Abstract
A case study examining the relationship between ozone depletion, UV radiation and skin cancer shows how scientific uncertainty is reduced and, through consensus building, translated into certainty in public health messages. Using narrative analysis we examine Canadian consensus statements on the dangers of UV and reconstruct the supporting logical claims and scientific evidence. Though considerable uncertainty remains about the relationship between the environment and skin cancer, both public health messages and the UV-Index formalize uncertainty and risk; concern then shifts from the less-certain, scientific realm into the apparently more-certain arena of public health messages. In this process the distinctions between science and policy become blurred. The case can be interpreted in two ways: as the result of various players acting in their self-interests or as a moral drama based on the importance of simple, clear messages to allow ‘correct’ actions.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Aase, A. and G. Bentham (1994). ‘The geography of malignant melanoma in Nordic countries: The implications of stratospheric ozone depletion,’ Geografiska Annaler76 (B2): 129–139.
Albæk, E. (1995). ‘Between knowledge and power: Utilization of social science in public policy making,’ Policy Sciences 28: 79–100.
Allen, T. F. H. and T.W. Hoekstra (1992).Toward a Unified Ecology. NewYork: Columbia UP.
Amron, D.M. and R. L. Roy (1991). Stratospheric ozone depletion and its relationship to skin cancer. J Dermatol Surg Oncol 17: 370–372.
Bailey, R. (1993). Ecoscam: The False Prophets of Ecological Apocalypse. New York: St. Martin's Press.
Beck, U. (1992). ‘From industrial society to the risk society: Questions of survival, social structure and ecological enlightenment,’ Theory, Culture & Society 9: 97–123.
Benedick, R. (1991). Ozone Diplomacy: New Directions in Safeguarding the Planet. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Bonett, A., D. Roder and A. Esterman (1989). ‘Epidemiological features of melanoma in South Australia: Implications for cancer control,’ Medical Journal of Australia 151: 502–509
Borland, R., D. Hill and S. Noy (1990). ‘Being SunSmart: Changes in community awareness and reported behaviour following a primary prevention program for skin cancer control,’ Behaviour Change 7 (3): 126–135.
Brandon, W. P. (1984). ‘Public policy as the continuation of moral philosophy by other means.’ Policy Studies Review 4 (1): 60–70.
Burger, E. J. (1990). ‘Health as a surrogate for the environment.’ Daedalus 114 (4): 133–153.
Burrows, W. R., M. Vall ée, D. I. Wardle, J. B. Kerr, L. J. Wilson and D.W. Tarasick (1994). ‘The Canadian operational procedure for forecasting total ozone and UV radiation,’ Met Apps. 1: 247–265.
Canadian Cancer Statistics (1996). Toronto: National Institute of Cancer.
Colborn, T., D. Dumanoski and J. Peterson Myers (1996). Our Stolen Future. New York: Dutton.
Cotgrove, S. (1982). Catastrophe or Cornucopia. NewYork: Wiley.
Crutzen, P. J. (1992). ‘Ultraviolet on the increase,’ Nature 336: 104.
Davenport, W. A. (1982). Fifteenth–century English Drama. Totowa, NJ: Rowman & Littlefield.
DeMuer, D. and H. DeBacker (1992). Revision of 20 years of Dobson total ozone data at Uccle (Belgium). Fictitious Dobson total ozone trends induced by sulfur dioxide trends. Journal of Geophysical Research–Atmospheres April 20, 1992: p. 5921.
Deslauriers, Y. (1996). Health Canada. Personal telephone interview. April 21, 1996.
Diffy, B. L., ed. (1996). Measurement and Trends of Terrestrial UVB Radiation in Europe. Milan, Italy: OEMF spa.
Drake, F. (1994). Stratospheric Ozone Depletion–An Overview of the Scientific Debate. Working Paper 94/9. University of Leeds: School of Geography.
Dubin, N., M. Moseson and B. S. Pasternack (1989). ‘Sun exposure and malignant melanoma among susceptible individuals.’ Environmental Health Perspectives 81: 139–151.
Dunn, W.N. (1981). Public Policy Analysis. Prentice Hall: Englewood Cliffs.
Epp, J. (1986). Achieving health for all: A framework for health promotion. Ottawa: Health & Welfare Canada.
Farman, J.C., B.G. Gardiner and J.D. Shanklin (1985). 'Large losses of total ozone in Antarctica reveal seasonal CLOx/NOx interaction. Nature 315: 207–210.
Frank, J.W., B. Gibson and M. Macpherson (1988). ‘Information in epidemiology: Detecting the health effects of environmental chemical exposure,’ Information Needs for risk Management University of Toronto.
Glass, A.G. and R.N. Hoover (1989). ‘The emerging epidemic of melanoma and squamous cell skin cancer,’ JAMA 262 (15): 2097–2100.
Globe and Mail. Researchers confirm link between ozone, UV levels. November 12, 1993; p. A8. Toronto, Canada.
Harvey, I. (1995). Prevention of Skin Cancer: A Review of Available Strategies. University of Bristol: Health Care Evaluation Unit.
Hennekens, C. and J. Buring (1987). Epidemiology in Medicine. Boston: Little Brown.
Keesling, B. and H. S. Friedman (1987). ‘Psychosocial factors in sunbathing and sunscreen use,’ Health Psychology 6 (5): 477–493.
Kerr, J. B. and C.T. McElroy (1993). ‘Evidence for large upward trends of ultraviolet–B radiation linked to ozone depletion,’ Science 262: 1032–1034.
