Abstract
Proponents of the scientific adaptive management approach argue that it increases knowledge acquisition rates, enhances information flow among policy actors, and provides opportunities for creating shared understandings. However, evidence from efforts to implement the approach in New Brunswick, British Columbia, Canada, and the Columbia River Basin indicates that these promises have not been met. The data show that scientific adaptive management relies excessively on the use of linear systems models, discounts nonscientific forms of knowledge, and pays inadequate attention to policy processes that promote the development of shared understandings among diverse stakeholders. To be effective, new adaptive management efforts will need to incorporate knowledge from multiple sources, make use of multiple systems models, and support new forms of cooperation among stakeholders.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
Literature Cited
Allen, G. M., and E. M. Gould, Jr. 1986. Complexity, wickedness, and public forests.Journal of Forestry 84(4):20–23.
AFL Memo (Anadromous Fish Law Memo). 1986. The failed promise of the Columbia fish and wildlife program and what to do about it.Anadromous Fish Law Memo 38:1–13.
AFL Memo (Anadromous Fish Law Memo). 1987. Intertie expansion and fish protection: Idaho objects to BPA's draft EIS.Anadromous Fish Law Memo 39:1–9.
AFL Memo (Anadromous Fish Law Memo). 1990. Anadromous fish law—1979–90.Anadromous Fish Law Memo 50:1–38.
Baskerville, G. 1978. New Brunswick's budworm future: Longterm policy of protection needed for a long-term problem.Pulp and Paper Canada 79(3):59–63.
Baskervile, G. 1985. Adaptive management, wood availability and habitat availability.The Forestry Chronicle 61(2):171–175.
Bellman, R. E. 1961. Adaptive control processes: A guided tour. Princeton University Press, Princeton, New Jersey.
Blumm, M. C. 1987. The northwest power act's institutional innovations and unfulfilled promises.Environmental Law and Litigation 2:165–175.
Brett-Crowther, M. R. 1981. The spruce budworm controversy in Nova Scotia.Science and Public Policy 8(1):55–76.
Buck, S. J. 1989. Cultural theory and management of common property resources.Human Ecology 17(1):101–116.
Canadian Forestry Service (Department of the Environment). 1976. Environmental effects of the spruce budworm spray program in New Brunswick, 1976. A preliminary report by the committee for environmental monitoring of forest insect control operations. Information Report M-X-67. Maritimes Forest Research Center, Fredericton, New Brunswick.
Chandler, P. M. 1990. Ecological knowledge in a traditional agroforest management system among peasants in China. PhD dissertation. University of Washington, Seattle.
Clark, W. C., D. D. Jones, and C. S. Holling. 1979. Lessons for ecological policy design: A case study of ecosystem management.Ecological Modelling 7:1–53.
Clune, T. and D. Dauble. 1991. The Yakima/Klickitat fisheries project: A strategy for supplementation of anadromous salmonids.Fisheries 16(5):28–34.
Cortner, H. J. and M. A. Moote. 1994. Trends and issues in land and water resources management: Setting the agenda for change.Environmental Management 18(2):167–173.
Craik, K. H. 1972. An ecological perspective on environmental decision-making.Human Ecology 1(1):69–80.
Cuff, W. and G. Baskerville. 1983. Ecological modelling and management of spruce budworm infested fir-spruce forests of New Brunswick, Canada. Pages 93–98in W. K. Lauenroth, G. V. Skogerboe, and M. Flug (eds.), Analysis of ecological systems: State-of-the-art in ecological modelling. Elsevier Scientific Publishing, Amsterdam.
Cuff, W. and H. D. Walker. 1984. Integration of forest management and pest management in the eastern provinces of Canada. Pages 443–463in C. J. Sanders, R. W. Stark, E. J. Mullins, and J. Murphy (eds.), Recent advances in spruce budworms research. Proceedings of the CANUSA spruce budworms research symposium. Canadian Forestry Service and USDA Forest Service.
Dale, N. 1991. The quest for consensus on sustainable development in the use and management of Fraser river salmon. Pages 155–187in A. H. J. Dorcey (ed.), Perspectives on sustainable development in water management: Towards agreement in the Fraser River basin. Westwater Research Centre, University of British Columbia, Vancouver.
