Abstract
Following Manne (1966, Insider Trading and the Stock Market (New York, Free Press)) we introduce a distinction between insider trading and market manipulation on the one hand and corporate insiders versus misappropriators on the other hand. This gives rise to four types of alleged inside transactions. We argue that the literature on insider trading has often targeted inside transactions type II, III and IV but that these arguments do not necessarily hold for type I transactions. We look for consequentionalist as well as non-consequentionalist arguments against type I transactions and demonstrate that these are hard to find. Throughout the article we refer extensively to the economic literature on insider trading in order to overcome a relative divide between the economic, legal, and philosophical discussion on insider trading.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Aktas, N., E. de Bodt and H. Van Oppens: 2007, Evidence of the Contribution of Legal Insider Trading to Market Efficiency, UCL Core discussion paper 0714
Bainbridge, S.: 2000, ‹Insider Trading’, in B. Bouckaert and G. De Geest (eds.), Encyclopedia of Law and Economics, Volume III, The Regulation of Contracts (Edward Elgar), pp. 772–812
Brudney V. 1979 Insiders, Outsiders and the Informational Advantages Under the Federal Securities Laws. Harvard Law Review 93: 322–376
Carlton D. W. and D. R. Fischel: 1983, The Regulation of Insider Trading, Stanford Law Review 35: 857–895
Chakravarty S., McConnell J. 1997 An Analysis of Prices, Bid/Ask Spreads, and Bid and Ask Depths Surrounding Ivan Boesky’s Illegal Trading in Carnation Stock. Financial Management 26(Summer): 18–34
Cornell B., Morgan 1990 Using Finance Theory to Measure Damages in Fraud on the Market Cases. UCLA Law Review 37: 883–924
Cornell B., Sirri E. 1992 The Reaction of Investors and Stock Prices to Insider Trading. Journal of Finance 47: 1031–1059
Dooley M. P. 1980 Enforcement of Insider Trading Restrictions. Virginia Law Review 66: 1–89
Engelen P. J.: 2005, Remedies to Information Asymmetries in Stosk Markets (Intersentia Publishers, Antwerpen, Oxford) 218 p.
Easterbrook, F.: 1981, ‹Insider Trading, Secret Agents, Evidentiary Privileges, and the Production of Information’, The Supreme Court Review 1981, 309–365
Fischel D. R. 1982 Use of Modern Finance Theory in Securities Fraud Cases Involving Actively Traded Securities. Business Lawyer 38: 1–20
Grossman S. 1986 An Analysis of the Role of Insider Trading on Futures Markets. Journal of Business 59: 129–146
Haddock, D. and J. Macey: 1986a, ‹A Coasian Model of Insider Trading’, Northwestern University Law Review 80, 1449–1472
Haddock, D. and J. Macey: 1986b, ‹Controlling Insider Trading in Europe and America: The Economics of the Politics’, in J. M. Graf von der Schulenberg and F. Skogh (eds.), Law & Economics and the Economics of Legal Regulation (Dordrecht), pp 149–167
Haddock D. D., J. R. Macey 1987 Regulation on Demand: A Private Interest Model, with an Application to Insider Trading Regulation. Journal of Law and Economics 30: 311–352
Haft R. 1982 The Effect of Insider Trading Rules on the Internal Efficiency of the Large Corporation. Michigan Law Review 80: 1051–1071
Healy, P. M. and K.G. Palepu: 1995 The Challenges of Investor Communication. The Case of CUC International, Inc. Journal of Financial Economic 38, 111–140
Holden C., Subrahmanyam A. 1992 Long-Lived Private Information and Imperfect Competition. Journal of Finance 47: 247–270
Irvine W. B. 1987 Insider Trading: An Ethical Appraisal. Business & Professional Ethics Journal 6(4): 3–33
