Abstract
Introduction
Employment discrimination is considered as a major impediment to community integration for people with serious mental illness, yet little is known about how the problem manifests differently across western and non-western societies. We developed a lay model based on Chinese beliefs and values in terms of Confucianism, Taoism, Buddhism, and folk religions which may be used to explain cross-cultural variation in mental illness stigma, particularly in the arena of employment discrimination. In this study, we tested this lay approach by comparing employers’ concerns about hiring people with psychotic disorder for entry-level jobs in US and China.
Method
One hundred employers (40 from Chicago, 30 from Hong Kong, and 30 from Beijing) were randomly recruited from small size firms and interviewed by certified interviewers using a semi-structured interview guide designed for this study. Content analysis was used to derive themes, which in turn were compared across the three sites using chi-square tests.
Results
Analyses reveal that employers express a range of concerns about hiring an employee with mental illness. Although some concerns were raised with equal frequency across sites, comparisons showed that, relative to US employers, Chinese employers were significantly more likely to perceive that people with mental illness would exhibit a weaker work ethic and less loyalty to the company. Comparison of themes also suggests that employers in China were more people-oriented while employers in US were more task-oriented.
Conclusion
Cultural differences existed among employers which supported the lay theory of mental illness.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Andresen R, Oades L, Caputi P (2003) The experience of recovery from schizophrenia: towards an empirically validated stage model. Aust N Z J Psychiatry 37:586–594
Anthony W, Blanch AA (1987) Supported employment for persons who are psychiatrically disabled: an historical and conceptual perspective. Psychosoc Rehabil J 11:5–23
Anthony WA, Jansen MA (1984) Predicting the vocational capacity of the chronically mentally ill: research and policy implications. Am Psychol 39:537–544
Baldwin ML, Marcus SC (2006) Perceived and measured stigma among workers with serious mental illness. Psychiatr Serv 57:388–392
Baron RC, Salzer MS (2002) Accounting for unemployment among people with mental illness. Behav Sci Law 20:585–599
Bordieri JE, Drehmer DE (1986) Hiring decisions for disabled workers: looking at the cause. J Appl Soc Psychol 16:197–208
Brockington IF, Hall P, Levings J, et al. (1993) The community tolerance of the mentally ill. Br J Psychiatry 162:93–99
Chan F, Hedl J, Parker HJ, Chan TN, Yu B (1988) Differential attitudes of Chinese students toward people with disabilities: a cross-cultural perspective. Int J Soc Psychiatry 34:267-273
Chan F, Hua MS, Ju JJ, Lam CS (1984) Factorial structure of the Chinese scale of attitudes towards disabled persons: a cross-cultural validation. Int J Rehabil Res 7:317–337
Chan F, Lam CS, Wong DW, Leung P, Fang XS (1988) Counseling Chinese Americans with disabilities. J Appl Rehabil Couns 19:21–25
Cheung FM (1988) Surveys of community attitudes toward mental health facilities: reflections or provocations. Am J Community Psychol 16:877–882
Cheung FM (1990) People against the mentally ill: community opposition to residential treatment facilities. Community Ment Health J 26:205–212
Chueng LCC, Tsang HWH (2005) Factor structure of essential social skills to be salespersons in retail market: implications for psychiatric rehabilitation. J Behav Ther Exp Psychiatry 36:265–280
Cohen J, Struening EL (1962) Opinions about mental illness in the personnel of two large hospitals. J Abnorm Soc Psychol 64:349–360
Cook JA (2006) Employment barriers for persons with psychiatric disabilities: Updated of a report for the president’s commission. Psychiatr Serv 57:1391–1405
Cook JA, Razzano L (2000) Vocational rehabilitation for persons with schizophrenia: recent research and implications for practice. Schizophr Bull 26:87–103
Cook JA, Razzano LA, Straiton DM, Ross Y (1994) Cultivation and maintenance of relationships with employers of people with psychiatric disabilities. Psychosoc Rehabil J 17:103–116
Corrigan P, Markowitz FE, Watson A, Rowan D, Kubiak MA (2003) An attribution model of public discrimination towards persons with mental illness. J Health Soc Behav 44:162–179
