Abstract
We contribute to the debate on NATO expansion in two ways that depart from standard practice: we make explicit the theoretical models that this debate demands; and we carefully trace Russian discourse and behavior through time. We show that NATO centrality rather than simply NATO expansion is the root issue. It best captures the historical origins of the problem and is most consistent with the Russian evidence. We demonstrate that Russia’s cooperative moves vis-à-vis NATO were premised upon Moscow’s strongly revisionist preferences regarding the European security architecture. We argue that the US–NATO–Russia spiral is best understood as an offensive-realist tragedy as opposed to a security dilemma or a standoff between one pure security-seeking state and one greedy expansionist. The key protagonists were both revisionists whose preferences and grand strategies brought them into conflict. Central to the whole story is not classical territorial security threats, but much broader conceptions of security.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
Change history
29 April 2020
In the original article, the first author name has been published incorrectly as “Andrey A. Sushenstov”. The correct name is “Andrey A. Sushentsov”.
References
Arms Control Today. 1997. The Debate over NATO Expansion: A Critique of the Clinton Administration’s Responses to Key Questions. Arms Control Today 27(7): 3–10.
Art, R.J. 2003. A Grand Strategy for America. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
Baranovsky, V. 2000. Russia: A Part of Europe or Apart from Europe? International Affairs 76(3): 443–458.
Bild. 2016. For Me, It Is Not Borders That Matter. Interview with Vladimir Putin., 11 January 2016. https://www.bild.de/politik/ausland/wladimir-putin/russian-president-vladimir-putin-the-interview-44092656.bild.html. Accessed 18 January 2020.
Bogaturov, A.D. 2007. Three Generations of Russian Foreign Policy Doctrines. International Trends 5(13): 54–69.
Brooks, S.G. 1997. Dueling Realisms. International Organization 51(3): 445–477.
Brooks, S.G., and W.C. Wohlforth. 2016. America Abroad: The United States’ Global Role in the 21st Century. New York: Oxford University Press.
Brown, M.E. 1999. Minimalist NATO: A Wise Alliance Knows When to Retrench. Foreign Affairs 78(3): 204–218.
Burley, A.M. 1989. The Once and Future German Question. Foreign Affairs 68(5): 65–83.
Burns, W.J. 2008. Nyet Means Nyet: Russia’s NATO Enlargement Redlines. WikiLeaks, 1 February 2008. https://search.wikileaks.org/plusd/cables/08MOSCOW265_a.html. Accessed 23 January 2020.
Bush, G., and B. Scowcroft. 1999. A World Transformed. New York: Vintage.
Carpenter, T.G., and B. Conry (eds.). 1998. NATO Enlargement: Illusions and Reality. Washington, DC: CATO Institute.
Charap, S., and T.J. Colton. 2017. Everyone Loses: The Ukraine Crisis and the Ruinous Contest for Post-Soviet Eurasia. London: Routledge.
Clinton Digital Library. 1997. Memorandum of Conversation. Morning Meeting with Russian President Yeltsin: NATO–Russia, START, ABM/TMD, Helsinki, 21 March 2017. https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/57569. Accessed 23 January 2020.
Fearon, J.D. 2011. Two States, Two Types, Two Actions. Security Studies 20(3): 431–440.
Federation of American Scientists (FAS). 1994. Moscow Declaration by President Clinton and Russian President Yeltsin, Moscow, Russia, January 14, 1994. https://fas.org/nuke/control/detarget/docs/940114-321186.htm. Accessed 23 January 2020.
Federation of American Scientists (FAS). 2000. The Foreign Policy Concept of the Russian Federation (Approved by the President of the Russian Federation V. Putin), 28 June 2000. https://fas.org/nuke/guide/russia/doctrine/econcept.htm. Accessed 23 January 2020.
Flanagan, S.J. 1992. NATO and Central and Eastern Europe: From Liaison to Security Partnership. Washington Quarterly 15(2): 141–151.
Gaddis, J.L. 1998. History, Grand Strategy and NATO Enlargement. Survival 40(1): 145–151.
Glaser, C.L. 1993. Why NATO Is Still Best: Future Security Arrangements for Europe. International Security 18(1): 5–50.
Glaser, C.L. 2010. Rational Theory of International Politics: The Logic of Competition and Cooperation, 23–50. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Goldgeier, J.M. 1999. Not Whether but When: The U.S. Decision to Enlarge NATO. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press.
Gordon, M.R. 1997. Russia Agrees to NATO Plan Pushed by Clinton to Admit Nations from Eastern Bloc. New York Times, 15 May 1997. https://www.nytimes.com/1997/05/15/world/russia-agrees-to-nato-plan-pushed-by-clinton-to-admit-nations-from-eastern-bloc.html. Accessed 23 January 2020.
GovInfo. 1993. Vancouver Declaration: Joint Statement of the Presidents of the United States and the Russian Federation, 4 April 1993. https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/WCPD-1993-04-12/pdf/WCPD-1993-04-12-Pg545.pdf. Accessed 23 January 2020.
