Abstract
Recreational and subsistence angling are important aspects of urban culture for much of North America where people are concentrated near the coasts or major rivers. Yet there are fish and shellfish advisories for many estuaries, rivers, and lakes, and these are not always heeded. This paper examines fishing behavior, sources of information, perceptions, and compliance with fishing advisories as a function of ethnicity for people fishing in the Newark Bay Complex of the New York–New Jersey Harbor. We test the null hypothesis that there were no ethnic differences in sources of information, perceptions of the safety of fish consumption, and compliance with advisories. There were ethnic differences in consumption rates, sources of information about fishing, knowledge about the safety of the fish, awareness of fishing advisories or of the correct advisories, and knowledge about risks for increased cancer and to unborn and young children. In general, the knowledge base was much lower for Hispanics, was intermediate for blacks, and was greatest for whites. When presented with a statement about the potential risks from eating fish, there were no differences in their willingness to stop eating fish or to encourage pregnant women to stop. These results indicate a willingness to comply with advisories regardless of ethnicity, but a vast difference in the base knowledge necessary to make informed risk decisions about the safety of fish and shellfish. Although the overall median income level of the population was in the $25,000–34,999 income category, for Hispanics it was on the border between $15,000–24,999 and $25,000–34,999.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
REFERENCES
P. Sparks and R. Shepherd, “Public Perceptions of the Potential Hazards Associated With Food Production: An Empirical Study,” Risk Anal. 14799–808 (1994).
Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry (ATSDR), “States Issue a Record Number of Health Advisories,” Hazardous Substance Public Health 61–2 (1996).
Institute of Medicine. Seafood Safety(National Academy Press, Washington, DC, 1991).
Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), Update: National Listing of Fish and Wildlife Consumption Advisories (Cincinnati, Ohio, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, 1996).
J. N. Morgan, M. R. Berry, and R. L. Graves, “Effects of Commonly Used Cooking Practices on Total Mercury Concentration in Fish and Their Impact on Exposure Assessments,” J.Exposure Anal.Environ.Epidemiol. 7119–134 (1996).
D. Airey, “Total Mercury Concentrations in Human Hair From 13 Countries in Relation to Fish Consumption and Location,” Sci.Total Environ. 31157–180 (1983).
J. Burger, K. Cooper, and M. Gochfeld, “Exposure Assessment for Heavy Metal Ingestion From a Sport Fish in Puerto Rico: Estimating Risk for Local Fishermen,” J.Toxicol.Environ. Health 36355–365 (1992).
P. Weihe, P. Grandjean, F. Debes, and R. White, “Health Implications for Faroe Islanders of Heavy Metals and PCBs From Pilot Whales,” Sci.Total Environ. 186141–148 (1996).
H. May and J. Burger, “Fishing in a Polluted Estuary: Fishing Behavior, Fish Consumption, and Potential Risk,” Risk Anal. 16459–471 (1996).
J. L. Jacobson and S. W. Jacobson, “Intellectual Impairment in Children Exposed to Polychlorinated Biphenyls in Utero,” N.Engl.J.Med. 335783–789 (1996).
S. L. Schantz, “Developmental Neurotoxicity of PCBs in Humans: What DoWeKnowand WhereDoWeGo From Here?” Neurotoxicol.Teratol. 18217–227 (1996).
B. Weiss and J. Elsner, “Risk Assessment for Neurobehavioral Toxicity,” Environ.Health Perspectives 104(supl), 171–413 (1996).
A. H. Stern, “Re-evaluation of the Reference Dose for Methylmercury and Assessment of Current Exposure Levels.” Risk Anal. 13355–364 (1993).
J. Burger, K. Staine, and M. Gochfeld, “Fishing in Contaminated Waters: Knowledge and Risk Perception of Hazards by Fishermen in New York City,” J.Toxicol.Environ.Health 3995–105 (1993).
C. M. Velicer and B. A. Knuth, “Communicating Contaminant Risks from Sport-Caught Fish: The Importance of Target Audience Assessment,” Risk Anal. 14833–841 (1994).
P. Slovic, B. Fischoff, and S. Lichtenstein, “Rating the Risks,” Environment 2114–20 (1979).
P. Slovic, “Perception of Risk,” Science 236280–285 (1987).
P. Slovic, “Perceived Risk, Trust, and Democracy,” Risk Anal. 13675–682 (1993).
R. E. Kasperson, O. Renn, P. Slovic, H. S. Brown, J. Emel, R. Goble, J. S. Kasperson, and S. Ratick, “The Social Amplifi-cation of Risk: A Conceptual Framework,” Risk Anal. 8177–187 (1988).
E. F. Fitzgerald, S. Hwang, K. A. Brix, B. Bush, K. Cook and P. Worswick, “Fish PCB Concentrations and Consumption PatternsAmong MohawkWomen at Akwesasne,” J.Exposure Anal.Environ.Epidemiol. 51–19 (1995).
