Abstract
This paper presents a case study of a psychiatric intervention as an example of an institutional ethnography of psychiatric work. Institutional ethnography, a mode of inquiry outlined by Dorothy Smith (1987), is conceived here as an approach to the analysis of work in institutions as the contingent, local and context-bound insertion of a particular "case" - a patron, a pupil, a client, a patient - into both institutional and other social (e. g. gender, class) relations. The case presented in this paper, shows how a psychiatric factual account is the outcome of a process of the recognition, and/or the production, of "mentionables," followed by the documentary interpretation of mentionables as symptoms. Subsequently it is demonstrated that, and how, the recognition of mentionables depends on non-professional interpretations which by their nature express other social (such as gender, class, etc.) relations. This description of psychiatric diagnostic work is produced by means of a method of discourse analysis that consists of the juxtaposition of the various institutional texts (the two reports) with the transcript of the interview. An analysis of only the interview data would undoubtedly have resulted in some insights about psychiatric interviewing but would have shown neither how the interview functioned as a stage in the institutional process of (re)writing reports nor how ideological evaluations entered the diagnostic process. On the other hand, an analysis of only the two reports would have resulted in some insights about psychiatric reporting but would not have shown how these reports were produced.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
De Boer, Fijgje and Hak, Tony. (1986). Besluitvorning in de Acute Psychiatrie. Konteksten 7. Rotterdam: Instituut voor Preventieve en Sociale Psychiatrie.
Hak, Tony. (1989). Constructing a Psychiatric Case. In Brian Torode (Ed.), Text and Talk as Social Practice. Dordrecht: Foris.
Hak, Tony. (1992). Psychiatric Records as Transformations of Other Texts. In Graham Watson and Robert Seiler (Eds.), Text in Context. Newbury Park: Sage Publications.
Jackson, Nancy. (1977). Describing News. M.A thesis, Department of Anthropology and Sociology, University of British Columbia.
Manicom, Ann. (1988). Constituting Class Relations. Ph.D. thesis, Department of Education, University of Toronto.
Ng, Roxana. (1988). The Politics of Community Services. Toronto: Garamond Press.
Smith, Dorothy. (1975). The Statistics on Mental Illness. In Dorothy Smith and Sara David (Eds.), Women Look at Psychiatry. Vancouver: Press Gang.
Smith, Dorothy. (1978). “K is Mentally Ill.” The Anatomy of a Factual Account, Sociology 12: 23–53.
Smith, Dorothy. (1983). No One Commits Suicide, Human Studies 6: 309–359.
Smith, Dorothy. (1987). The Everyday World as Problematic. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
Smith, Dorothy. (1990). The Active Text. In Texts, Facts, and Feminity. London: Routledge.
Smith, George. (1988). Policing the Gay Community, International Journal of the Sociology of Law 16: 163–183.
Smith, George. (1990). Political Activist as Ethnographer, Social Problems 37: 629–648.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Hak, T. "There Are Clear Delusions." The Production of a Factual Account. Human Studies 21, 419–436 (1998). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1005441732459
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1005441732459