Dryzek, J. S. 1987. Rational ecology: Environment and political economy. Basil Blackwood, Oxford.
Firey, W. 1960. Man, mind and land: A theory of resource use. Greenwood Press, Westport, Connecticut.
Fox, I. K. 1991. Institutional design for the management of the natural resources of the Fraser river basin. Pages 289–311in A. H. J. Dorcey (ed.), Perspectives on sustainable development in water management: Towards agreement in the Fraser river basin. Westwater Research Centre, University of British Columbia, Vancouver.
Halbert, C. 1993. How adaptive is adaptive management? Implementing adaptive management in Washington State and British Columbia.Reviews in Fisheries Science 1(3):261–283.
Haley, K. B. 1990. Operational research and management in fishing. Pages 3–7in A. G. Rodrigues (ed.), Operations research and management in fishing. NATO ASI Series. Series E: Applied Sciences, Vol 189. Kluwer Academic, Dordrecht, The Netherlands.
Hilborn, R. 1979. Some failures and successes in applying systems analysis to ecological systems.Journal of Applied Systems Analysis 6:25–31.
Hilborn, R. 1987. Living with uncertainty in resource management.North American Journal of Fisheries Management 7(1):1–5.
Hilborn, R. and W. Luedke. 1987. Rationalizing the irrational: A case study in user group participation in pacific salmon management.Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 44:1796–1805.
Hilborn, R. and C. J. Walters. 1977. Differing goals of salmon management on the Skeena river.Journal of the Fisheries Research Board of Canada 34:64–72.
Hilborn, R., C. J. Walters, R. M. Peterman, and M. J. Staley. 1984. Models and fisheries: A case study in implementation.North American Journal of Fisheries Management 4:9–14.
Holling, C. S. 1978. Adaptive environmental assessment and management. John Wiley & Sons, New York.
Keen, P. G. W., and M. S. S. Morton. 1978. Decision support systems: An organizational perspective. Addison-Wesley, Reading, Massachusetts.
Keeny, R. L. 1977. A utility function for examining policy affecting salmon on the Skeena river.Journal of Fisheries Resources Board of Canada 34:49–63.
Kettela, E. G. 1975. Aerial spraying for protection of forests infested by spruce budworm.The Forestry Chronicle 51(4):141–142.
Korten, D. C. 1981. The management of social transformation.Public Administration Review 41(6):609–618.
Korten, D. C. 1982. Community organization and rural development: A learning process approach.Public Administration Review 42(5):480–511.
Kuhn, T. S. 1970. The structure of scientific revolution. University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
Lee, K. N. 1989. Columbia river basin: Experimenting with sustainability.Environment 31(6):7–10, 30–33.
Lee, K. N. 1991a. Rebuilding confidence: Salmon, science, and law in the Columbia basin.Environmental Law 21:745–805.
Lee, K. N. 1991b. Unconventional power: Energy efficiency and environmental rehabilitation under the northwest power act.Annual Review of Energy and the Environment 16:337–364.
Lee, K. N. 1993. Compass and gyroscope: Integrating science and politics for the environment. Island Press, Washington, DC.
Lee, K. N., and J. Lawrence. 1986. Adaptive management: Learning from the Columbia river basin fish and wildlife program.Environmental Law 16:431–460.
Lee, R. G. 1992. Ecologically effective social organization as a requirement for sustaining watershed ecosystems. Pages 73–90in B. Naiman (ed.), Watershed management: Balancing sustainability and environmental change. Springer-Verlag, New York.
Lee, R. G., R. Flamm, M. G. Turner, C. Bledsoe, P. Chandler, C. Deferrari, R. Gottfried, R. J. Naiman, N. Schumaker, and D. Wear. 1992. Integrating sustainable development and environmental vitality. Pages 499–521in B. Naiman (ed.), Watershed management: Balancing sustainability and environmental change. Springer-Verlag, New York.
May, E. 1978. The forest eater: Have we lost the insecticide war?Nature Canada 7(2):11–15.
