Abstract
Recently within the critical accounting literature Funnell (1998) has argued that accounting was implicated in the Holocaust. This charge is primarily related to the technical, mathematical nature of accounting and its ability to dehumanise individuals. Broadbent (1998, see also DeMoss and McCann, 1997) has also contended that "accounting logic" excludes emotion. She suggests that a more emancipatory form of accounting could be possible if emotion were given a voice and allowed to be heard within accounting discourse (see also Kjonstad and Wilmott, 1995). This paper contends that emotion should be introduced into accounting education and in particular emotional commitment to other individuals should be encouraged. It is suggested that one way to do this may be through business ethics education. It is also suggested that increasing ethical commitment to other individuals may go some way towards combating the tendency for accountancy to dehumanise other people. While there have been specific studies of ethics and accounting education there has, as yet, been little open debate about what the objectives of accounting ethics education should be or the specific techniques that could be used to meet the desired aims. This paper contends that accountancy has become dangerously dehumanised and that one of the most important objectives for any business ethics education must be to develop an empathy with "the other". The paper studies the developments within the medical, legal and engineering profession in order to suggest some specific methods which could be employed in order to re-humanise accountancy and develop a sense of moral commitment towards other individuals.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Abdolmohammadi, M. J., D. R. L. Gadhart and M. F. Reeves: 1997, ‘Ethical Cognition of Business Students Individually and in Groups’, Journal of Business Ethics 16(16), 1717–1725.
Abell, J. D.: 1990, ‘A Note on The Teaching of Ethics in the MBA Macroeconomics Course’, Journal of Business Ethics 9(1), 21–29.
Adler, R. B.: 1995, ‘Teaching Communication Theories with Jungle Fever’, Communication Education 44, 157–164.
American Assembly of Collegiate Schools of Business: 1988, Accreditation Council Policies, Procedures and Standards (AACSB, St. Louis).
Arditi, D.: 1984, ‘Graduate Education in Construction Management’, Journal of Construction Management & Economics 2, 193-199.
Backof, J. F. and C. L. Martin: 1991, ‘Historical Perspectives: Development of the Codes of Ethics in the Legal, Medical and Accounting Professions’, Journal of Business Ethics 10, 99–110.
Bauman, Z.: 1993, Postmodern Ethics (Blackwell, Oxford).
Bauman, Z.: 1996, Modernity and The Holocaust (Blackwell, Oxford).
Bauman, Z.: 1998, Globalisation, The Human Consequences (Blackwell, Oxford).
Baylis, F. and J. Downie: 1991, ‘Ethics Education for Canadian Medical Students’, Academic Medicine 66, 413–414.
Berger, J. and C. Pratt: 1998, ‘Teaching Business-Communication Ethics with Controversial Films’, Journal of Business Ethics 17(16), 1817–1823.
Betts M., S. J. R. Liow and R. W Pollock: 1993, ‘Different Perceptions of Importance of Educational Objectives’, Journal of Professional Issues in Engineering Education and Practice 119(3), 317–329.
Bissonette, R., R. M. O'Shea, M. Horwitz and C. F. Route: 1995, ‘A Date-generated Basis for Medical Ethics Education: Categorizing Issues Experienced by Students during Clinical Training’, Academic Medicine 70, 1035–1037.
Bok, D. C.: 1976, ‘Can Ethics Be Taught?’, Change, 26–30.
Boud, D.: 1985, Problem-Based Learning in Education for the Professions (Higher Education Research and Development Society of Australasia, Sydney, Australia).
Broadbent, J.: 1998, ‘The Gendered Nature of Accounting Logic: Pointers to an Accounting That Encompasses Multiple Values’, Critical Perspectives on Accounting 9, 267–297.
Carson, R. A.: 1994, ‘Teaching Ethics in the Context of Medical Humanities’, Journal of Medical Ethics 20, 235–238.
Chaplan, J. A.: 1996, ‘Youth Perspectives on Lawyers' Ethics: A Report on Seven Interviews’, Fordham Law Review 64(4), 1763–1784.
Coates, G. H.: 1993, ‘Facilitating Sustainable Development: Role of The Engineer’, Journal of Professional Issues in Engineering Education and Practice 119(3), 225–229.