Hill, W.H. 2018. No Place for Russia: European Security Institutions since 1989. New York: Columbia University Press.
Istomin, I. 2017. Negotiations under Disagreement: Limitations and Achievements of Russian-Western Talks on NATO Enlargement. In Tug of War: Negotiating Security in Eurasia, ed. F.O. Hampson and M. Troitsky, 35–42. Toronto: McGill-Queen’s Press.
Ivanov, I. 2011. What Diplomacy Does Russia Need in the 21st Century?. Russia in Global Affairs, 29 December 2011. https://eng.globalaffairs.ru/number/What-Diplomacy-Does-Russia-Need-in-the-21st-Century-15420. Accessed 23 January 2020.
Izvestia. 1993. Prospects for NATO Expansion and Russia’s Interests. Report of the Foreign Intelligence Service. 26 November 1993, p. 4. https://m.yeltsin.ru/uploads/upload/newspaper/1993/izv11_26_93/FLASH/index.html. Accessed 23 January 2020.
Kennan, G.F. 1989. The Wall Falls: This Is No Time to Talk of German Reunification. Washington Post, 12 November 1989.
Kennan, G.F. 1997. A Fateful Error. New York Times, 5 February 1997.
Kokoshin, A. 1989. Soviet Strategic Thought, 1917–1991. Cambridge: MIT Press.
Korshunov, M. 2014. Mikhail Gorbachev: I Am against All Walls. Russia beyond the Headlines, 16 October 2014. https://www.rbth.com/international/2014/10/16/mikhail_gorbachev_i_am_against_all_walls_40673.html. Accessed 23 January 2020.
Kortunov, A. 2015. The Splendours and Miseries of Geopolitics. Russia in Global Affairs, 16 January 2015. https://eng.globalaffairs.ru/book/The-Splendours-and-Miseries-of-Geopolitics-17258. Accessed 18 January 2020.
Kozyrev, A. 1992a. Opening statement at the Conference on Security and Cooperation in Europe (CSCE). Stockholm, 14 December 1992.
Kozyrev, A. 1992b. Russia: A Chance for Survival. Foreign Affairs 71(2): 1–16.
Kremlin. 2006. Speech during the Meeting with Ambassadors and Permanent Representatives of the Russian Federation, 27 June 2006. http://kremlin.ru/events/president/transcripts/23669. Accessed 23 January 2020.
Kremlin. 2014. Address by President of the Russian Federation, 18 March 2014. http://en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/20603. Accessed 23 January 2020.
Kupchan, C.A. 1994. Expand NATO—And Split Europe. New York Times 27: 11.
Kydd, A. 2001. Trust Building, Trust Breaking: The Dilemma of NATO Enlargement. International Organization 55(4): 801–828.
Larson, D.W., and A. Shevchenko. 2003. Shortcut to Greatness: The New Thinking and the Revolution in Soviet Foreign Policy. International Organization 57(1): 77–109.
Layne, C. 1989/1990. Superpower Disengagement. Foreign Policy 77: 17–40.
Mandelbaum, M. 1995. Preserving the New Peace: The Case against NATO Expansion. Foreign Affairs 74(3): 9–13.
Mearsheimer, J.J. 2001. The Tragedy of Great Power Politics. New York: W.W. Norton.
Mearsheimer, J.J. 2014. Why the Ukraine Crisis Is the West’s Fault: The Liberal Delusions That Provoked Putin. Foreign Affairs 93(5): 77–89.
Mearsheimer, J.J. 2018. The Great Delusion: Liberal Dreams and International Realities. New Haven: Yale University Press.
Menon, R., and E. Rumer. 2015. Conflict in Ukraine: The Unwinding of the Post-Cold War Order. Cambridge: MIT Press.
National Security Archive (online). 1993. Retranslation of Yeltsin Letter on NATO Expansion, 15 September 1993. https://nsarchive2.gwu.edu//dc.html?doc=4390818-Document-04-Retranslation-of-Yeltsin-letter-on. Accessed 23 January 2020.
National Security Archive (online). 1995. Summary Report on One-on-One Meeting Between Presidents Clinton and Yeltsin, the Kremlin, 10 May 1995. https://nsarchive2.gwu.edu//dc.html?doc=4390833-Document-19-Summary-report-on-One-on-One-meeting. Accessed 23 January 2020.
NATO. 1996. Press Conference of Secretary General and Minister Primakov. Meeting of the North Atlantic Cooperation Council in Ministerial Session, NATO HQ, Brussels, 11 December 1996. https://www.nato.int/docu/speech/1996/s961211d.htm. Accessed 23 January 2020.
NATO. 1997. Remarks by Russian President Yeltsin. Signing Ceremony of the NATO–Russia Founding Act, Paris, 27 May 1997. https://www.nato.int/docu/speech/1997/s970527e.htm. Accessed 23 January 2020.
