Abstract
The in vitro production of meat is probably feasible with existing tissue engineering techniques and may offer health and environmental advantages by reducing environmental pollution and land use associated with current meat production systems. By culturing loose myosatellite cells on a substrate, it is probably possible to produce cultured meat by harvesting mature muscle cells after differentiation and processing them into various meat products. Besides reducing the animal suffering significantly, it will also ensure sustainable production of designer, chemically safe and disease free meat with favourable nutritional profile as the conditions in an in vitro meat production system are controlled and manipulatable. However, the production of highly-structured, unprocessed meat faces considerably greater technical challenges and a great deal of research is still needed to establish a sustainable in vitro meat culturing system on an industrial scale. This review discusses the requirements that need to be met to increase the feasibility of meat production in vitro, which include finding an appropriate stem cell source and being able to grow them in a three dimensional environment inside a bioreactor, providing essential cues for proliferation and differentiation.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Alberts B, Bray D, Lewis J, Raff M, Roberts K, Watson JD (1994) Molecular biology of the cell, 3rd edn. Garland, New York
Allen RE, Temm-Grove CJ, Sheehan SM, Rice G (1997) Skeletal muscle satellite cell cultures. Methods Cell Biol 52:155–176
Amit M, Carpenter MK, Inokuma MS, Chiu CP, Harris CP, Waknitz MA et al (2000) Clonally derived human embryonic stem cell lines maintain pluripotency and proliferative potential for prolonged periods of culture. Dev Biol 227(2):271–278
Asakura A, Komaki M, Rudnicki M (2001) Muscle satellite cells are multi-potential stem cells that exhibit myogenic, osteogenic, and adipogenic differentiation. Differentiation 68(4–5):245–253
Asner GP, Elmore AJ, Olander LP, Martin RE, Harris AT (2004) Grazing systems, ecosystem responses and global change. Annu Rev Environ Resour 29:261–299
Avery A (1997) Red meat production can be part of an environmentally sound future. J Am Diet Assoc 97(11):1249–1250
Bach AD, Stem-Straeter J, Beier JP, Bannasch H, Stark GB (2003) Engineering of muscle tissue. Clin Plast Surg 30(4):589–599
Barnard ND, Nicholson A, Howard JL (1995) The medical costs attributable to meat consumption. Prev Med 24:646–655
Bender A (1992) Meat and meat products in human nutrition in developing countries. Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO), Food and Nutrition Paper 53, Italy, Rome
Benjaminson M, Lehrer S, Macklin D (1998) Bioconversion systems for food and water on long term space missions. Acta Astronaut 43(3–6):329–348
Benjaminson MA, Gilchriest JA, Lorenz M (2002) In vitro edible muscle protein production system (MPPS): Stage 1, fish. Acta Astronaut 51(12):879–889
Bernardo ME, Zaffaroni N, Novara F, Cometa AM, Avanzini MA, Moretta A et al (2007) Human bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cells do not undergo transformation after long-term in vitro culture and do not exhibit telomere maintenance mechanisms. Cancer Res 67(19):9142–9149
Bhat ZF, Bhat H (2011) Animal-free meat biofabrication. Am J Food Technol 6(6):441–459
Blanton JR, Grand AL, McFarland DC, Robinson JP, Bidwell CA (1999) Isolation of two populations of myoblasts from porcine skeletal muscle. Muscle Nerve 22(1):43–50
Boland T, Mironov V, Gutowska A, Roth E, Markwald R (2003) Cell and organ printing 2: fusion of cell aggregates in three-dimensional gels. Anat Rec 272A(2):497–502