Colby, A. and L. Kohlberg: 1987, The Measurement of Moral Judgement, Vol. 1: Theoretical Foundations and Research Validation (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge).
Coles, R.: 1989, The Call of Stories: Teaching and The Moral Imagination (Houghton-Mifflin, Boston).
Coope, C. M.: 1986, ‘Teaching Medical Ethics: Does Teaching By Cases Mislead Us About Morality?’, Journal of Medical Ethics 22, 46–52.
Cottell, M. N. T.: 1993 ‘Facilitating Sustainable Development: Is Our Approach Correct?’, Journal of Professional Issues in Engineering Education and Practice 119(3), 220–224.
Cragg, W.: 1997, ‘Teaching Business Ethics: The Role of Ethics in Business and in Business Education’, Journal of Business Ethics 16(3), 231–245.
Cullia, J. B.: 1985, ‘Do MBA Students Have Ethics Phobia?’, Business and Society Review, 52–54.
DeMoss, M. A. and G. K. McCann: 1997, ‘Without a Care in the World: The Business Ethics Course and Its Exclusion of a Care Perspective’, Journal of Business Ethics 16(4), 435–443.
Donaldson, J.: 1988, Key Issues in Business Ethics (Academic Press, London).
Downie, R. S.: 1991, ‘Literature and Medicine’, Journal of Medical Ethics 17, 93–96.
Downie, R. S. and B. Charlton: 1992, The Making of a Doctor (Oxford University Press, Oxford).
Downie, R. S., R. A. Hendry, R. J. MacNaughton and B. H. Smith: 1997, ‘Humanizing Medicine: A Special Study Module’, Medical Education 31, 276–280.
Dunfee, T. W. and D. C. Robertson: 1988, ‘Integrating Ethics Into the Business School Curriculum’, Journal of Business Ethics 7(11), 847–859.
Elbow, P.: 1981, Writing With Power: Techniques for Mastering the Writing Process (Oxford University Press, Oxford).
Faulkner, A. C., J. H. Sargent and S. H. Weane: 1989, ‘Civil Engineers' Managerial Roles and Needs: Report of Survey’, Construction Management Economics 7, 155–174.
Fahy, J. M., C. J. Mitchell and S. M. Cacciaguidi: 1999, ‘Accounting, Accountability and The Holocaust: The Search for the Missing Millions’, Paper presented at the Scottish British Accounting Association, Glasgow.
Florman, S. C.: 1987, The Civilized Engineer (St Martin's Press, New York).
Fogarty, T. J.: 1995, ‘Accountant Ethics: A Brief Examination of Neglected Sociological Dimensions’, Journal of Business Ethics 14(2), 103–115.
Francis, J. R.: 1990, ‘After Virtue? Accounting as a Moral and Discursive Practice’, Accounting Auditing and Accountability Journal 3(3), 5–17.
Funnell, W.: 1998, ‘Accounting in the Service of the Holocaust’, Critical Perspectives on Accounting 8(4), 435–464.
Gaa, J. C.: 1990, ‘A Game Theory Analysis of Professional Rights and Responsibilities’, Journal of Business Ethics 9(3), 159–169.
Gandz, J. and N. Hayes: 1988, ‘Teaching Business Ethics’, Journal of Business Ethics 7(9), 661.
George, R. J.: 1987, ‘Teaching Business Ethics: Is There a Gap Between Rhetoric and Reality?’, Journal of Business Ethics 6(7), 513–518.
George, R. J.: 1988, ‘The Challenge of Preparing Ethically Responsible Managers: Closing the Rhetoric-Reality Gap’, Journal of Business Ethics 7(9), 715–720.
Ghorpade, J.: 1991, ‘Ethics in MBA Programs: The Rhetoric, The Reality and a Plan of Action’, Journal of Business Ethics 10(12), 891–905.
Gillon, R.: 1996, ‘Thinking About a Medical School Curriculum for Medical Ethics and Law’, Journal of Medical Ethics 22, 323–324.
Giroux, H. A.: 1996, Fugitive Cultures: Race Violence and Youth (Routledge, New York).
Glynn E. F. and W. B. Fergusson: 1994, ‘Innovative Introduction to Civil Engineering Curriculum’, Journal of Professional Issues in Engineering Education and Practice 120(2), 149–157.