Kabir R., Vermaelen T. 1996 Insider Trading Restrictions and the Stock market: Evidence from the Amsterdam Stock Exchange. European Economic Review 40: 1594–1603
King, M. and A. Roell: 1988, Insider Trading, Economic Policy 6, 165–187
Kitch E. 1980 The Law and Economics of Rights in Valuable Information. Journal of Legal Studies 9: 683–723
Kyle A. 1985 Continuous Auctions and Insider Trading. Econometrica 53: 1315–1336
Lawson G. 1988 The Ethics of Insider Trading. Harvard Journal of Law and Public Policy 11(3): 727–783
Leland, H.: 1992, ‹Insider Trading: Should It be Prohibited?’, Journal of Political Economy 100, 859–887
Levine R. 1997 Financial Development and Economic Growth: Views and Agenda. Journal of Economic Literature 35: 688–726
Levmore S. 1982 Securities and Secrets: Insider Trading and the Law of Contracts. Virginia Law Review 68: 117–160
Ma Y., Sun H. L. 1998 Where Should the Line be Drawn on Insider Trading Ethics. Journal of Business Ethics 17: 67–75
Macey J. R. 1988 Ethics, Economics and Insider Trading: Ayn Rand Meets the Theory of the Firm. Harvard Journal of Law and Public Policy 11: 785
Macey J. R. 1999 Securities Trading: A Contractual Perspective. Case Western Reserve Law Review 50: 269–290
Macey J. R., Kanda 1990 The Stock Exchange as a Firm: The Emergence of Close Substitutes for the New York and Tokyo Stock Exchanges3. Cornell Law Review 76:1007
Machan T. R. 1996 What is Morally Right with Insider Trading. Public Affairs Quarterly 10(2): 135–142
Manne H. G.: 1985, Insider Trading and property rights in new information Cato Journal 4, 933–943
Manne H. G. 1966 Insider Trading and the Stock Market. New York, Free Press
Mendelson: 1969, ‹The Economics of Insider Trading Reconsidered’, University of Pennsylvania Law Review, 117(3), 470–492
Meulbroek, L.: 1992, ‹An Empirical Analysis of Illegal Insider Trading’, Journal of Finance 49, 1661–1699
Moore J. 1990 What is Really Unethical about Insider Trading? Journal of Business Ethics 9: 171–182
Schotland: 1967, ‹Unsafe at Any Price: A Reply to Manne’, Virginia Law Review 53(7), 1425–1478
Scott, K.: 1998, ‹Insider trading’, in P. Newman (ed.), The New Palgrave Dictionary of Economics and the Law (Macmillan, London), pp. 410–419
Shaw B. 1990 Shareholder Authorized Inside Trading: A legal and Moral Analysis. Journal of Business Ethics, 9(12): 913–928
Snoeyenbos M., Smith K. 2000 Ma and Sun on Insider Trading Ethics. Journal of Business Ethics 28: 361–363
Tighe C., Michener R. 1994 The Political Economy of Insider Trading. Journal of Finance 47(5): 1661–1699
Vermaelen, T.: 1986, `Encouraging Information Disclosure', Tijdschrift voor Economie en Management, 435–449
Werhane P. H. 1989 The Ethics of Insider Trading. Journal of Business Ethics 8: 841–845
Werhane P. H. 1991 The Indefensibility of Insider Trading. Journal of Business Ethics 10: 729–731
Werhane P. H. 1991 Adam Smith and his Legacy for Modern Capitalism. Oxford University Press, Oxford and New York
Wisniewski T. P. 2005 The Information Content of Registered Insider Trading Under Lax Law Enforcement. International Review of Law and Economics 2: 169–185
Young, S. D.: 1985, ‹Insider Trading: Why the Concern?’, Journal of Accounting, Auditing and Finance 8, 178–183
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Engelen, PJ., Van Liedekerke, L. The Ethics of Insider Trading Revisited. J Bus Ethics 74, 497–507 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-007-9532-z
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-007-9532-z