, J. Dang, C. Guo, and Z. Du: Journal of Alloys and Compounds, 2018, vol. 768, pp. 316–22.
O.N. Senkov, S. Gorsse, and D.B. Miracle: Acta Materialia, 2019, vol. 175, pp. 394–405.
O.N. Senkov, C. Zhang, A.L. Pilchak, E.J. Payton, C. Woodward, and F. Zhang: Journal of Alloys and Compounds, 2019, vol. 783, pp. 729–42.
F.G. Coury, T. Butler, K. Chaput, A. Saville, J. Copley, J. Foltz, P. Mason, K. Clarke, M. Kaufman, and A. Clarke: Materials & Design, 2018, vol. 155, pp. 244–56.
H. Song, F. Tian, and D. Wang: Journal of Alloys and Compounds, 2016, vol. 682, pp. 773–7.
H. Song, F. Tian, Q.-M. Hu, L. Vitos, Y. Wang, J. Shen, and N. Chen: Physical Review Materials, 2017, vol. 1, p. 23404.
M. Widom, W.P. Huhn, S. Maiti, and W. Steurer: Metallurgical and Materials Transactions A, 2014, vol. 45, pp. 196–200.
Y. Wang, M. Yan, Q. Zhu, W.Y. Wang, Y. Wu, X. Hui, R. Otis, S.-L. Shang, Z.-K. Liu, and L.-Q. Chen: Acta Materialia, 2018, vol. 143, pp. 88–101.
S.I. Rao, C. Varvenne, C. Woodward, T.A. Parthasarathy, D. Miracle, O.N. Senkov, and W.A. Curtin: Acta Materialia, 2017, vol. 125, pp. 311–20.
M.C. Gao, B. Zhang, S. Yang, and S.M. Guo: Metallurgical and Materials Transactions A, 2016, vol. 47, pp. 3333–45.
F. Tian: Frontiers in Materials, 2017, vol. 4, p. 36.
F.G. Coury, M. Kaufman, and A.J. Clarke: Acta Materialia, 2019, vol. 175, pp. 66–81.
H.W. Yao, J.W. Qiao, J.A. Hawk, H.F. Zhou, M.W. Chen, and M.C. Gao: Journal of Alloys and Compounds, 2017, vol. 696, pp. 1139–50.
F. Maresca and W.A. Curtin: Acta Materialia, 2020, vol. 182, pp. 235–49.
O. Senkov, J. Scott, S. Senkova, D.B. Miracle, and C.F. Woodward: Journal of Alloys and Compounds, 2011, vol. 509, pp. 6043–8.
L. Qi and D.C. Chrzan: Physical review letters, 2014, vol. 112, p. 115503.
N. Yurchenko, N. Stepanov, and G. Salishchev: Materials Science and Technology, 2017, vol. 33, pp. 17–22.
S. Guo: Materials Science and Technology, 2015, vol. 31, pp. 1223–30.
M. Moorehead, K. Bertsch, M. Niezgoda, C. Parkin, M. Elbakhshwan, K. Sridharan, C. Zhang, D. Thoma, and A. Couet: Materials & Design, 2019, p. 108358.
D.C. Hofmann, J. Kolodziejska, S. Roberts, R. Otis, R.P. Dillon, J.-O. Suh, Z.-K. Liu, and J.-P. Borgonia: Journal of Materials Research, 2014, vol. 29, pp. 1899–910.
T. Borkar, B. Gwalani, D. Choudhuri, C. V Mikler, C.J. Yannetta, X. Chen, R.V. Ramanujan, M.J. Styles, M.A. Gibson, and R. Banerjee: Acta Materialia, 2016, vol. 116, pp. 63–76.
P. Wilson, R. Field, and M. Kaufman: Intermetallics, 2016, vol. 75, pp. 15–24.
A. Marshal, K.G. Pradeep, D. Music, S. Zaefferer, P.S. De, and J.M. Schneider: Journal of Alloys and Compounds, 2017, vol. 691, pp. 683–9.
F.G. Coury, P. Wilson, K.D. Clarke, M.J. Kaufman, and A.J. Clarke: Acta Materialia, 2019, vol. 167, pp. 1–11.
D.B. Miracle: JOM, 2017, vol. 69, pp. 2130–6.
ASTM International: B655/B655M-10(2018) Standard Specification for Niobium-Hafnium Alloy Bar and Wire, ASTM International, West Conshohocken, PA, 2018.
G. Youping: in Unpublished research, Castheon Inc, Thousand Oaks, CA, 2019.
J. Jackson and R. Rice: PRELIMINARY MATERIAL PROPERTIES Handbook, vol. 1, AIR FORCE RESEARCH LABORATORY, WRIGHT-PATTERSON AIR FORCE BASE, 2000.
SAE International: SAE AMS 7857 - Columbium (Niobium) Alloy Bars, Rods, and Extrusions 10Hf - 1.0Ti, Recrystallization Annealed, SAE International, 2017.
B.J. McTiernan and J. Moll: in Powder Metallurgy, P. Samal and J. Newkirk, eds., vol. 7, ASM International, 2015, pp. 682–702.
J. Stephens: JOM J. Miner. Met. Mater. Soc.
R.A. Perkins, K.T. Chiang, G.H. Meier, and R.A. Miller: in Report No. LMSC-F195926, vol. AD-A179245, Lockheed Missiles and Space Company, Inc., Palo Alto, 1987.
R.A. Perkins, K.T. Chiang, and G.H. Meier: Scripta Metallurgica, 1988, vol. 22, pp. 419–24.
J. Wadsworth, S.E. Dougherty, P.A. Kramer, and T.G. Nieh: Scripta Metallurgica et Materiala, 1992, vol. 27, pp. 71–6.
N. Raghavan et al, Acta Materialia, 2017, vol. 140, pp. 375–387
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Manuscript submitted on January 10, 2020.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Philips, N.R., Carl, M. & Cunningham, N.J. New Opportunities in Refractory Alloys. Metall Mater Trans A 51, 3299–3310 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11661-020-05803-3
Received:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11661-020-05803-3