Goldstein, M. B.: 1984, ‘Law and Ethics in Co-operative Education’, The Journal of Co-operative Education 20(2), 39–48.
Gowan, C. R., N. Hanna, L. W. Jacobs, D. E. Keys and D.E. Weiss, 1996, ‘Integrating Business Ethics into a Graduate Program’, Journal of Business Ethics 15, 671–679.
Gray, R. H., J. Bebbington, and K. J. McPhail: 1994, ‘Teaching Ethics and the Ethics of Teaching: Educating for Immorality and a Possible Case For Social and Environmental Accounting’, Accounting Education 3, 51–75.
Green, B., P. D. Miller and C. P. Routh: 1995, ‘Teaching Ethics in Psychiatry: A One-Day Workshop for Clinical Students’, Journal of Medical Ethics 21, 234–238.
Griffin, C. L.: 1995, ‘Teaching Rhetorical Criticism with Thelma and Louise’, Communication Education 44, 165–176.
Grundstein-Amado, R.: 1995, ‘Values Education: A New Direction for Medical Education’, Journal of Medical Ethics 21, 174–178.
Gunn, A. and P. A. Vesilind: 1984, ‘Ethics and Engineering Education’, Journal of Professional Issues in Engineering Education and Practice 110(4), 143–149.
Gunz, S. and J. McCutcheon: 1991, ‘Some Unresolved Ethical Issues in Auditing’, Journal of Business Ethics 10(10), 777–785.
Hafferty, F. W. and R. Franks: 1994, ‘The Hidden Curriculum, Ethics Teaching and the Structure of Medical Education’, Academic Medicine 69, 11.
Hartwell, S.: 1990, ‘Moral Development, Ethical Conduct and Clinical Education’, New York Law School Law Review 35, 131.
Hassler, P. C.: 1987, ‘Six Years Experience in Offering Courses in Ethics’, Journal of Professional Issues in Engineering Education and Practice 113(1), 10–15.
Herkert, J. R. and V. B. Viscomi: 1991, ‘Introducing Professionalism and Ethics in Engineering Curriculum’, Journal of Professional Issues in Engineering Education and Practice 117(3), 383–388.
Herndon, N. C.: 1996, ‘A New Context for Ethics Education Objectives in a College of Business: Ethical Decision-Making Models’, Journal of Business Ethics 15, 501–510.
Hiltebeitel, K. M. and S. K. Jones: 1992, ‘An Assessment of the Ethics Instruction in Accounting Education’, Journal of Business Ethics 11(1), 37–46.
Hoffman, P. T.: 1982, ‘Clinical Course Design and the Supervisory Process’, Arizona State Law Journal, 277–311.
Hoskin, K. W. and R. Macve: 1986, ‘Accounting and The Examination: A Genealogy of Disciplinary Power’, Accounting, Organzsations and Society 11(2), 105–136.
Huss, H. F. and D. M. Patterson: 1993, ‘Ethics in Accounting: Values Education Without Indoctrination’, Journal of Business Ethics 12(3), 235–243.
Kelman, H.: 1973, ‘Violence Without Moral Restraint’, Journal of Social Issues 29, 29–61.
Kennedy, E. J. and L. Lawton: 1992, ‘Business Ethics in Fiction’, Journal of Business Ethics 11(3), 187–195.
Kjonstad, B. and H. Willmott: 1995, ‘Business Ethics: Restrictive or Empowering?’, Journal of Business Ethics 14(6), 445–464.
Koehn, E.: 1991, ‘An Ethics and Professionalism Seminar in the Civil Engineering Curriculum’, Journal of Professional Issues in Engineering Education and Practice 117(2), 96–101.
Koehn, E.: 1992, ‘Practitioner Involvement with Engineering Ethics and Professionalism’, Journal of Professional Issues in Engineering Education and Practice 118(1), 49–55.
Koeh, E. and J. Bourque: 1990, ‘Professionalism, Ethics and Image of Civil Engineers’, Education and Continuing Development for the Civil Engineer: Setting the Agenda for the 1990's and Beyond, ASCE, 968–974.