Boldrin L, Malerba A, Vitiello L, Cimetta E, Piccoli M, Messina C et al (2008) Efficient delivery of human single fiber derived muscle precursor cells via biocompatible scaffold. Cell Transplant 17(5):577–584
Borenstein JT, Terai H, King KR, Weinberg EJ, Kaazempur-Mofrad MR, Vacanti JP (2002) Microfabrication technology for vascularized tissue engineering. Biomed Microdevices 4(3):167–175
Burdock GA, Carabin GI, Griffiths GC (2006) The importance of GRAS to the functional food and nutraceutical industries. Toxicology 221(1):17–27
Burdon T, Smith A, Savatier P (2002) Signalling, cell cycle and pluripotency in embryonic stem cells. Trends Cell Biol 12(9):432–438
Burton NM, Vierck JL, Krabbenhoft L, Byrne K, Dodson MV (2000) Methods for animal satellite cell culture under a variety of conditions. Methods Cell Sci 22(1):51–61
Campion DR (1984) The muscle satellite cell: a review. Int Rev Cytol 87:225–251
Canavan HE, Cheng X, Graham DJ, Ratner BD, Castner DG (2005) Cell sheet detachment affects the extracellular matrix: a surface science study comparing thermal liftoff, enzymatic, and mechanical methods. J Biomed Mater Res 75A(1):1–13
Carrier RL, Papadaki M, Rupnick M, Schoen FJ, Bursac N, Langer R et al (1999) Cardiac tissue engineering: cell seeding, cultivation parameters and tissue construct characterization. Biotechnol Bioeng 64(5):580–589
Carrier RL, Rupnick M, Langer R, Schoen FJ, Freed LE, Vunjak-Novakovic G (2002) Perfusion improves tissue architecture of engineered cardiac muscle. Tissue Eng 8(2):175–188
Catts O, Zurr I (2002) Growing semi-living sculptures: Tissue culture and art project. In: Leonardo 35(4):365–370
Cen S, Zhang J, Huang F, Yang Z, Xie H (2008) Effect of IGF-I on proliferation and differentiation of primary human embryonic myoblasts. Chinese Journal of Reparative and Reconstructive Surgery 22(1):84–87
Cha JM, Park SN, Noh SH, Suh H (2006) Time-dependent modulation of alignment and differentiation of smooth muscle cells seeded on a porous substrate undergoing cyclic mechanical strain. Artif Organs 30(4):250–258
Charge S, Brack A, Hughes S (2002) Aging-related satellite cell differentiation defect occurs prematurely after Ski-induced muscle hypertrophy. Am J Physiol Cell Physiol 283(4):C1228–C1241
Cheng L, Gu X, Sanderson JE, Wang X, Lee K, Yao X et al (2006) A new function of a previously isolated compound that stimulates activation and differentiation of myogenic precursor cells leading to efficient myofiber regeneration and muscle repair. Int J Biochem Cell Biol 38(7):1123–1133
Coecke S, Balls M, Bowe G, Davis J, Gstraunthaler G, Hartung T et al (2005) Guidance on good cell culture practice: a report of the second ECVAM Task Force on good cell culture practice. Altern Lab Anim 33(3):261–287
Costales A, Gerber P, Steinfeld H (2006) Underneath the livestock revolution. Livestock report, Rome, Italy: Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations
Counter C, Hahn W, Wei W, Caddle S, Beijersbergen R, Lansdorp P, Sedivy J, Weinberg R (1998) Dissociation among in vitro telomerase activity, telomere maintenance, and cellular immortalization. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 95(25):14723–14728
Crok M (2003) Bij de beesten af. Natuur and Techniek 71(4):46–49
Da Silva RMP, Mano JF, Reis RL (2007) Smart thermoresponsive coatings and surfaces for tissue engineering: switching cell-material boundaries. Trends Biotechnol 25(12):577–583
De Deyne PG (2000) Formation of sarcomeres in developing myotubes: role of mechanical stretch and contractile activation. Am J Physiol Cell Physiol 279(6):C1801–C1811