L. E. Fleming, S. Watkins, R. Kaderman, B. Levin, D. R. Ayyar, M. Bizzio, D. Stephens, and J. A. Bean, “Mercury Exposure in Humans Through Food Consumption From the Everglades of Florida,” Water Air Soil Pollution 8041–48 (1995).
D. E. Taylor, “Blacks and the Environment: Toward an Explanation of the Concern and Action Gap Between Blacks and Whites,” Environ.Behavior 21175–205 (1989).
J. Flynn, P. Slovic, and C. K. Mertz, “Gender, Race, and Perception of Environmental Health Risks,” Risk Anal. 141101–1108 (1994).
W. Arp III and C. Kenny, “Black Environmentalism in the Local Community Context,” Environ.Behavior 28267–282 (1996).
R. D. Bullard and B. H. Wright, “The Politics of Pollution: Implications for the Black Community,” Phylon 4771–78 (1986).
J. F. Toth Jr and R. B. Brown, “Racial and Gender Meanings of Why People Participate in Recreational Fishing,” Leisure Sci. 19129–146 (1997).
K. Kirk Pflugh, L. Lurig, L. A. VonHagen, S. VonHagen, and J. Burger, “Urban Anglers' Perception of Risk From Contaminated Fish,” Science Total Environment 228203–218 (1999).
N. N. Kraus and Paul Slovic, “Taxonomic Analysis of Perceived Risk: Modeling Individual and Group Perceptions Within Homogeneous Hazard Domains,” Risk Anal. 8435–455 (1993).
R. U. Ayres and S. R. Rod, “Patterns of Pollution in the Hudson-Raritan Basin,” Environment 2814–43 (1986).
T. P. O' Connor and C. N. Ehler, “Results from the NOAA National Status and Trends Program on Distribution and Effects of Chemical Contamination in the Coastal and Estuarine United States,” Environ.Monit.Assess. 1733–49 (1991).
K. S. Squibb, “Overview of Toxics in the Harbor Estuary,” Tidal Exchange 31–2 (1992).
New York State Department of Health (NYSDOH), 1994- 1995 Health Advisories: Chemicals in Sportfish or Game(New York State Department of Health, Bureau of Toxic Substance Assessment, New York, 1994).
New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection, Division of Science and Research (NJDEP), A Guide to Health Advisories for Eating Fish and Crabs in New Jersey(New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection, Division of Science and Research, Trenton, New Jersey, 1994).
B. L. Finley, K. R. Trowbridge, S. Burton, D. M. Proctor, J. M. Panko, and D. J. Paustenbach, “Preliminary Assessment of PCB Risks to Human and Ecological Health in the Lower Passaic River,” J.Toxico.Environ.Health 5295–118 (1997).
P. Hauge, Polychlorinated Biphenyls (PCBs), Chlordane, and DDTs in Selected Fish and Shellfish from New Jersey Waters, 1988- 1991: Results from New Jersey's Toxics in Biota Monitoring Program (New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection, Division of Science and Research, Trenton, New Jersey, 1993).
J. Flynn, P. Slovic, and C. K. Mertz. “Gender, Race, and Perception of Environmental Health Risks,” Risk Anal. 141101–1108 (1994).
T. Belton, R. Roundy, and N. Weinstein, “Urban Fishermen: Managing the Risks of Toxic Exposure,” Environment 2819–37 (1986).
R. Gregory and R. Mendelsohn, “Perceived Risk, Dread, and Benefits,” Risk Anal. 13259–264 (1993).
N. Kraus, T. Malmfors, and P. Slovic, “Intuitive Toxicology: Expert and Lay Judgements of Chemical risks,” Risk Anal. 12215–232 (1992).
P. D. Anderson and J. B. Wiener, “Eating Fish,” In J. D. Graham and J. B. Weiner, eds, Risk versus Risk: Tradeoffs in Protecting Health and the Environment(Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA, 1995).
Federal Census Bureau, U.S.Census(U.S. Government Printing Office, Washington DC, 1995).
C. Starr, “Social Benefits Versus Technological Risk,” Science 1651232–1238 (1969).
N. D. Weinstein, “Unrealistic Optimism About Susceptibility to Health Problems,” J.Behav.Med. 5441–460 (1982).
N. D. Weinstein, “Optimistic Biases About Personal Risks,” Science 2461232–1233 (1989).
M. B. Campbell, “Fishing Lore: The Construction of the 'sportsmen',” Annals of Tourism Research 1676–88 (1989).
H. Otway and B. Wynne, “Risk Communication: Paradigm and Paradox,” Risk Anal. 9141–145 (1989).
A. Tversky and D. Kahneman, “The Framing of Decisions and the Psychology of Choice,” Science 211452–458 (1981).
E. Horn, “Toxics in Seafood,” Tidal Exchange 36–7 (1992).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Burger, J., Pflugh, K.K., Lurig, L. et al. Fishing in Urban New Jersey: Ethnicity Affects Information Sources, Perception, and Compliance. Risk Anal 19, 217–229 (1999). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1006921610468
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1006921610468