Abstract
The Kyoto Protocol on global warming has provoked great controversy in part because it calls for heavier burdens on wealthy countries than on developing countries in the effort to control climate change. The U.S. Senate voted unanimously to oppose any agreement that does not require emissions reductions in low-income countries. The ethics of this position are examined in this paper which shows that there are good moral reasons for supporting the provisions of the Kyoto Protocol. Such a conclusion follows easily from considerations of distributive justice but can also be supported by more narrowly self-interested arguments.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
REFERENCES
Audi, Robert, Moral Knowledge and Ethical Character (Oxford University Press, New York, 1997).
Audi, Robert, “Outline of a Kantian Intuitionism in Moral Epistemology and Normative Ethics, ” notes from the seminar entitled Moral Theory and Its Practical Application: An Interdisciplinary Seminar, University of Nebraska, Lincoln (June 8- 13, 1998).
Baier, Annette, “The Rights of Past and Future Persons, ” in Ernest Partridge (ed), Responsibilities to Future Generations (Prometheus Books, Buffalo, NY, 1981).
Banuri, T., K. Göran-Mäler, M. Grubb, H.K. Jacobson and F. Yamin, “Equity and Social Considerations, ” in James P. Bruce, Hoesung Lee and Erik F. Haites (eds), Climate Change 1995: Economic and Social Dimensions of Climate Change (Cambridge University Press, New York, 1996).
Beitz, Charles R., “Justice and International Relations, ” in Charles R. Beitz, Marshall Cohen, Thomas Scanlon and A. John Simmons (eds), International Ethics, a Philosophy and Public Affairs Reader (Princeton University Press, Princeton, 1985).
Boyd, Roy, Kerry Krutilla and W. Kip Viscusi, “Energy Taxation as a Policy Instrument to Reduce CO2 Emissions: A Net Benefit Analysis, ” J. of Environ. Econ. and Management 29 (1995), 1–24.
Bruce, James P. Hoesung Lee and Erik F. Haites (eds), Climate Change 1995: Economic and Social Dimension of Climate Change (Cambridge University Press, New York, 1996).
Carlucci, Frank C., “Kyoto Environment Pact Creates Harsh Climate for National Security, ” Insight on the News 14(22) (June 15, 1998), 29.
CDIAC (Carbon Dioxide Information Analysis Center), Carbon Emissions (CDIAC, Department of Energy, Washington, DC, 1998), Internet address: cdiac.esd.ornl.gov/ftp/trends/emissions/.
Coward, Howard and Thomas Hurka (eds), Ethics and Climate Change: The Greenhouse Effect (Wilfrid Laurier University Press, Waterloo, Ontario, Canada, 1993).
Cullity, Garrett, “International Aid and the Scope of Kindness, ” Ethics 105- 1 (October, 1994), 99–127.
Dancy, Jonathan, “Intuitionism, ” in Peter Singer (ed), A Companion to Ethics (Blackwell Publishers, Oxford, UK, 1993).
Dasgupta, Partha, An Inquiry into Well-Being and Destitution (Clarendon Press, New York, 1993).
DOE: Department of Energy, International Energy Outlook 1997 (Department of Energy, Washington, DC, 1997), Internet address: www.eia.doe.gov/oiaf/ieo97/.
Fankhauser, Samuel, Valuing Climate Change: The Economics of the Greenhouse (Earthscan Publications Limited, London, 1995).
Francl, Terry, “Potential Impact of the Global Climate Treaty on the Agricultural Sector, ” Analysis, American Farm Bureau Federation (Sept. 19, 1997): www.fb.com/issues/analysis/climatea/climcost.html.
Goodin, Robert E., “What Is So Special About Our Fellow Countrymen?”Ethics 98 (July, 1988), 663–686.
Griffin, James, “Virtue Ethics and Environs, ” Social Philosophy and Policy 15- 1 (Winter, 1998), 56–70.
Grubb, Michael, “Seeking Fair Weather: Ethics and the International Debate on Climate Change, ” International Affairs 71- 3 (July, 1995), 463–496.
Hagel, Chuck, Personal communication, letter dated November 14, 1997.
Hurka, Thomas, “Ethical Principles, ” in Ethics and Climate Change: The Greenhouse Effect (Wilfrid Laurier University Press, Waterloo, Ontario, Canada, 1993).
International Affairs, “Ethics, the Environment and the Changing International Order, ” International Affairs 71- 3 (July, 1995), 463–588.
Kotok, C. David and Julie Anderson, “Hagel and Kerrey See Trouble in Global Warming Treaty, ” Omaha World Herald 134(19) (Oct. 27, 1998).
Mason, Andrew, “Special Obligations to Compatriots, ” Ethics 107- 3 (April, 1997), 427–447.
Michaels, Patrick, “The Consequences of Kyoto, ” News Release from the Cato Institute reported in News and Views (Publication of the American Water Resources Association) 17(4) (July, 1998), 6.
Midgley, Mary, “The Origin of Ethics, ” in Peter Singer (ed), A Companion to Ethics (Blackwell Publishers, Oxford, UK, 1993).
Miller, David, “The Ethical Significance of Nationality, ” Ethics 98 (July, 1988), 647–662.
