Abstract
Although the police have long been recognized as a community health resource in the United States, this role has expanded significantly over the past several decades as a result of the deinstitutionalization movement. From a critical perspective, this article provides an analysis of the relationship between this enlarged police role and the current American socio-political order, in general, and the welfare state in particular. It is argued that in the course of handling the mentally ill the police carry out a number of functions for both the welfare state and the socio-political order, and in doing so, shore-up the social conditions which have inhibited the development of a positive, long-term care policy for the mentally ill. This article discusses three such functions and identifies an alternative social arrangement; one in which the police would not have to serve as a support for liberal-capitalism and its attendant inadequate welfare state.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes and references
Teplin, L., “Criminalizing Mental Disorders: The Comparative Arrest Rate for the Mentally Ill,”American Psychologist, 1984a (39∶7) 794–803.
Bittner, E., “Police Discretion in Emergency Apprehension of Mentally Ill Persons,”Social Problems, 1967 (14:3), 278–292.
Hanewicz, W., L. Fransway and M. O'Neill, “Improving the Linkages between Community Mental Health and the Police,”Journal of Police Science and Administration, 1982 (10:2), 218–223; D. Kalinich and J. Senese, “Police Discretion and the Mentally Disordered in Chicago: A Reconsideration,”Police Studies, 1987 (10:4), 185–191; Teplin, L., 1984a, op. cit. “Criminalizing Mental Disorders: The Comparative Arrest Rate for the Mentally Ill,”American Psychologist, (39:7), 794–803.
Bonovitz, J. and J. Bonovitz, “Diversion of the Mentally Ill into the Criminal Justice System: The Police Intervention Perspective,”American Journal of Psychiatry, 1981 (138:7), 973–976; Finn, P., “Dealing with Street People: The Social Service Systems Can Help,”The Police Chief, 1988 (55:2), 47–51; Teplin, L., 1984a, op. cit. “Criminalizing Mental Disorders: The Comparative Arrest Rate for the Mentally Ill,”American Psychologist, (39:7), 974–803.
.
; Fischer, P. “Criminal Activity among the Homeless: A Study of Arrests in Baltimore,”Hospital and Community Psychiatry, 1988 (39:1), 46–51; Teplin, L. (ed.),Mental Health and Criminal Justice (Beverly Hills: Sage Publications, 1984b).
Arcaya, J., “The Police and the Emotionally Disturbed: A Psychoanalytic Theory of Intervention,”International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology, 1989 (33:1), 37–48.
Finn, P. and M. Sullivan,Police Response to Special Populations (Washington, D.C., National Institute of Justice, 1987), Finn, P. and M. Sullivan, “Police Handling of the Mentally Ill: Sharing Responsibility with the Mental Health System,”Journal of Criminal Justice, 1989 (7), 1–14.
Bonsignore, J., E. Katsh, P. Errico, R. Pipkin, S. Arons and J. Rifkin,Before the Law: An Introduction to the Legal Process (Dallas, Houghton Mufflic Co.: 1979, 2nd ed.), 163.
Morrissey, J., “Deinstitutionalizing the Mentally Ill: Process, Outcomes, and New Directions,” in W. Groves (ed.),Deviance and Mental Illness (Beverly Hills: Sage Publications, 1982).
Elpers, J., “Are We Legislating Reinstitutionalization?”American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 1987 (57:3), 441–446; Ibid.; Williams, D., E. Bellis and S. Wellington, “Deinstitutionalization and Social Policy: Historical Perspective and Present Dilemmas,”American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 1980 (50:1), 54–64.
.
Kiesler, C., T. McGuire, D. Mechanic, L. Mosher, S. Nelson, F. Newman, R. Rich and H. Schulberg, “Federal Mental Health Policy Making: An Assessment of Deinstitutionalization,”American Psychologist, 1983 (December), 1292–1297.
Scull, A.,Decarceration: Community Treatment and the Deviant—A Radical View (New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press, 1984, 2nd ed.).
.
Braun, P., G. Kochansky, R. Shapiro, S. Greenberg, J. Gudeman, S. Johnson and M. Shore, “Deinstitutionalization of Psychiatric Patients: A Critical Review of Outcome Studies,”American Journal of Psychiatry, 1981 (138), 736–749 at 739.
Lovell, A. and N. Scheper-Hughes, “Deinstitutionalization and Psychiatric Expertise: Reflections on Dangerousness, Deviancy, and Madness,”International Journal of Law and Psychiatry, 1986 (9), 361–381.
Goffman, E.,Asylums: Essays on the Social Situation of Mental Patients and Other Inmates (New York: Harper and Row, 1961); Szasz, T.,The Myth of Mental Illness (New York: Harper and Row, 1961).
.
; Pepper, B. and H. Ryglewicz, “Testimony for the Neglected: The Mentally Ill in the Post-Deinstitutionalized Age,”American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 1982 (52:3), 388–392.
.