Corrigan PW, Salzer M, Ralph RO, Sangster Y, Keck L (2004) Examining the factor structure of the recovery assessment scale. Schizophr Bull 30:1035–1041
Corrigan PW, Slopen N, Gracia G, Phelan S, Keogh CB, Keck L (2005) Some recovery processes in mutual-help groups for persons with mental illness; II: qualitative analysis of participant interviews. Community Ment Health J 41:1035–1041
Corrigan PW, Watson AC (2002) The paradox of self-stigma and mental illness. Clin Psychol Sci Pract 9:35–53
Diksa E, Rogers ES (1996) Employer concerns about hiring persons with psychiatric disability: results of the employer attitude questionnaire. Rehabil Couns Bull 40:31–44
Farina A, Felner RD (1973) Employment interviewer reactions to former mental patients. J Abnorm Psychol 82:268–272
Feldman D (1988) Employing physically and mentally impaired employees. Personnel 65:14–15
Fogel J, Ford DE (2005) Stigma beliefs of Asian Americans with depression in an internet sample. Can J Psychiatry 50:470–478
Fung KMT, Tsang HWH, Corrigan PW, Lam CS (in press) Measuring self-stigma of mental illness in China and its implications for recovery. Int J Soc Psychiatry
Fung MT (2006) Relationship between self-stigma of people with psychotic disorder and their adherence to psychosocial treatment. Unpublished master’s thesis, The Hong Kong Polytechnic University, Hong Kong
Furnham A, Chan E (2004) Lay theories of schizophrenia: a cross-cultural comparison of British and Hong Kong Chinese attitudes, attributions and beliefs. Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol 39:543–552
Goffman E (1963) Notes on the management of spoiled identity. NJ: Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs
Hand C, Tryssenaar J (2006) Small business employers’ views on hiring individuals with mental illness. Psychiatr Rehabil J 29:166–173
Hernandez B, Keys C (2000) Employer attitudes toward workers with disabilities and their ADA employment rights: a literature review. J Rehabil 66:4–16
Johnson-Dalzine P, Dalzine L, Martin-Stanley C (1996) Fear of criminal violence and the African American elderly: assessment of a crime prevention strategy. J Negro Educ 65:462–469
Jorm AF (2000) Mental health literacy–Public knowledge and beliefs about mental disorders. Br J Psychiatry 177:396–401
Jorm AF, Korten AE, Jacomb PA, Christensen H, Rodgers B, Pollitt P (1997) “Mental health literacy”: a survey of the public’s ability to recognise mental disorders and their beliefs about the effectiveness of treatment. Med J Aust 166:182–186
Killackey EJ, Jackson HJ, Gleeson J, Hickie IB, McGorry PD (2006) Exciting career opportunity beckons! Early intervention and vocational rehabilitation in first-episode psychosis: employing cautious optimism. Aust N Z J Psychiatry 40:951–962
King AYC, Bond MH (1985) The Confucian paradigm of man: a sociological view. In: Tseng WS, Wu DYH (eds) Chinese culture and mental health. Academic Press, New York
Kopelowicz A, Aguirre F, Liberman RP, Mintz J, Wallace CJ (2006) Differential performance of job skills in schizophrenia: an experimental analysis. J Rehabil 72:31–39
Lee YT, Jussim L, McCauley C (1995) Stereotype accuracy: toward appreciating group differences. The American Psychological Association, Washington DC
Lin YT (1983) The Wisdom of confucius. Modern library, New York
Link BG (1982) Mental patient status, work, and income: an examination of the effects of a psychiatric label. Am Sociol Rev 47:202–215
Link BG (1987) Understanding labelling effects in the area of mental disorders: an assessment of the effects of expectations of rejection. Am Sociol Rev 52:96–112
Link BG, Phelan JC, Bresnahan M, Stueve A, Pescosolido BA (1999) Public conceptions of mental illness: labels, causes, dangerousness, and social distance. Am J Public Health 89:1328–1333
Manning C, White PD (1995) Attitudes of employers to the mentally ill. Psychiatr Bull R Coll Psychiatr 19:541–543
Olshanksy S, Grob S, Ekdahl M (1960) Survey of employment experience of patients discharged from three mental hospitals during the period 1951–1953. Ment Hyg 44:510–521
Pearson V (1995) Mental health care in China: state policies, professional services and family responsibilities. Gaskell, London
Pescosolido BA, Monahan J, Link BG, Stueve A, Kikuzawa S (1999) The public’s view of the competence, dangerousness, and need for legal coercion of persons with mental health problems. Am J Public Health 89:1339–1345