Kraft, K. L. and A. Singhapakdi: 1991, ‘The Role of Ethics and Social Responsibility in Achieving Organizational Effectiveness: Students Versus Managers’, Journal of Business Ethics 10(9), 679–686.
Kremers, M.: 1989, ‘Teaching Ethical Thinking in a Technical Writing Course’, IEEE Transitions on Professional Communication 32(2), 58–61.
Kuhn, J. W: 1998, ‘Emotion As Well As Reason: Getting Students Beyond “Interpersonal Accountability”’, Journal of Business Ethics 17(3), 295–308.
Lachs, J.: 1981, Responsibility of the Individual in Modern Society (Harvester, Brighton).
Lande, N. and A. Slade: 1979, Stages (Harper and Row, New York).
Langenderfer, H. Q. and J. W. Rockness: 1989, ‘Integrating Ethics Into Accounting Curriculum: Issues, Problems and Solutions’, Issues in Accounting Education 4, 58–69.
Lansley, P.: 1985, ‘Putting Organisational Research into Practice’, Journal of Construction Management Economics 3, 1–4.
Laurillard, D.: 1993, Rethinking University Teaching (Routledge, London).
Lehmann, C.: 1988, ‘Accounting Ethics: Surviving Survival of the Fittest’, Advances in Public Interest Accounting 2, 71–82.
Lindaver, G. C. and D. J. Hagerty: 1983, ‘Ethics Simulation in the Classroom’, Journal of Chemical Engineering Process 79(7), 17–19.
Loeb, S. E.: 1988, ‘Teaching Students Accounting Ethics: Some Crucial Issues’, Issues in Accounting Education 3, 316–329.
Loeb, S. E.: 1991, ‘The Evaluation of Outcomes of Accounting Ethics Education’, Journal of Business Ethics 10(2), 77–84.
Loeb, S. E. and J. Rockness: 1992, ‘Accounting Ethics And Education: A Perspective’, Journal of Business Ethics 11(7), 485–490.
MacIntyre, A.: 1967, A Short History of Ethics a History of Moral Philosophy from the Homeric Age to the Twentieth Century (Routledge and Kegan Paul, London).
McAdams, T.: 1993, ‘The Great Gatsby as a Business Ethics Inquiry’, Journal of Business Ethics 12(8), 653–660.
McAdams, T. and R. Koppensteiner: 1992, ‘The Manager Seeking Virtue: Lessons from Literature’, Journal of Business Ethics 11(8), 627–634.
McCuen, R. H.: 1994, ‘Constructivist Learning Model for Ethics Education’, Journal of Professional Issues in Engineering Education and Practice 120(3), 273–278.
McDonald, G. M. and G. D. Donleavy: 1995, ‘Objections to the Teaching of Business Ethics’, Journal of Business Ethics 14(10), 839–853.
McNaughton, D.: 1988, Moral Vision An Introduction to Ethics (Blackwell, Oxford).
McPhail, K. J.: 1999, ‘The Threat of Ethical Accountants: An Application of Foucault's Concept of Ethics to Accounting Education and Some Thoughts on Ethically Educating for the Other’, Critical Perspectives on Accounting 10, 833–866.
McPhail, K. J.: forthcoming, ‘The Dialectic of Accounting Education: From Role Identity to Ego Identity’, Critical Perspectives on Accounting.
Mahoney, J.: 1990, ‘An International Look at Business Ethics: Britain’, Journal of Business Ethics 9(7), 545–550.
Mahoney, J.: 1993, ‘Teaching Business Ethics’, Professional Manager, March, 13–15.
Mai-Dalton, R. R.: 1987, ‘The Experience of One Faculty Member in a Business Ethics Seminar: What Can We Take to the Classroom?’, Journal of Business Ethics 6(7), 509–511.
Marcel, G.: 1962, Man Against Mass Society (Henry Regnery, Chicago).
Matasar, R. A.: 1989, ‘Teaching Ethics in Civil Procedure Courses’ Journal of Legal Education 39(4), 587–607.
Michalos, A.: 1979, ‘The Loyal Agent's Argument’, as reprinted in T. L. Beauchamp and N. E. Bowie (eds.), Ethical Theory and Business (Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs), pp. 338–348.
Mickleborough and Wareham: 1994, ‘Teaching Engineering to Increase Motivation’, Journal of Professional Issues in Engineering Education and Practice 120(1), 29–35.