. ; Ibid. Pepper, B. and H. Ryglewicz, 1982, “Testimony for the Neglected: The Mentally Ill in the Post-Deinstitutionalized Age,”American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 1982 (52:3), 388–392.
Kiesler, A. and E. Sibulkin,Mental Hospitalization: Myths and Facts about a National Crisis (New Bury Park, CA: Sage, 1987).
.
.
Pepper, B. and H. Ryglewicz, 1982,.
Scull, A., “Deinstitutionalization and Public Policy,”Social Science Medical, 1985 (20:5), 545–552.
Torrey, E.,Nowhere to Go: The Tragic Odyssey of the Homeless Mentally Ill (New York: Harper and Row, 1988).
Bachrach, L., “The Homeless Mentally Ill and Mental Health Services: An Analytical Review of the Literature,” in H. R. Lamb (ed.),The Homeless Mentally Ill (Washington, D.C.: American Psychiatric Association, 1984).
Test, R., “Effective Community Treatment and the Chronically Mentally Ill: What is Necessary?”Journal of Social Issues, 1981 (37), 71–86.
Torrey, E., 1988,.
Goldman, H., A. Gattozzi and A. Taube, “Defining and Counting the Chronically Mentally Ill,”Hospital and Community Psychiatry, 1981 (32), 21–27.
Scull, A., 1985,.
Lovell, A. and N. Scheper-Hughes, 1986,, 364.
Martin, G.,Social Policy in the Welfare State (New Jersey: Prentice Hall, 1990).
Torrey, E., 1988,.
Kiesler, C., T. McGuire, D. Mechanic, L. Mosher, S. Nelson, F. Newman, R. Rich and H. Schulberg, 1983,.
Lovell, A. and N. Scheper-Hughes, 1986,.
Torrey, E., 1988,.
Lovell, A. and N. Scheper-Hughes, 1986,.
Finn, P. and M. Sullivan, 1989,.; Teplin, L., 1984a, op. cit. “Criminalizing Mental Disorders: The Comparative Arrest Rate for the Mentally Ill,”American Psychologist, (39:7), 794–803.
Bittner, E., 1967,.
Kalinich, D. and J. Senese, 1987,; Teplin, L., W. Filstead, G. Hefter and E. Sheridan, “Police involvement with the Psychiatric-Emergency Patient,”Psychiatric Annals, 1980 (10:5), 46–54.
Fox, R. and P. Erickson,Apparently Suffering From Mental Disorder (Toronto, Canada: University of Toronto, 1976) cited in L. Teplin (ed.),Mental Health and Criminal Justice (Beverly Hills: Sage Publications, 1984b), 148.
Bittner, E., 1967,.
Arcaya, J., 1989,.
Bittner, E., 1967,. Teplin, L., W. Filstead, G. Hefter and E. Sheridan, 1980, op. cit. “Police involvement with the Psychiatric-Emergency Patient,”Psychiatric Annals, 1980 (10:5), 46–54.
Kalinich, D. and J. Senese, 1987,.
Ibid.; Teplin, L., 1984a, op. cit.; Teplin, L., 1984b, op. cit.. Whitmer, G.: “From Hospitals to Jails: The Fate of California's Deinstitutionalization Mentally Ill,”American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 1980 (50:1), 65–75.
Bonovitz, J. and J. Bonovitz, 1981, op. cit.;
Whitmer, G., 1980, op. cit..
Bonovitz, J. and J. Bonovitz, 1981, op. cit.; Teplin, L., 1984a, op. cit..
Kalinich, D. and J. Senese, 1987, op. cit.; Monahan, J., C. Caldeira and H. Friedlander, “Police and the Mentally Ill: A Comparison of Committed and Arrested Persons,”International Journal of Law and Psychiatry, 1979 (2), 509–518; Teplin, L., 1984a, op. cit..
Monahan, J., C. Caldeira and H. Friedlander, 1979, op. cit.;
Arcaya, J., 1989 op. cit..
Finn, P. and M. Sullivan, 1987, ; Finn, P. and M. Sullivan, 1989, op. cit. Finn. P. and M. Sullivan, “Police Handling of the Mentally Ill: Sharing Responsibility with the Mental Health System”Journal of Criminal Justice 1989 (7), 1–14.
Galper, J.,The Politics of Social Services (New Jersey Prentice-Hall, 1975), 9.
Esping-Anderson, G., “After the Welfare State,Public Welfare, 1983 (Winter), 28–34.
Bureau of Census,Measuring the effects of Benefits and Taxes on Income and Property: Current Populations Reports, Series P-60, No. 169-RD (Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1990).
Krugman, P.,The Age of Diminished Expectations: U.S. Economic Policy in the 1990s (Washington: The Washington Post Publishing Co., 1990).
Galper, J., 1975, op. cit..
.
Mullaly, R., Structural Social Work: Ideology, Theory and Practice (Unpublished Manuscript, 1991).
Marchak, P.,Ideological Perspectives on Canada (Toronto: McGraw-Hill Ryerson, 1975).