de Haan C, Steinfeld H, Blackburn H (1997) Livestock and the environment: finding a balance. Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations, World Bank and US Agency for International Development
Delgado CL (2003) Rising consumption of meat and milk in developing countries has created a new food revolution. J Nutr 133:3907S–3910S
Delo DM, Eberlie D, Williams JK, Anderrson KE, Atala A, Soker S (2008) Angiogenic gene modification of skeletal muscle cells to compensate for ageing induced decline in bioengineered functional muscle tissue. BJU Int 102(7):878–884
Dennis R, Kosnik P 2nd (2000) Excitability and isometric contractile properties of mammalian skeletal muscle constructs engineered in vitro. In Vitro Cell Dev Biol Anim 36(5):327–335
Dennis R, Kosnik P 2nd, Gilbert M, Faulkner J (2001) Excitability and contractility of skeletal muscle engineered from primary cultures and cell lines. Am J Physiol Cell Physiol 280(2):C288–C295
Dieryck W, Pagnier J, Poyart C, Marden M, Gruber V, Bournat P et al (1997) Human haemoglobin from transgenic tobacco. Nature 386(6620):29–30
Dodson MV, Mathison BA (1988) Comparison of ovine and rat muscle-derived satellite cells: response to insulin. Tissue Cell 20(6):909–918
Dodson MV, McFarland DC, Martin EL, Brannon MA (1986) Isolation of satellite cells from ovine skeletal muscles. J Tissue Cult Methods 10(4):233–237
Dodson MV, Martin EL, Brannon MA, Mathison BA, McFarland DC (1987) Optimization of bovine satellite cell derived myotube formation in vitro. Tissue Cell 19(2):159–166
Dodson MV, McFarland DC, Grant AL, Doumit ME, Velleman SG (1996) Extrinsic regulation of domestic animal-derived satellite cells. Domest Anim Endocrinol 13(2):107–126
Doumit ME, Cook DR, Merkel RA (1993) Fibroblast growth factor, epidermal growth factor, insulin-like growth factor and platelet-derived growth factor-BB stimulate proliferate of clonally derived porcine myogenic satellite cells. J Cell Physiol 157(2):326–332
Drysdale A, Ewert M, Hanford A (2003) Life support approaches for Mars missions. Adv Space Res 31(1):51–61
Duque P, Gómez E, Diaz E, Facal N, Hidalgo C, Diez C (2003) Use of two replacements of serum during bovine embryo culture in vitro. Theriogenology 59(3–4):889–899
Edelman PD, McFarland DC, Mironov VA, Matheny JG (2005) Commentary: in vitro-cultured meat production. Tissue Eng 11(5):659–662
Engler AJ, Griffin MA, Sen S, Bönnemann CG, Sweeney HL, Discher DE (2004) Myotubes differentiate optimally on substrates with tissue-like stiffness, pathological implications for soft or stiff microenvironments. J Cell Biol 166(6):877–887
European Food Safety Authority (2006) The community summary report on trends and sources of zoonoses, zoonotic agents, antimicrobial resistance and food borne outbreaks in the European Union in 2005. EFSA J 94:2–288
Fisher IS, Meakens S (2006) Surveillance of enteric pathogens in Europe and beyond: enter-net annual report for 2004. Euro Surveillance: Bulletin Européen sur les Maladies Transmissibles 11, E060824.060823. Available at: http://www.hpa.org.uk/hpa/inter/enter-net/Enter-net%20annual%20report%202004.pdf, (26 March 2007 last date accessed)
Florini JR, Magri KA, Ewton DZ, James PL, Grindstaff K, Rotwein PS (1991) Spontaneous differentiation of skeletal myoblasts is dependent upon autocrine secretion of insulin-like growth factor-II. J Biol Chem 266(24):15917–15923
Fox SI (1996) Human physiology. Wim C, Brown, Boston
Froud SJ (1999) The development, benefits and disadvantages of serum-free media. Dev Biol Stand 99:157–166
Gawlitta D, Oomens CW, Bader DL, Baaijens FP, Bouten CV (2007) Temporal differences in the influence of ischemic factors and deformation on the metabolism of engineered skeletal muscle. J Appl Physiol 103(2):464–473