Miles, S. H., L. W. Lane, J. Bickle, R. M. Walker and C. K. Cassel: 1989, ‘Medical Ethics Education: Coming of Age’, Academic Medicine 64, 705–714.
Milgram, S.: 1974, Obedience to Authority: An Experimental View (Tavistock Publications, London).
Miller, P. and T. O'Leary: 1987, ‘Accounting and the Construction of the Governable Person’, Accounting, Organizations and Society 12(3), 235–265.
Moliterno, J. E.: 1996, ‘On The Future of Integration Between Skills and Ethics Teaching: Clinical Legal Education in the Year 2010’, Journal of Legal Education 46(1).
Morgan, G.: 1998, ‘Accounting As Reality Construction: Towards a New Epistemology for Accounting Practice’, Accounting, Organizations and Society 13(5), 477–485.
Myser, C., I. H. Kerridge and K. R. Mitchell: 1995, ‘Teaching Clinical Ethics as a Professional Skill: Bridging the Gap Between Knowledge About Ethics and its Use in Clinical Practice’, Journal of Medical Ethics 21, 97–103.
Nielsen, R. P.: 1991, ‘I Am We Consciousness and Dialog as Organizational Ethics Method’, Journal of Business Ethics 10, 649–663.
Osler, F. and A. Schafli: 1985, ‘The Thin Line Phenomenon: Helping Bank Trainees Form a Social and Moral Identity’, in G. Lind, H. A. Hartmann and R. Wakenhut (eds.), Moral Development and the Social Environment (Precedent Publishers, Chicago).
Parker, M.: 1995, ‘Autonomy, Problem-Based Learning and the Teaching of Medical Ethics’, Journal of Medical Ethics 21, 305–310.
Pask, G.: 1976, ‘Conversational Techniques in the Study and Practice of Education’, British Journal of Educational Psychology 46, 12–25.
Patten, R. J. and D. Z. Williams: 1990, ‘There's Trouble-Right Here in Our Accounting Programs: The Challenge to Accounting Educators’, Issues in Accounting Education 5(2), 175–179.
Peek, L. E., G. S. Peek and M. Horras: 1994, ‘Enhancing Arthur Andersen Business Ethics Vignettes: Group Discussion Using Co-operative/Collaborative Learning Techniques’, Journal of Business Ethics 13(3), 189–196.
Ponemon, L. A.: 1992, ‘Ethical Reasoning and Selection-Socialization in Accounting’, Accounting, Organizations and Society 17(3/4), 239–258.
Popescu, C.: 1987, ‘Construction Engineering Graduate Education Survey’, Journal of Professional Issues in Engineering Education and Practice, ASCE 113(4), 664–668.
Power, M. K.: 1991, ‘Educating Accountants: Towards A Critical Ethnography’, Accounting, Organizations and Society 16(4), 333–353.
Proctor, R. F.: 1993, ‘Using Feature Films to Teach Critical Thinking: Multiple Morals to the Stories’, Speech Communication Teacher 7, 11–12.
Proctor, R. F. and R. Adler: 1991, ‘Teaching Interpersonal Communication with Feature Films’, Communication Education 40, 393–400.
Rhode, D. L.: 1992, ‘Ethics by the Pervasive Method’, Journal of Legal Education 42(1), 31.
Robertson, H. D.: 1987, ‘Developing Ethics Education in Construction Education Programs’, Proceedings of the 23rd Annual Conf. of Associated Schools of Construction, Purdue University W.Lafayetter, Ind., 140–143.
Romisowski, A. J.: 1981, Designing Instructional Systems (Kogan Page, London).
Russel, J. S. and R. G. McCullouch: 1990, ‘Civil Engineering Education: Case Study Approach’, Journal of Professional Issues in Engineering Education and Practice, ASCE, 116(2), 164–174.
Saunders, M.: 1995, ‘The Forgotten Curriculum: An Argument for Medical Ethics Education’, Journal of the American Medical Association 274, 768–769.
Schweiker, W.: 1993, ‘Accounting for Ourselves: Accounting Practice and the Discourse of Ethics’, Accounting, Organizations and Society 18(2/3), 231–252.