Mullaly, R., 1991, op. cit. Structural Social Work: Ideology, Theory and Practice (Unpublished Manuscript, 1991).
Ibid. Mullaly, R., Structural Social Work: Ideology, Theory and Practice (Unpublished Manuscript, 1991).
Titmuss, R.,Essays on the Welfare State (London: Allen and Unwin, 1958).
Esping-Anderson, G., 1983, op. cit..
Martin, G., 1990, op. cit..
Andrian, C.,Social Policies in Western Industrial Societies (Berkeley, Institute of International Studies, University of California, 1985).
Weir, M., A. Orloff and T. Skocpol (eds.),The Politics of Social Policy in the United States (New Jersey: Princeton University Press, 1988).
Department of Health and Human Services,Monthly Benefits Statistics: Summary Program Data, No. 12 (Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1986).
Day, P.,A New History of Social Welfare (New Jersey: Prentice-Hall, 1989).
Fuerst J. (ed.),Public Housing in Europe and America (London: Croom Helm, 1974) cited in R. Mishra,Society and Social Policy: Theories and Practice of Welfare (New Jersey: Humanities Press, 1981, 2nd ed.).
HOUSING NOW!, “Homeless Fact Sheet,” 1989, April cited in G. Barak, “Homelessness and the Case for Community-Based Initiatives: The Emergence of Model Shelter as a Short-Term Response to the Deepening Crisis in Housing,” in H. Pepinsky and R. Quinney (eds.),Criminology as Peacemaking (Bloomington, Indiana: Indiana University press, 1991).
Esping-Anderson, G., 1983 op. cit..
Teplin, L., “The Prevalence of Severe Mental Disorder Among Male Urban Jail Detainees: Comparison with the Epidemiologic Catchment Area Program,”American Journal of PUblic Health, 1990 (80:6), 663–669; Palermo, G., M. Smith and F. Liska, “Jails Versus Mental Hospitals: A Social Dilemma,”International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology, 1991 (35:2), 97–106.
Teplin, L., 1984a, op. cit..
Aulette, J. and A. Aulette, “Police Harassment of the Homeless: The Political Purpose of the Criminalization of the Homeless,”Humanity and Society, 1987 (11:2), 244–256; Fischer, P., 1988, op. cit..
Finn, P., 1988, op. cit., 49.
Aulette, J. and A. Aulette, 1988, op. cit. Fischer, P., 1988, op. cit.
Olivero, M., “Police Linkage with Community Mental Health Centers in the Management of Criminal Justice-Mental Health Emergencies,”Journal of Police and Criminal psychology, 1990 (6:2), 8–13.
Snow, D., S. Baker and L. Anderson, “Criminality and Homeless Men: An Empirical Assessment,”Social Problems, 1989 (36:5), 532–549.
Aulette, J. and A. Aulette, 1988, op. cit..
.
Fischer, P., 1988, op. cit.; Whitmer, G., 1980, op. cit..
Lurigio, A. and D. Lewis, “Worlds that Fail: A Longitudinal Study of Urban Mental Patients,”Journal of Social Issues, 1989 (45:3), 79–90.
Barak, G. and R. Bohm, “The Crimes of the Homeless or the Crime of Homelessness? On the Dialectics of Criminalization, Decriminalization, and Victimization,”Contemporary Crisis, 1989 (13:3), 275–288.
Gil, D., “Work, Violence, Injustice, and War,”Journal of Sociology and Social Welfare, 1989 (16:1), 39–53 at 48.
Finn, P. and M. Sullivan, 1987, op. cit.; Finn, P. and M. Sullivan, 1989, op. cit..
Rein, M. and D. Schon, “Problem Setting in Policy Research,” in C. Weiss (ed.)Using Social Research in Public Policy Making (Lexington, Mass Lexington Books, 1977).
, 244.
Torrey, E., 1988, op. cit..
.
Pepper, B. and H. Ryglewicz, 1982, op. cit..
Torrey, E., 1988, op. cit..
Reamer, R., “The Affordable Housing Crisis and Social Work,”Social Work: Journal of the National Association of Social Workers, 1989 (34:1), 5–9.
Blau, J., “The Limits of the Welfare State: New York City's Response to Homelessness,”Journal of Sociology and Social Welfare (16:1), 79–91.
Martin, G., 1990, op. cit..
Finn, P. and M. Sullivan, 1987, op. cit.; Finn, P. and M. Sullivan, 1989, op. cit..
Galper, J., 1975, op. cit..; George, V. and P. Wilding,Ideology and Social Welfare (London: Routledge and Kegan, 1976).
Barak, G. and R. Bohm, 1989, op. cit..
Nove, A., “Socialism-Why?” in H. McCullough (ed.),Political Ideologies and Political Philosophies (Toronto: Thompson Educational Publishing, Inc., 1989).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Wachholz, S., Mullaly, R. Policing the deinstitutionalized mentally ill: Toward an understanding of its function. Crime Law Soc Change 19, 281–300 (1993). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01844063
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01844063