Morrissey, Wayne A. and John R. Justus, “CRS Issue Brief for Congress 89005: Global Climate Change” (National Institute for the Environment, Washington, DC, 1997), Internet: www.cnie.org/nle/clim-2.html.
Nozick, Robert, Anarchy, State and Utopia (Basic Books, New York, 1974).
O'Neill, Onara, “Transnational Justice, ” in David Held (ed), Political Theory Today (Stanford University Press, Stanford, 1991).
Partridge, Ernest, Responsibilities to Future Generations (Prometheus Books, Buffalo, NY, 1981).
Pence, Greg, “Virtue Theory, ” in Peter Singer (ed), A Companion to Ethics (Blackwell Publishers, Oxford, UK, 1993).
Pogge, Thomas W., “Cosmopolitanism and Sovereignty, ” Ethics 103- 1 (October, 1992), 48–75.
Pogge, Thomas W., “An Egalitarian Law of Peoples, ” Philosophy and Public Affairs 23- 3 (Summer, 1994), 195–224.
Pope, Charles, “Fresh Focus on Global Warming does not Dispel Doubts about Kyoto Treaty Future, ” Congressional Quarterly Weekly Report 56(23) (June 6, 1998), 1537–1539.
Public Citizen, Poll results reported at www.citizen.org/cmep/budget/96pollresults.html (1995).
Rawls, John, A Theory of Justice (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts, 1971).
Rawls, John, “The Law of Peoples, ” in Stephen Shute and Susan Hurley (eds), On Human Rights: The Oxford Amnesty Lectures (Basic Books, New York, 1993).
Redefining Progress, “The Economists' Statement on Climate Change, ” Redefining Progress (San Francisco, November 1997).
Ross, William David, “Many Self-Evident Obligations, ” chapter 2 in The Right and the Good (Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1930).
Scheffler, Samuel, “Relationships and Responsibilities, ” Philosophy and Public Affairs 26- 3 (Summer, 1997), 189–209.
Schelling, Thomas C., “Some Economics of Global Warming, ” Am. Econ. Review 82- 1 (March, 1992), 1–14.
Sen, Amartya, “Human Rights and Asian Values: What Lee Kuan Yew and Le Peng Don't Understand about Asia, ” The New Republic 217(2/3) (July 14, 1997), 33–41.
Shue, Henry, “The Unavoidability of Justice, ” in Andrew Hurrell and Benedict Kingsbury (eds), The International Politics of the Environment (Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1992).
Shue, Henry, “An Introduction to the Debate, ” International Affairs 71- 3 (July, 1995), 453–462.
Sikora, F.I. and Brian Barry, Obligations to Future Generations (Temple University Press, Philadelphia, 1978).
Singer, S. Fred, “Don't Believe Kyoto Hype, ” Lincoln Journal Star (Lincoln, NE, January 7, 1998).
Singer, Peter, “Famine, Affluence, and Morality, ” in Charles R. Beitz, Marshall Cohen, Thomas Scanlon and A. John Simmons (eds), International Ethics, a Philosophy and Public Affairs Reader (Princeton University Press, Princeton, 1985).
Smith, Adam, The Theory of Moral Sentiments, Liberty Fund Reprint (Oxford University Press, Indianapolis, IN, 1982, originally 1759).
Sumner, L.W., “Is Virtue its Own Reward?” Social Philosophy and Policy 15- 1 (Winter, 1998), 18–36.
Thompson, Paul B., The Ethics of Aid and Trade (Cambridge University Press, New York, 1992).
UNA- USA, “Feature on Global Warming, ” Washington Weekly Report, United Nations Association- USA, Washington, DC, XXIV- 13 (May 15, 1998).
United Nations, The Kyoto Protocol to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (United Nations, New York, 1997), Internet: www.law.pace.edu/env/energy/kyoto.html.
U.S. Department of Commerce, Statistical Abstract of the United States (U.S. Government Printing Office, Washington, DC, various dates).
Van Liedekerke, Luc and Luc Lauwers, “Sacrificing the Patrol: Utilitarianism, Future Generations and Infinity, ” Economics and Philosophy 13- 2 (October, 1997), 159–174.
Walzer, Michael, “Membership, ” in Schlomo Avineri and Avner de-Shalit (eds), Communitarianism and Individualism (Oxford University Press, New York, 1992).
Washington Post National Weekly Edition, “Cooling it at Home, ” Washington, DC (December 8, 1997), 10–11.
World Bank, World Development Report 1997 (Oxford University Press, New York, 1997).
World Resources Institute, WRI, World Resources, 1996/97 (World Resources Institute, Basic Books, New York, 1996/97).
WWF (World Wildlife Fund), “New Mellman Poll Shows Overwhelming Public Support for International Efforts to Halt Global Warming, ” reported at: www.wwf.org/new/news/pr125.htm (1997).
Zengerle, Jason, “Hagelianism, ” The New Republic, 218(32) (Feb. 9, 1998), 10–12.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Wesley, E., Peterson, F. The Ethics of Burden-Sharing in the Global Greenhouse. Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 11, 167–196 (1999). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1009570100135
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1009570100135