Serey, T.: 1992, ‘Carpe Diem: Lessons About Life and Management from Dead Poets Society’, Journal of Management Education 16, 374–399.
Shea, G. F.: 1988, Practical Ethics (American Management Association Membership Publications Division, New York).
Shepard, J. M. and L. S. Hartenian: 1991, ‘Egoistic and Ethical Orientations of University Students Towards Work Related Decisions’, Journal of Business Ethics 10(4), 303–310.
Shepard, J. M., M. G. Goldsby and V. W. Gerde: 1997, ‘Teaching Business Ethics Through Literature’, The Online Journal of Ethics.
Stanga, K. G. and R. A. Turpen: 1991, ‘Ethical Judgements on Selected Accounting Issues: An Empirical Study’, Journal of Business Ethics 10(10), 739–747.
Stead, B. A. and J. J. Miller: 1988, ‘Can Social Awareness Be Increased Through Business Curricula?’, Journal of Business Ethics 7(7), 553–560.
Stenhouse, L.: 1975, An Introduction to Curriculum Research and Development (Heinemann, London).
Smith, M. B. E.: 1990, ‘Should Lawyers Listen To Philosophers About Legal Ethics?’, Law and Philosophy 9, 67–93.
Tansel, B.: 1994, ‘Outlook For Environmental Education In 21st Century’, Journal of Professional Issues in Engineering Education and Practice 120(1), 129–134.
Tinker, A. M., B. D. Merino and M. P. Neimark: 1982, ‘The Normative Origins of Positive Theories: Ideology and Accounting Thought’, Accounting Organizations and Society 7(2), 167–200.
Tinker, A. M.: 1985, Paper Prophets: A Social Critique of Accountancy (Holt Saunders, Eastbourne).
Tucker, W. H.: 1983, ‘Dilemmas in Teaching Engineering Ethics’, Journal of Chemical Engineering Process 79(4), 20–25.
Veshosky, D. and J. H. Egbers: 1991, ‘Civil Engineering Project Management Game: Teaching With Simulation’, Journal of Professional Issues in Engineering Education and Practice, ASCE 117(3), 203–213.
Vesilind, P. A.: 1991, ‘Views on Teaching Ethics and Morals’, Professional Issues In Engineering Education and Practice 117(2), 88–95.
Waples, E. and M. K. Shaub: 1991, ‘Establishing an Ethic of Accounting: A Response to Westra's Call for Government Employment of Auditors’, Journal of Business Ethics 10(5), 385–393.
Weatherall, D. J.: 1995, ‘Teaching Ethics to Medical Students’, Journal of Medical Ethics 21, 133–134.
Webb, J.: 1996, ‘Inventing the Good: A Prospectus for Clinical Education and the Teaching of Legal Ethics in England’, The Law Teacher 30(3), 270–294.
Weisberg and Duffin: 1995, ‘Evoking the Moral Imagination: Using Stories to Teach Ethics and Professionalism to Nursing, Medical and Law Students’, The Journal of Medical Humanities 16(4), 247–262.
Wichman, A. and R. Foa: 1996, ‘Ethics Education in Neurology Residency Programs: Results of a Survey’, Neurology 46(5), 1481–1483.
Wilcox, J. R.: 1983, ‘The Teaching of Engineering Ethics’, Journal of Chemical Engineering Process 79(5), 15–20.
Williamson, B.: 1996, ‘Medical Ethics, Teaching and the New Genetics’, Journal of Medical Ethics 22, 325–326.
Willmott, H. C.: 1989, ‘Serving The Public Interest? A Critical Analysis of a Professional Claim’ in D. J. Cooper and T. M. Hopper (eds.), Critical Accounts (Macmillan, Basingstoke) 325–326.
White, J. B.: 1985, Heracles' Bow (University of Wisconsin Press, Madison).
Zorn, T.: 1991, ‘Willy Loman's Lesson: Teaching Identity Management with Death of a Salesman’, Communication Education 40, 219–224.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
McPhail, K. The Other Objective of Ethics Education: Re-humanising the Accounting Profession – A Study of Ethics Education in Law, Engineering, Medicine and Accountancy. Journal of Business Ethics 34, 279–298 (2001). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1012576631990
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1012576631990