New York Times. 1992. Presidents Bush and Yeltsin: “Dawn of a New Era”, 2 February 1992. http://www.nytimes.com/1992/02/02/world/presidents-bush-and-yeltsin-dawn-of-a-new-era.html. Accessed 22 January 2020.
Poe, M.T. 2003. The Russian Moment in World History. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Pushkov, A. 1997. Don’t Isolate Us: A Russian View of NATO Expansion. National Interest 47: 58–63.
Rasmussen, A.F. 2016. The Will to Lead: America’s Indispensable Role in the Global Fight for Freedom. New York: HarperCollins.
Reiter, D. 2001. Why NATO Expansion Does Not Spread Democracy. International Security 25(4): 41–67.
Russell, D.A. 2008. Russian–Ukrainian Relations Monopolized by Ukraine’s NATO Bid. WikiLeaks, 30 May 2008. https://search.wikileaks.org/plusd/cables/08MOSCOW1517_a.html. Accessed 23 January 2020.
Russett, B., and A.C. Stam. 1998. Courting Disaster: An Expanded NATO vs. Russia and China. Political Science Quarterly 113(3): 361–382.
Russian Ministry of Foreign Affairs. 1993. The Concept of Foreign Policy of the Russian Federation. In: Foreign Policy and Security of Modern Russia (1992–2002), vol. 4 (2002) Shakleina, T.A., comp. Moscow: MGIMO, RISA, ISE-Center.
Russian Ministry of Foreign Affairs. 2018. Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov’s Interview with Serbian Information Agency BETA. Ljubljana: Embassy of the Russian Federation to the Republic of Slovenia, 19 February 2018. https://veleposlanistvorusije.mid.ru/en/press-centre/news/foreign_minister_sergey_lavrov_s_interview_with_serbian_information_agency_beta. Accessed 23 January 2020.
Sakwa, R. 2016. Frontline Ukraine: Crisis in the Borderlands. London: I.B. Tauris.
Sarotte, M.E. 2011. 1989: The Struggle to Create Post-Cold War Europe. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Shaake, K. 1998. NATO after the Cold War, 1991–1995: Institutional Competition and the Collapse of the French Alternative. Contemporary European History 7(3): 379–407.
Simes, D.K. 1999. After the Collapse: Russia Seeks Its Place as a Great Power. New York: Simon & Schuster.
Tang, S. 2009. The Security Dilemma: A Conceptual Analysis. Security Studies 18(3): 587–623.
Thompson, K.W. (ed.). 1998. NATO Expansion. Lanham: University Press of America.
Troitskiy, M. 2008. Going “Relativistic”: The Changing Vision of a “Just International Order” in Russian Foreign Policy. In Russia and Globalization: Identity, Security, and Society in an Era of Change, ed. D.W. Blum, 207–232. Washington, DC: Woodrow Wilson Center Press.
Tsygankov, A.P. 2016. Russia’s Foreign Policy: Change and Continuity in National Identity. Lanham: Rowman & Littlefield.
Tyler, P.E. 1992. U.S. Strategy Plan Calls for Insuring [sic] No Rivals Develop. New York Times, 8 March 1992, p. 1.
United Nations (UN) Digital Library. 1997. Russian–Chinese Joint Declaration on a Multipolar World and the Establishment of a New International Order. 23 April 1997. https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/234074. Accessed 23 January 2020.
White House. 1992. A Charter for American–Russian Partnership and Friendship. 17 June 1992. http://www.channelingreality.com/NWO_WTO/NWO_DOCS/1992_Charter_for_American-Russian_Camp_David.pdf. Accessed 22 January 2020.
Wohlforth, W.C. 1993. The Elusive Balance: Power and Perceptions in the Cold War. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
Wohlforth, W.C. 2000. German Reunification: A Reassessment. In The Cold War—Reassessments, ed. A.L. Rosenbaum and C.J. Lee. Claremont: Keck Center.
Wohlforth, W.C. 2021. The Challenge of Evaluating Grand Strategy. In The Oxford Handbook of Grand Strategy, ed. R.R. Krebs and T. Balzaq. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Wohlforth, W.C., and V. Zubok. 2017. An Abiding Antagonism: Realism, Idealism, and the Mirage of US–Russian Partnership after the End of the Cold War. International Politics 54(4): 405–419.
Yeltsin, B. 1994. Speech at the Conference on Security and Cooperation in Europe (CSCE). Budapest, 5 December 1994.
Funding
This work was supported by Russian Ministry of Science and Education under Grant 14.461.31.0002.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Conflict of interest
On behalf of all authors, the corresponding author states that there is no conflict of interest.
Additional information
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
The original version of this article was revised due to incorrect name of first author. The correct name is Andrey A. Sushentsov.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Sushentsov, A.A., Wohlforth, W.C. The tragedy of US–Russian relations: NATO centrality and the revisionists’ spiral. Int Polit 57, 427–450 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1057/s41311-020-00229-5
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1057/s41311-020-00229-5