Gimble JM, Katz AJ, Bunnell BA (2007) Adipose-derived stem cells for regenerative medicine. Circ Res 100(9):1249–1260
Hawke T, Garry D (2001) Myogenic satellite cells: physiology to molecular biology. J Appl Physiol 91(2):534–551
Hill M, Wernig A, Goldspink G (2003) Muscle satellite (stem) cell activation during local tissue injury and repair. J Anat 203(1):89–99
Holmes PD, Dacey A (2008) Vegetarian meat: could technology save animals and satisfy meat eaters? J Agric Environ Ethics 21:579–596
Houdebine LM (2009) Production of pharmaceutical proteins by transgenic animals. Comp Immunol Microbiol Infect Dis 32(2):107–121
Jun I, Jeong S, Shin H (2009) The stimulation of myoblast differentiation by electrically conductive sub-micron fibers. Biomaterials 30(11):2038–2047
Kazama T, Fujie M, Endo T, Kano K (2008) Mature adipocyte-derived dedifferentiated fat cells can transdifferentiate into skeletalmyocytes in vitro. Biochem Biophys Res Commun 377(3):780–785
Keefer CL, Pant D, Blomberg L, Talbot NC (2007) Challenges and prospects for the establishment of embryonic stem cell lines of domesticated ungulates. Anim Reprod Sci 98(1–2):147–168
Kim MJ, Choi YS, Yang SH, Hong HN, Cho SW, Cha SM et al (2006) Muscle regeneration by adipose tissue-derived adult stem cells attached to injectable PLGA spheres. Biochem Biophys Res Commun 348(2):386–392
Korhonen H (2002) Technology options for new nutritional concepts. Int J Dairy Technol 55(2):79–88
Kosnik P, Faulkner J, Dennis R (2001) Functional development of engineered skeletal muscle from adult and neonatal rats. Tissue Eng 7(5):573–584
Lam MT, Sim S, Zhu X, Takayama S (2006) The effect of continuous wavy micropatterns on silicone substrates on the alignment of skeletal muscle myoblasts and myotubes. Biomaterials 27(24):4340–4347
Lam MT, Huang YC, Birla RK, Takayama S (2009) Microfeature guided skeletal muscle tissue engineering for highly organized three-dimensional free-standing constructs. Biomaterials 30(6):1150–1155
Lazennec G, Jorgensen C (2008) Concise review: adult multipotent stromal cells and cancer: risk or benefit? Stem Cells 26(6):1387–1394
Le Grand F, Rudnicki MA (2007) Skeletal muscle satellite cells and adult myogenesis. Curr Opin Cell Biol 19(6):628–633
Levenberg S, Rouwkema J, Macdonald M, Garfein ES, Kohane DS, Darland DC et al (2005) Engineering vascularized skeletal muscle tissue. Nat Biotechnol 23(7):879–884
Lowe K (2006) Blood substitutes: from chemistry to clinic. J Mater Chem 16(43):4189–4196
Lustig A (1999) Crisis intervention: the role of telomerase. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 96(7):3339–3341
Martin I, Wendt D, Herberer M (2004) The role of bioreactors in tissue engineering. Trends Biotechnol 22(2):80–86
Matsumoto T, Kano K, Kondo D, Fukuda N, Iribe Y, Tanaka N et al (2007) Mature adipocyte-derived dedifferentiated fat cells exhibit multilineage potential. J Cell Physiol 215(1):210–222
McFarland DC, Doumit ME, Minshall RD (1988) The turkey myogenic satellite cell: optimization of in vitro proliferation and differentiation. Tissue Cell 20(6):899–908
McFarland DC, Pesall JE, Norberg JM, Dvoracek MA (1991) Proliferation of the turkey myogenic satellite cell in a serum-free medium. Comp Biochem Physiol 99(1–2):163–167
Mead P, Slutsker L, Dietz A, McCaig L, Bresee J, Shapiro C, Griffin P, Tauxe R (1999) Food-related illness and death in the United States. Emerg Infect Dis 5(5):607–625
Merten OW (1999) Safety issues of animal products used in serum-free media. Dev Biol Stand 99:167–180
