Abstract
The finding that early detection of permanent congenital childhood hearing loss produces worthwhile benefit in terms of improved speech and language provides the rationale for the universal screening of newborns. The aim of the present study is to collect the current evidence with regard to the efficacy, the results and outcomes of universal hearing screening programs. An extensive search of the literature was performed in Medline and other available database sources. Study selection was based on the evaluation of the protocols used and the assessment of their efficacy in the early diagnosis of congenital hearing impairment. The initial referral rate and the rate of false positives were also evaluated. A total of 676,043 screened children have been identified in 20 studies. The average initial referral rate in these studies was 3.89%. The initial referral rate varied from 0.6 to 16.7%. The lost-to-follow-up rates varied from 3.7 to 65%. Although universal hearing screening is now widely adopted, there are still some serious drawbacks and limitations. False positives rates remain considerably high when newborns are screened with TEOAE’s. The combination of TEOAE’s and a-ABR provides a significantly reduced referral rate. Close cooperation between audiological centres and maternity units and a dedicated secretariat team are of paramount importance with regard to the reliability and efficacy of universal hearing screening.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Shah VA, Yeo CL (2007) Identifying risk of neonatal hyperbilirubinaemia and early discharge for glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase deficient newborns in Singapore. Ann Acad Med Singap 36(12):1003–1009
Geelhoed EA, Lewis B, Hounsome D, O’leary P (2005) Economic evaluation of neonatal screening for phenylketonuria and congenital hypothyroidism. J Paediatr Child Health 41(11):575–579
Thompson DC, McPhillips H, Davis RL, Lieu TL, Homer CJ, Helfand M (2001) Universal newborn hearing screening: summary of evidence. JAMA 286(16):2000–2010
Seymour CA, Thomason MJ, Chalmers RA et al (1997) Newborn screening for inborn errors of metabolism: a systematic review. Health Technol Assess 1(11):i–iv, 1–95
Korres S, Nikolopoulos TP, Peraki EE et al (2008) Outcomes and efficacy of newborn hearing screening: strengths and weaknesses (success or failure?). Laryngoscope 118(7):1253–1256
Yoshinaga-Itano C, Apuzzo ML (1998) The development of deaf and hard of hearing children identified early through the high-risk registry. Am Ann Deaf 143(5):416–424
Yoshinaga-Itano C, Apuzzo ML (1998) Identification of hearing loss after age 18 months is not early enough. Am Ann Deaf 143(5):380–387
Yoshinaga-Itano C, Sedey AL, Coulter DK, Mehl AL (1998) Language of early- and later-identified children with hearing loss. Pediatrics 102(5):1161–1171
Yoshinaga-Itano C (2003) Early intervention after universal neonatal hearing screening: impact on outcomes. Ment Retard Dev Disabil Res Rev 9(4):252–266
Lin HC, Shu MT, Chang KC, Bruna SM (2002) A universal newborn hearing screening program in Taiwan. Int J Pediatr Otorhinolaryngol 63(3):209–218
Aidan D, Avan P, Bonfils P (1999) Auditory screening in neonates by means of transient evoked otoacoustic emissions: a report of 2,842 recordings. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol 108(6):525–531
Capua A, Constantini D, Martufi C et al (2007) Universal hearing screening: the Siena (Italy) experience on 19,700 newborns. Early Hum Dev 83:601–606
Uilenburg N, Kaufmann-de Boer M, Van der Ploeg K et al (2009) An implementation study of neonatal hearing screening in Netherlands. Int J Audiol 48:108–116
Mason JA, Herrmann KR (1999) Universal infant hearing screening by automated auditory brainstem response measurement. Pediatrics 103(3):670–672
Clemens CJ, Davis SA, Bailey AR (2000) The false-positive in universal newborn hearing screening. Pediatrics 106(1):E7
Lin HC, Shu MT, Lee KS, Lin HY, Lin G (2007) Reducing false positives in newborn hearing screening program: how and why. Otol Neurotol 28(6):788–792
Lam BC (2006) Newborn hearing screening in Hong Kong. Hong Kong Med J 12(3):212–218
(1998) Controlled trial of universal neonatal screening for early identification of permanent childhood hearing impairment. Wessex Universal Neonatal Hearing Screening Trial Group. Lancet 352(9145):1957–1964
Mehl AL, Thomson V (2002) The Colorado newborn hearing screening project, 1992–1999: on the threshold of effective population-based universal newborn hearing screening. Pediatrics 109(1):E7
Kanne TJ, Schaefer L, Perkins JA (1999) Potential pitfalls of initiating a newborn hearing screening program. Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 125(1):28–32
