Abstract
Background, aim, and scope
Ecotoxicological risk assessment of sediments is usually based on a multitude of data obtained from tests with different endpoints. In the present study, a fuzzy logic-based model was developed in order to reduce the complexity of these data sets and to classify sediments on the basis of results from a battery of in vitro biotests.
Materials and methods
The membership functions were adapted to fit the specific sensitivity and variability of each biotest. For this end, data sets were categorized into three toxicity levels using the box plot and empirical methods. The variability of each biotest was determined to calculate the range of the gradual membership. In addition, the biotests selected were ranked according to the biological organisation level in order to consider the ecological relevance of the endpoints measured by selected over- or underestimation of the toxicity levels. In the next step of the fuzzy logic model, a rule-base was implemented using if...and...then decisions to arrive at a system of five quality classes.
Results
The results of the classification of sediments from the Rhine and Danube Rivers showed the highest correlation between the biotest results and the fuzzy logic alternative based on the empirical method (i.e. the classification of the data sets into toxicity levels).
Discussion
Many different classification systems based on biological test systems are depending on respective data sets; therefore, they are difficult to compare with other locations. Furthermore, they don‘t consider the inherent variability of biotests and the ecological relevance of these test systems as well. In order to create a comprehensive risk assessment for sediments, mathematical models should be used which take uncertainties of biotest systems into account, since they are of particular importance for a reliable assessment. In the present investigation, the variability and ecological relevance of biotests were incorporated into a classification system based on fuzzy logic. Furthermore, since data from different sites and investigations were used to create membership functions of the fuzzy logic, this classification system has the potential to be independent of locations.
Conclusions
In conclusion, the present fuzzy logic classification model provides an opportunity to integrate expert knowledge as well as acute and mechanism-specific effects for the classification of sediments for an ecotoxicological risk assessment.
Recommendations and perspectives
In order to achieve a more comprehensive classification, further investigation is needed to incorporate results of chemical analyses and in situ parameters. Furthermore, more discussions are necessary with respect to the relative weight attributed to different ecological and chemical parameters in order to obtain a more precise assessment of sediments.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Adriaenssens V, De Baets B, Goethals PL, De Pauw N (2004) Fuzzy rule-based models for decision support in ecosystem management. Sci Total Environ 319:1–12
Ahlf W, Heise S (2005) Sediment toxicity assessment. J Soils Sediments 5:16–20
Babut M, Oen A, Hollert H, Apitz S, Heise S, White S (2007) Prioritisation at river basin scale, risk assessment at site-specific scale: Suggested approaches. In: Heise S (ed) Sediment risk management and communication. Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp 107–152
Baerlocher F (1999) Biostatistik. Thieme Verlag, Stuttgart. 206 pp
Bojorquez-Tapia LA, Juarez L (2002) Integrating fuzzy logic, optimization, and GIS for ecological impact assessments. Environ Assess 30:418–433
Borenfreund E, Puerner JA (1984) A simple quantitative procedure using monolayer cultures for cytotoxicity assays (HTD/NR-90). J Tissue Cult Meth 9:7–9