McGovern, T. H., G. Bigelow, T. Amorosi, and D. Russell. 1988. Northern islands, human error, and environmental degradation: A view of social and ecological change in the medieval North Atlantic.Human Ecology 16(3):225–270.
Miller, A. 1985. Psychosocial origins of conflict over pest control strategies.Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment 12:235–251.
Miller, A. 1993a. The role of analytical science in natural resource decision making.Environmental Management 17(5):563–574.
Miller, A. 1993b. The role of citizen scientist in nature resource decision-making: Lessons from the spruce budworm problem in Canada.The Environmentalist 13(1):47–59.
Miller, A. and W. Cuff. 1986. The delphi approach to the mediation of environmental disputes.Environmental Management 10(3):321–330.
Mintzberg, H. 1980. Beyond implementation: An analysis of the resistance to policy analysis.Infor 18(2):100–138.
Moore, S. A. 1994. Interaction processes and the resolution of environmental disputes: Case studies from public land planning in the United States and Australia. PhD dissertation. University of Washington, Seattle, Washington.
NWPPC (Northwest Power Planning Council). 1982. Columbia river basin fish and wildlife program. Northwest Power Planning Council, Portland, Oregon.
NWPPC (Northwest Power Planning Council). 1984. Columbia river basin fish and wildlife program. Northwest Power Planning Council, Portland, Oregon.
NWPPC (Northwest Power Planning Council). 1987. Work plan for system planning: July 16, 1987. Northwest Power Planning Council, Portland, Oregon.
Peterman, R. M. 1977. Graphical evaluation of environmetal management options: Examples from a forest-insect pest system.Ecological Modelling 3:133–148.
Pinkerton, E. 1989. Rural resource planning in coastal British Columbia: Can fishing communities plan the future of their fisheries?Plan Canada 29(2):80–86.
Platt, J. R. 1964. Strong inference.Science 16:347–353.
Public Law 96–501. 1980. Pacific northwest electric power planning and conservation act of 1980. US Congress, Washington, DC.
Rayner, J. and D. Peerla. 1987. The spruce budworm spray controversy in Canada: Foresters' perceptions of power and conflict in the policy process. Pages 213–231in M. L. Miller, R. P. Gale, and P. J. Brown (eds.), Social science in natural resource management systems. Westview Press, Boulder, Colorado.
Shannon, M. A. 1987. Forest planning: Learning with people. Pages 233–247in M. L. Miller, R. P. Gale, and P. J. Brown (eds.), Social science in natural resource management systems. Westview Press, Boulder, Colorado.
Sheehan, S. W. and S. O. Russell. 1978. Application of decision theory to salmon management.Water Resources Research 14(5):976–980.
Thierauf, R. J. and R. C. Klekamp. 1975. Decision making through operations research. John Wiley & Sons, New York.
Timmerman, P. 1986. Mythology and surprise in the sustainable development of the biosphere. Pages 435–453in W. C. Clark and R. E. Munn (eds.), Sustainable development of the biosphere. Cambridge University Press, New York.
Turner, M. G., D. N. Wear, and R. O. Flamm. 1994. Landownership and land cover dynamics in the southern Appalachian highlands and Olympic peninsula.Ecological Applications (in press).
Uwadia, F. E. 1990. Creativity and innovation in organizations: Two models and managerial implications.Technological Forecasting and Social Change 38:65–80.
Volkmann, J. M. and W. E. McConnaha. 1992. Through a glass darkly: Columbia river salmon, the endangered species act and adaptive management. Conference on watershed resources: Balancing environmental, social, political and economic factors in large basins. Oregon State University College of Fisheries and the University of Washington Center for Streamside Studies. 14–16 October 1992.
Walker, G. B., and S. E. Daniels. 1994. Collaborative learning and the mediation of natural resources disputes. Draft manuscript.
Walters, C. 1986. Adaptive management of renewable resources. Macmillan, New York.
Walters, C. and B. Riddell. 1986. Multiple objectives in salmon management: The chinook sport fishery in the strait of Georgia, B.C.Northwest Environmental Journal 2(1):1–15.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
McLain, R.J., Lee, R.G. Adaptive management: Promises and pitfalls. Environmental Management 20, 437–448 (1996). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01474647
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01474647