Mol A, Driessen NJ, Rutten MC, Hoerstrup SP, Bouten CV, Baaijens FP (2005) Tissue engineering of human heart valve leaflets: a novel bioreactor for a strain-based conditioning approach. Ann Biomed Eng 33(12):1778–1788
Nataro JP, Kaper JB (1998) Diarrheagenic Escherichia coli. Clin Microbiol Rev 11:142–201
Nestle M (1999) Animal vs. plant foods in human diets and health: is the historical record unequivocal? Proc Nutr Soc 58:211–218
Nicholson FA, Hutchison ML, Smith KA, Keevil CW, Chambers BJ, Moore A (2000) A study on farm manure applications to agricultural land and an assessment of the risks of pathogen transfer into the food chain. Project Number FS2526, Final report to the Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food, London
O’Hare M, Bond J, Clarke C, Takeuchi Y, Atherton A, Berry C, Moody J, Silver A, Davies D, Alsop A, Neville A, Jat P (2001) Conditional immortalization of freshly isolated human mammary fibroblasts and endothelial cells. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 98(2):646–651
Ohira Y, Yoshinaga T, Nomura T, Kawano F, Ishihara A, Nonaka I, Roy R, Edgerton V (2002) Gravitational unloading effects on muscle fiber size, phenotype and myonuclear number. Adv Space Res 30(4):777–781
Pathak V, Bukhari SAA, Bhat ZF, Sharma N (2008) Prospectus of in-vitro meat. Indian Food Industry Nov-Dec:33–35
Powell RE, Dodson MV, Cloud JG (1989) Cultivation and differentiation of satellite cells from skeletal muscle of the rainbow trout Salmo gairdneri. J Exp Zool 250(3):333–338
Prowse K, Greider C (1995) Developmental and tissue-specific regulation of mouse telomerase and telomere length. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 92(11):4818–4822
Radisic M, Euloth M, Yang L, Langer R, Freed LE, Vunjak-Novakovic G (2003) High-density seeding of myocyte cells for cardiac tissue engineering. Biotechnol Bioeng 82(4):403–414
Radisic M, Marsano A, Maidhof R, Wang Y, Vunjak-Novakovic G (2008) Cardiac tissue engineering using perfusion bioreactor systems. Nat Protoc 3(4):719–738
Reay D (2002) Intensive farming, US-style, is not sustainable worldwide. Nature 417(6884):15
Riboldi SA, Sampaolesi M, Neuenschwander P, Cossu G, Mantero S (2005) Electrospun degradable polyesterurethane membranes: potential scaffolds for skeletal muscle tissue engineering. Biomaterials 26(22):4606–4615
Rizzino A (2007) A challenge for regenerative medicine: proper genetic programming, not cellular mimicry. Dev Dyn 236(12):3199–3207
Roelen BA, Lopes SM (2008) Of stem cells and gametes: similarities and differences. Curr Med Chem 15:1249–1256
Rosegrant M, Leach N, Gerpacio R (1999) Alternative futures for world cereal and meat consumption. Proc Nutr Soc 58(2):219–234
Rubio D, Garcia-Castro J, Martin MC, de la Fuente R, Cigudosa JC, Lloyd AC et al (2005) Spontaneous human adult stem cell transformation. Cancer Res 65(8):3035–3039
Saha P, Trumbo P (1996) The nutritional adequacy of a limited vegan diet for a controlled ecological life-support system. Adv Space Res 18(4–5):63–72
Sanders T (1999) The nutritional adequacy of plant-based diets. Proc Nutr Soc 58(2):265–269
Savadogo P, Sawadogo L, Tiveau D (2007) Effects of grazing intensity and prescribed fire on soil physical and hydrological properties and pasture yield in the savanna woodlands of Burkina Faso. Agricult Ecosys Environ 118:80–92
Shah G (1999) Why do we still use serum in production of biopharmaceuticals? Dev Biol Stand 99:17–22
Solomon R, Johnston C (1997) Production of red meat should be curbed in order to conserve natural resources. J Am Diet Assoc 97(11):1249
Speedy AW (2003) Global production and consumption of animal source foods. J Nutr 133:4048S–4053S