Braunbeck T (1998) Cytological alterations in fish hepatocytes following in vivo and in vitro sublethal exposure to xenobiotics—Structural biomarkers of environmental contamination. In: Braunbeck T, Hinton DE, Streit B (eds) Fish ecotoxicology. Birkhäuser Verlag, Basel, pp 61–140
Canfield TJ, Kemble NE, Brumbaugh WG, Dwyer FJ, Ingersoll C, Fairchild JF (1994) Use of benthic invertebrate community structure and the sediment quality triad to evaluate metal-contaminated sediment in the upper Clark Fork River, Montana. Environ Toxicol Chem 13:1999–2012
Cox E (1994) The fuzzy systems handbook: A practitioner's guide to building using and maintaining fuzzy systems. Academic, Boston. 512 pp
Diekmann M, Hultsch V, Nagel R (2004a) On the relevance of genotoxicity for fish populations I: Effects of a model genotoxicant on zebrafish (Danio rerio) in a complete life-cycle test. Aquat Toxicol 68:13–26
Diekmann M, Waldmann P, Schnurstein A, Grummt T, Braunbeck T, Nagel R (2004b) On the relevance of genotoxicity for fish populations II: Genotoxic effects in zebrafish (Danio rerio) exposed to 4-nitroquinoline-1-oxide in a complete life-cycle test. Aquat Toxicol 68:27–37
Duft M, Tillmann M, Oehlmann J (2003) Ökotoxikologische Sedimentkartierung der großen Flüsse Deutschlands, Bundesministerium für Umwelt. Naturschutz und Reaktorsicherheit, Berlin
Engwall M, Broman D, Ishaq R, Näf C, Zebühr Y, Brunström B (1996) Toxic potencies of lipophilic extracts from sediments and settling particulate matter (SPM) collected in a PCB contaminated river system. Environ Toxicol Chem 15:213–222
EWFD (2000) Directive 2000/60/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 23 October 2000 establishing a framework for Community action in the field of water policy, European Union
Heise S, Ahlf W (2002) The need for new concepts in risk management of sediments: Historical developments, future perspectives and new approaches. J Soils Sediments 2:4–8
Heise S, Maaß V, Gratzer H, Ahlf W (2000) Möglichkeiten und Leistungen einer ökotoxikologischen Sedimentklassifikation am Beispiel der Elbe. Bundesanstalt für Gewässerkunde, Koblenz
Hollert H, Dürr M, Erdinger L, Braunbeck T (2000) Cytotoxicity of settling particulate matter (SPM) and sediments of the Neckar river (Germany) during a winter flood. Environ Toxicol Chem 19:528–534
Hollert H, Dürr M, Olsman H, Halldin K, van Bavel B, Brack W, Tysklind M, Engwall M, Braunbeck T (2002a) Biological and chemical determination of dioxin-like compounds in sediments by means of a sediment triad approach in the catchment area of the Neckar River. Ecotoxicol 11:323–336
Hollert H, Heise S, Pudenz S, Brüggemann R, Ahlf W, Braunbeck T (2002b) Application of a sediment quality triad and different statistical approaches (Hasse diagrams and fuzzy logic) for the comparative evaluation of small streams. Ecotoxicol 11:311–321
Hollert H, Keiter S, König N, Rudolf M, Ulrich M, Braunbeck T (2003) A new sediment contact assay to assess particle-bound pollutants using zebrafish (Danio rerio). J Soils Sediments 3:19–207
Hollert H, Dürr M, Holtey-Weber R, Islinger M, Brack W, Färber H, Erdinger L, Braunbeck T (2005) Endocrine disruption of water and sediment extracts in a non-radioactive dot blot/RNAse protection-assay using isolated hepatocytes of rainbow trout—deficiencies between bioanalytical effectiveness and chemically determined concentrations and how to explain them. Environ Sci Pollut Res 12:347–360
Hollert H, Heise S, Keiter S, Heinrich H, Förstner U (2007) Wasserrahmenrichtlinie—Fortschritte und Defizite. Umweltwiss Schadst Forsch 19:58–70
Jorgensen SE (1999) State-of-the-art of ecological modelling with emphasis on development of structural dynamic models. Ecol Modell 120:75–96
Keiter S, Rastall AC, Kosmehl T, Wurm K, Erdinger L, Braunbeck T, Hollert H (2006) Ecotoxicological assessment of sediment, suspended matter and water samples in the upper Danube River—a pilot study in search for the causes for the decline of fish catches. Environ Sci Pollut Res 13:308–319