Provencher HL, Gregg R, Mead S, Mueser KT (2002) The role of work in the recovery of persons with psychiatric disabilities. Psychiatr Rehabil J 26:132–144
Raguram R, Raghu TM, Vounatsou P, Weiss MG (2004) Schizophrenia and the cultural epidemiology of Stigma in Bangalore, India. J Nerv Ment Dis 192:734–744
Resnick SG, Fontana A, Lehman AF, Rosenheck RA (2005) An empirical conceptualization of the recovery orientation. Schizophr Res 75:119–128
Rochlin J (1987) Rehabilitation: an employer’s perspective. Rehabil Educ, 1:89–94
Scheid TL (2005) Stigma as a barrier to employment: mental disability and the Americans with disabilities act. Int J Law Psychiatry 28:670–690
Schiff AC (2004) Recovery and mental illness: analysis and personal reflections. Psychiatr Rehabil J 27:212–218
Srinivasan L, Tirupati S (2005) Relationship between cognition and work functioning among patients with schizophrenia in an urban area of India. Psychiatr Serv 56:1423–1428
Tan CT, Chee KT, Leung FY (1981) Psychiatric patients who seek traditional healers in Singapore. Singapore Med J 22:643–647
Taylor SM, Dear MJ (1981) Scaling community attitudes toward the mentally-ill. Schizophr Bull 7:225–240
Thomas TD, Thomas G, Joiner JG (1993) Issues in the vocational rehabilitation of persons with serious and persistent mental illness: a national survey of counselor insights. Psychosoc Rehabil J 16:129–134
Tsang HWH, Chen EYH Perceptions on remission and recovery in schizophrenia. Psychopathology (in press)
Tsang H, Lam P, Ng B, Leung O (2000) Predictors of employment outcome of people with psychiatric disabilities: a review of the literature since mid 80s. J Rehabil 66:19–31
Tsang HWH, Ng B, Chiu F (2002) Job profiles of people with schizophrenia: implications for rehabilitation. Int J Rehabil Res 25:189–196
Tsang HWH, Tam P, Chan F, Cheung WM (2003) Stigmatizing attitudes towards individuals with mental illness in Hong Kong: implications to their recovery. J Community Psychol 31:383–396
Tsang H, Weng YZ, Tam P (2000) Needs and problems related to mental health services in Beijing. Psychiatr Rehabil Skills 4:1–21
Waghorn G, Lewis S (2002) Disclosure of psychiatric disabilities in vocational rehabilitation. Aust J Rehabil Couns 8:67–80
Waghorn G, Lloyd C (2005) The employment if people with mental illness. AeJAMH 4:1446–1798
Wahl O (1999) Mental health consumers’ experience of stigma. Schizophr Bull 25:467–478
Wansborough N, Cooper P (1980) Open employment after psychotic disorder. Tavistock Publications, London
Webber A, Orcutt J (1984) Employers’ reactions to racial and psychiatric stigma: a field experiment. Deviant Behav 5:327–336
Weiner B (1980) A cognitive (attribution)-emotion-action model of motivated behavior: a analysis of judgments of help giving. J Pers Soc Psychol 39:186–200
Weiner B (1983) Some methodological pitfalls in attributional research. J Educ Psychol 75:530–543
Weiner B (1985) An attributional theory of achievement motivation and emotion. Psychol Rev 92:548–573
Weiner B (1993) On sin versus sickness: a theory of perceived responsibility and social motivation. Am Psychol 48:957–965
Weiner B (1995) Judgments of responsibility: a foundation for a theory of social conduct. Guiford Press, New York
Weiss MG (1997) The explanatory model interview catalogue (EMIC). Framework for comparative study of illness. Transcult Psychiatry 34:235–263
Weiss MG, Sharma SD, Gaur RK, Sharma JS, Desai A, Doongaji DR (1986) Traditional concepts of mental disorder among Indian psychiatric patients: preliminary report of work in progress. Soc Sci Med 23:379–386
Wilgosh L, Skaret D (1987) Employer attitudes toward hiring individuals with disabilities: a review of the recent literature. Can J Rehabil 1:89–98
Acknowledgments
This study was supported by a grant referenced AA014842-01 from the U.S. National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism, the National Institute of Mental Health, and the Fogarty International Center. We are also grateful to Natalie Slopen, Ellen Chan, Lin Lin, Xioalu Wang, Zhen Wang, Xiaopeng Rui, Bei Liu, Menglei Shi, Yang Ye, and Yi Wang for interviewing the employers.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Tsang, H.W., Angell, B., Corrigan, P.W. et al. A cross-cultural study of employers’ concerns about hiring people with psychotic disorder: implications for recovery. Soc Psychiat Epidemiol 42, 723–733 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00127-007-0208-x
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00127-007-0208-x