Steinfeld H, Gerber P, Wassenaar T, Castel V, Rosales M, De Haan C (2006a) Livestock’s long shadow: environmental issues and options (Rome: Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations, p. xxi). Available at: www.virtualcentre.org/en/library/key_pub/longshad/A0701E00.pdf. Accessed March 7, 2008
Steinfeld H, Wassenaar T, Jutzi S (2006b) Livestock production systems in developing countries: status, drivers, trends. Revue Scientifique et Technique de l’Office International des Epizooties, Paris 25(2):505–516
Stoker M, O’Neil C, Berryman S, Waxman V (1968) Anchorage and growth regulation in normal and virus-transformed cells. Int J Cancer 3:683–693
Talbot NC, Blomberg LA (2008) The pursuit of ES cell lines of domesticated ungulates. Stem Cell Reviews and Reports 4(3):235–254
Technology Review (2003) Fractals support growing organs. Technology Research News. http://www.trnmag.com/Stories/2003/073003/Fractals_support_growing_organs_073003. Accessed July 30/August 6, 2003
Thornton P, Kruska R, Henninger N, Kristjanson P, Reid R, Atieno F, Odero A, Ndegwa T (2002) Mapping poverty and livestock in the developing world. International Livestock Research Institute, Nairobi, p 124
Van Eelen WF, van Kooten WJ, Westerhof W (1999) WO/1999/031223: industrial production of meat from in vitro cell cultures. Patent Description http://www.wipo.int/pctdb/en/wo.jsp?wo=1999031223 Accessed Mar. 2009
Vandenburgh H, Shansky J, Benesch-Lee F, Barbata V, Reid J, Thorrez L et al (2008) Drug screening platform based on the contractility of tissue engineered muscle. Muscle Nerve 37(4):438–447
Vein J (2004) Method for producing tissue engineered meat for consumption. US Patent Number 6835390, http://www.freepatentsonline.com/6835390.html-12/28/2004
Verma AK, Banerjee R (2010) Dietary fibre as functional ingredient in meat products: a novel approach for healthy living: a review. J Food Sci Technol 47(3):247–257
Wagers AJ, Weissman IL (2004) Plasticity of adult stem cells. Cell 116(5):639–648
Webster R (2002) The importance of animal influenza for human disease. Vaccine 20(Suppl 2):S16–S20
WHO (2001) Global burden of disease estimates for 2001. Geneva, World Health Organization. http://www3.who.int/whosis/menu.cfm?path=evidence,burden,burden_estimates,burden_estimates_2001&language=english, accessed 9 April 2004
Wilschut KJ, Jaksani S, Van Den Dolder J, Haagsman HP, Roelen BAJ (2008) Isolation and characterization of porcine adult muscle-derived progenitor cells. J Cell Biochem 105(5):1228–1239
Wilson EM, Hsieh MM, Rotwein P (2003) Autocrine growth factor signaling by insulin-like growth factor-II mediates myod-stimulated myocyte maturation. J Biol Chem 278(42):41109–41113
Wolfson W (2002) Raising the steaks. New Sci 176:60–63
Wolpert L, Beddington R, Brockes J, Jessel T, Lawrence P, Meyerowitz E (1998) Principles of development. Current Biology, 1st edn. Oxford University Press
Yablonka-Reuveni Z, Quinn LS, Nameroff M (1987) Isolation and clonal analysis of satellite cells from chicken pectoralis muscle. Dev Biol 119(1):252–259
Zandonella C (2003) Tissue engineering: the beat goes on. Nature 421(6926):884–886
Zandstra E, de Graaf C, van Trijp H (2000) Effects of variety and repeated in-home consumption on product acceptance. Appetite 35(2):113–119
Zuckerman SH, Doyle MP, Gorczynski R, Rosenthal GJ (1998) Preclinical biology of recombinant human hemoglobin, rHb1.1. Artif Cells Blood Substit Immobil Biotechnol 26(3):231–257
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Bhat, Z.F., Fayaz, H. Prospectus of cultured meat—advancing meat alternatives. J Food Sci Technol 48, 125–140 (2011). https://doi.org/10.1007/s13197-010-0198-7
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s13197-010-0198-7