Kerr, J. B. and D. I. Wardle (1993). ‘Ozone and UV–B monitoring program in Canada,’ Atmospheric Ozone 2047: 160–168, SPIE: Tromsö, Norway.
Kingwell, M. (1996). Dreams of Millennium. Toronto: Viking.
Kuhn, T. (1962).The Structure of Scientific Revolutions. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Latour, B and S. Woolgar (1979). Laboratory Life. London: Sage.
Litfin, K.T. (1994). Ozone Discourses: Science and Politics in Global Environmental Cooperation. NewYork: Columbia University Press.
Liu S. et al. (1992). ‘Effect of anthropogenic aerosols on biologically active ultraviolet radiation,’ Geophysical Research Letters 2265: (Jan. 3, 1992).
Lloyd, S.A., E. S. Im and D. E. Anderson, Jr. (1994). ‘Modeling the latitude–dependent increase in non–melanoma skin cancer incidence as a consequence of stratospheric ozone depletion,’ in R. H. Biggs and M. E.B. Joyner, eds., Stratospheric Ozone Depletion/UV–B Radiation in the Biosphere. NATO ASI Series Vol I 18: 329–337.
Majone, G. (1989). Evidence, Argument and Persuasion in the Policy Process. New Haven: Yale University Press.
Marks, R. (1992). ‘From Slip! Slop! Slap! to SunSmart–the public health approach to skin cancer control in Australia in the 1990s,’ in R. Marks and S. Plewig, eds., The Environmental Threat to the Skin. London: Martin Dunitz.
Miller, A.G., W.A. Ashton, J.W. McHoskey & J. Gimbel (1990). ‘What price attractiveness? Stereo–type and risk factors in suntanning behavior,’ Journal of Applied Social Psychology 20 (15): 1272–1300.
Mills, C. J. and S. Jackson (1995). ‘Workshop Report: Public education messages for reducing health risks from ultraviolet radiation,’ Chronic Diseases in Canada 16 (1): 33–36.
Moan, J. and A. Dahlback (1992). ‘The relationship between skin cancers, solar radiation and ozone depletion,’ Br. J. Cancer 65: 916–921.
Molina, J. J. and F. S. Rowland (1974). ‘Stratospheric sink for chloroflouromethanes: Chlorine atom–catalysed destruction of ozone,’ Nature 249: 810–812.
Mukhtar, H. and D.R. Bickers (1993). ‘Environmental skin cancer: Mechanisms, models and human relevance,’ Cancer Research 53: 3439–3442.
Mulkay, M. (1980). Science and the Sociology of Knowledge. London: Allen and Unwin.
Nance, J. J. (1991). What Goes Up: The Global Assault on our Atmosphere. New York: William Morrow.
Nisbett, R. E. and L. Ross (1980). Human Inference. Englewood Cliffs: Prentice Hall.
Potter, R. (1975).The English Morality Play. Boston: Routledge.
Potter, R. (1989). ‘Afterword,’ in D. Gilman, ed., Everyman and Company. New York: AMS, pp. 329–334.
Roan, S. (1989). Ozone Crisis. The 15–Year Evolution of a Sudden Global Emergency. New York: Wiley.
Roe, E. (1994). Narrative Policy Analysis: Theory and Practice. Durham: Duke University Press.
Salter, L. (1988). Mandated Science: Science and Scientists in the Making of Standards. Boston: Kluwer.
Scotto, J., G. Cotton, F. Urbach, D. Berger and T. Fears (1988). ‘Biologically effective ultraviolet radiation: Surface measurements in the United States, 1974–1985.’ Science 293: 762–764.
Steckler, A., J. P. Allegrante, D. Altman, R. Brown, J.N. Burdine, R.M. Goodman and C. Jorgen–sen (1995). 'Health Education Intervention Strategies. Health Education Quarterly 22: 307–328.
Stone, D. A. (1988). Policy Paradox and Political Reason. Harper Collins.
Tesh, S.N. (1993). ‘Environmentalism, pre–environmentalism, and public policy,’ Policy Sciences 26: 1–20.
Torgerson, D. (1986). ‘Between knowledge and politics: Three faces of policy analysis.’ Policy Sciences 19: 33–59.
Vancouver Sun. Intensity of sun's ultraviolet rays to be tabulated by government. May 28, 1992. p. A9.
Virtual Elimination Taskforce (1993). A Strategy for Virtual Elimination of Persistent Toxic Sub stances. IJC: Windsor.
Weinstock, M. A. (1993). ‘Epidemiology of Melanoma,’ Cancer Treatment & Research 65: 29–56.
Wildavsky, A. (1995). But is it True? A Citizen's Guide to Environmental Health and Safety Issues. Cambridge, MASS.: Harvard Press, 304–339.
Winnipeg Free Press. Canadians link ozone, UV rays in settled areas. November 12, 1993. Canada: Winnipeg.
WMO (World Meteorological Organization) (1994). Scientific assessment of ozone depletion: 1994. WMO Global Ozone Research and Monitoring Project, Report No. 37.
Zerefos, C. S. (1996). ‘An update of the recent UV–B change over Greece,’ in B. L. Diffey, ed., Measurement and Trends of terrestrial UVB Radiation in Europe. 87–92.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Garvin, T., Eyles, J. The sun safety metanarrative: Translating science into public health discourse. Policy Sciences 30, 47–70 (1997). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1004256124700
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1004256124700