Vohr BR, Carty LM, Moore PE, Letourneau K (1998) The Rhode Island Hearing Assessment Program: experience with statewide hearing screening (1993–1996). J Pediatr 133(3):353–357
Finitzo T, Albright K, O’Neal J (1998) The newborn with hearing loss: detection in the nursery. Pediatrics 102(6):1452–1460
Dalzell L, Orlando M, Prieve B et al (2000) The New York State universal newborn hearing screening demonstration project: ages of hearing loss identification, hearing aid fitting, and enrollment in early intervention. Ear Hear 21(2):118–130
Low WK, Pang KY, Ho LY, Lim SB, Joseph R (2005) Universal newborn hearing screening in Singapore: the need, implementation and challenges. Ann Acad Med Singapore 34(4):301–306
Lagnagne T, Leveque M, Schmidt P, Chays A (2010) Universal newborn hearing screening in the Champagne–Ardenne region: a 4-year follow up after early diagnosis of hearing impairment. Int J Pediatric Otorhinolaryngol 74:1164–1170
Rohlfs AK, Wiesner T, Drews H et al (2010) Interdisciplinary approach to design, performance and quality management in a multicenter newborn hearing screening project. Introduction, methods and results of the newborn hearing screening in Hamburg (Part I). Eur J Pediatr 169:1353–1360
Neumann K, Gross M, Bottcher P et al (2006) Effectiveness and efficiency of a universal newborn hearing screening in Germany. Folia Phoniatr Logop 58:440–455
Ghirri P, Liumbruno A, Lunardi S et al (2011) Universal neonatal audiological screening: experience of the University Hospital of Pisa. Italian J Pediatrics 37:16
Yoshinaga-Itano C (2004) Levels of evidence: universal newborn hearing screening (UNHS) and early hearing detection and intervention systems (EHDI). J Commun Disord 37(5):451–465
Cao-Nguyen MH, Kos MI, Guyot JP (2007) Benefits and costs of universal hearing screening programme. Int J Pediatr Otorhinolaryngol 71(10):1591–1595
Web site of National Centre for Hearing Assessment & Management (NCHAM) Utah State University, Utah. Last modified 11 Apr 2008
Ciorba A, Hatzopoulos S, Busi M, Guerrini P, Petruccelli J, Martini A (2008) The universal newborn hearing screening program at the University Hospital of Ferrara: focus on costs and software solutions. Int J Pediatr Otorhinolaryngol 72(6):807–816
Bottcher P, Gramb M, Euler HA et al (2009) Cost analysis of a universal newborn hearing screening for clinics using the State of Hesse as an example. HNO 57:21–28
Rohlfs AK, Wiesner T, Drews H et al (2010) Interdisciplinary approach to design, performance and quality management in a multicenter newborn hearing screening project. Discussion of the results of newborn hearing in Hamburg (Part II). Eur J Pediatr 169:1453–1463
Erenberg A, Lemons J, Sia C et al (1998) Newborn and infant hearing loss: detection and intervention. American Academy of Pediatrics. Task Force on Newborn and Infant Hearing 1998–1999. Pediatrics 103:527–530
Deutsches Konsensuspapier zu Neugeborenenhorscreening—Programmen 3.0 (2001). (http://www.neugeborenenhorscreening.de)
Finckh-Kramer U, Spormann Lagodzinski M, Nubel K et al (1998) Is diagnosis of persistent pediatric hearing loss still made too late? HNO 46:598–602
Korver A, Konings S, Decker F et al (2010) Newborn hearing screening vs later hearing screening and developmental outcomes in children with permanent childhood hearing impairment. JAMA 304:1701–1708
Stelmachowicz PG, Mace AL, Kopun JG, Carney E (1993) Long -term and short-term characteristics of speech: implications for hearing aid selection for young children. J Speech Hear Res 36(3):609–620
Hatzopoulos S, Petruccelli J, Ciorba A et al (2009) Optimizing otoacoustic emission protocols for a UNHS program. Audiol Neurootol 14:7–16
Sininger Y (2002) Auditory neuropathy in infants: implications on early hearing detection and intervention programs. Audiol Today 16–21
Berg AL, Spitzer JB, Towers HM et al (2005) Newborn hearing screening in the NICU: profile of failed auditory brainstem response/passed otoacoustic emission. Pediatrics 116:933–938
Korres S, Nikolopoulos T, Ferekidis E et al (2003) Otoacoustic emissions in universal hearing screening: which day after birth should we examine the newborns? ORL J Otorhinolaryngol Relat Spec 65:199–201
Nennstiel-Ratzel U, Arenz S, von Kries R et al (2007) The model project “newborn auditory screening” in the Upper Palatinate: high process and result quality of an interdisciplinary concept. HNO 55:128–134
Conflict of interest
None to declare.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Papacharalampous, G.X., Nikolopoulos, T.P., Davilis, D.I. et al. Universal newborn hearing screening, a revolutionary diagnosis of deafness: real benefits and limitations. Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol 268, 1399–1406 (2011). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00405-011-1672-1
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00405-011-1672-1