Keiter S, Grund S, van Bavel B, Engwall M, Hagberg J, Kammann U, Klempt M, Manz W, Olsman H, Braunbeck T, Hollert H (2008) Activities and identification of Ah receptor agonists in sediments from the Danube River. Anal Bioanal Chem 390:2009–2020
König N, Garke V, Kosmehl T, Glaß B, Golod A, Leist E, Wetterauer B, Johannsen H, Braunbeck T, Hollert H (2002) Der Zebrabärbling in Fischeitest und Comet-Assay—Embryotoxische Untersuchungen von Rheinsedimenten. Bundesanstalt für Gewässerkunde, Koblenz
Kosmehl T, Krebs F, Manz W, Erdinger L, Braunbeck T, Hollert H (2004) Comparative genotoxicity testing of Rhine river sediment extracts using the permanent cell lines RTG-2 and RTL-W1 in the comet assay and ames assay. J Soils Sediments 4:84–94
Lee LEJ, Clemons JH, Bechtel DG, Caldwell SJ, Han K, Pasitschniak-Arts M, Mosser DD, Bols NC (1993) Development and characterization of a rainbow trout liver cell line expressing cytochrome P450-dependent monooxygenase activity. Cell Biol Toxicol 9:279–294
Regan HM, Colyvan M, Burgman MA (2002) A taxonomy and treatment of uncertainty for ecology and conservation biology. Ecol Appl 12:618–628
Sachs L (2004) Angewandte Statistik, 11. Springer Verlag, Heidelberg. 889 pp
Salski A, Kandzia P (1996) Fuzzy sets and fuzzy logic in ecological modelling. Eco Sys 4:85–97
Seitz N, Böttcher M, Keiter S, Kosmehl T, Manz W, Hollert H, Braunbeck T (2008) A novel index to evaluate genotoxicity data from dose-response curves in the comet assay. Mut Res 652:38–45
Shepard RB (2005) Quantifying environmental impact assessments using fuzzy logic. Springer Series on environmental management. Springer, New York. 264 pp
Silvert W (1997) Ecological impact classification with fuzzy sets. Ecol Modell 96:1–10
Silvert W (2000) Fuzzy indices of environmental conditions. Ecol Modell 130:111–119
Singh NP, McCoy MT, Tice RR, Schneider EL (1988) A simple technique for quantitation of low levels of DNA damage in individual cells. Exp Cell Res 175:184–191
Tran LT, Knight CG, O'Neill RV, Smith ER, Riitters KH, Wickham J (2002) Fuzzy decision analysis for integrated environmental vulnerability assessment of the mid-Atlantic Region. Environ Manag 29:845–859
Ulrich M, Schulze T, Leist E, Glaß B, Maier M, Maier D, Braunbeck T, Hollert H (2002) Ökotoxikologische Untersuchung von Sedimenten und Schwebstoffen: Abschätzung des Gefährdungspotenzials für Trinkwasser und Korrelation verschiedener Expositionspfade (Acetonischer Extrakt, Natives Sediment) im Bakterienkontakttest und Fischeitest. Umweltwiss Schadst Forsch 14:132–137
White PA, Robitaille S, Rasmussen JB (1999) Heritable reproductive effects of benzo[a]pyrene on the fathead minnow (Pimephales promelas). Environ Toxicol Chem 18:1843–1847
Wickham JD, Jones KB, Riitters KH, O'Neill RV, Tankersley RD, Smith ER, Neale AC, Chaloud DJ (1999) Environmental Auditing: An integrated environmental assessment of the US Mid-Atlantic region. Environ Manag 24:553–560
Yauk CL, Fox GA, McCarry BE, Quinn JS (2000) Induced minisatellite germline mutations in herring gulls (Larus argentatus) living near steel mills. Mutat Res 452:211–218
Zadeh LA (1965) Fuzzy sets. Inf Control 8:338–353
Zorita I, Apraiz I, Ortiz-Zarragoitia M, Orbea A, Cancio I, Soto M, Marigomez I, Cajaraville MP (2007) Assessment of biological effects of environmental pollution along the NW Mediterranean Sea using mussels as sentinel organisms. Environ Pollut 148:236–250
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Keiter, S., Braunbeck, T., Heise, S. et al. A fuzzy logic-classification of sediments based on data from in vitro biotests. J Soils Sediments 9, 168–179 (2009). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11368-009-0087-8
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11368-009-0087-8