Abstract
We introduce a distinction between cortical dominance andcortical deference, and apply it to various examples ofneural plasticity in which input is rerouted intermodally orintramodally to nonstandard cortical targets. In some cases butnot others, cortical activity `defers' to the nonstandard sourcesof input. We ask why, consider some possible explanations, andpropose a dynamic sensorimotor hypothesis. We believe that thisdistinction is important and worthy of further study, bothphilosophical and empirical, whether or not our hypothesis turnsout to be correct. In particular, the question of how the distinction should be explained is linked to explanatory gapissues for consciousness. Comparative and absolute explanatorygaps should be distinguished: why does neural activity in aparticular area of cortex have this qualitative expressionrather than that, and why does it have any qualitativeexpression at all? We use the dominance/deference distinction toaddress the comparative gaps, both intermodal and intramodal (notthe absolute gap). We do so not by inward scrutiny but rather by expanding our gaze to include relations between brain, body andenvironment.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Arho, P., Capelle, C., Wanet-Defalque, M.C., Catalan-Ahumada, M. and Veraart, C.: 1999, ‘Auditory Coding of Visual Patterns for the Blind’, Perception 28(8), 1013-1029.
Bach-y-Rita, P.: 1972, BrainMechanisms in Sensory Substitution, Academic Press, New York.
Bach-y-Rita, P.: 1995, Nonsynaptic Diffusion of Neurotransmission and Late Brain Reorganization, Demos-Vermande, New York.
Bach-y-Rita, P.: 1984, ‘The Relationship between Motor Processes and Cognition in Tactile Visual Substitution’, in W. Prinz and A.F. Sanders (eds), Cognition and Motor Processes, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, pp. 149-160.
Bach-y-Rita, P.: 1996, ‘Sustitucion sensorielle et qualia’, in J. Proust (ed.), Perception et Intermodalité, Presses Universitaires de France, Paris). Reprinted in English translation in Noë, A. and Thompson, E.: 2002, Vision and Mind: Selected Readings in the Philosophy of Perception, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.
Bach-y-Rita, P., Collins, C.C., Saunders, F., White, B., and Scadden, L. 1969, Nature 221, 963-964.
Borsook, D., Becerra, L., Fishman, S., Edwards, A., Jennings, C.L., Stonjanovic, M., Papinicolas, L., Ramachandran, V.S., Gonzalez, R.G. and Breiter, H.: 1998, ‘Acute Plasticity in the Human Somatosensory Cortex Following Amputation’, Neuroreport 9(6), 1013-1017.
Botvinik, M., and Cohen, J.: 1998, ‘Rubber Hands ‘Feel’ Touch that Eyes See’, Nature 391(6669), 756.
Buchel, C.: 1998, ‘Functional Neuroimaging Studies of Braille Reading: Cross-modal Reorganization and Its Implications’, Brain 121, 1193-1194.
Buchel, C., Price, C., Frackowiak, R.S.J. and Friston, K.: 1998, ‘Different Activation Patterns in the Visual Cortex of Late and Congenitally Blind Subjects’, Brain 121, 409-419.
Carman, L.S., Pallas, S.L. and Sur, M.: 1992, ‘Visual Inputs Routed to Auditory Pathway in Ferrets’, Society for Neuroscience Abstracts 18, 593.
Chalmers, D.: 1996, The Conscious Mind, Oxford University Press, New York.
Cohen, L.G., Celnik, P., Pascual-Leone, A., Corwell, B., Faiz, L., Dambrosia, J., Honda, M., Sadato, N., Gerloff, C., Catala, M.D. and Hallett, M.: 1997a, ‘Functional Relevance of Cross-modal Plasticity in Blind Humans’, Nature 389, 180-183.
Cohen L.G., Weeks, R., Celnik, P. and Hallett, M.: 1997b, ‘Role of the Occipital Cortex During Braille Reading (Cross-Modal Plasticity) in Subjects with Blindness Acquired Late in Life’, Society for Neuroscience Abstracts (92.1).
Cohen, L.G., Weeks, R.A., Sadato, N., Celnik, P., Ishii, K. and Hallett, M.: 1999, ‘Period of Susceptibility of Cross-Modal Plasticity in the Blind’, Annals of Neurology 45(4), 451-460.
Cole, D.: 1990, ‘Functionalism and Inverted Spectra’, Synthese 82, 207-222.
Elman, J., Bates, E., Johnson, M., Karmiloff-Smith, A., Parisi, D. and Plunkett, K.: 1996, Rethinking Innateness, MIT Press, Cambridge.
Hadjikhani, M., Liu, A.K., Dale, A., Cavanagh, P. and Tootell, R.B.H.: 1998, ‘Retinotopy and Color Sensitivity in Human Visual Cortical Area V8’, Nature Neuroscience, 235-241.
Halligan, P.W., Marshall, J.C. and Wade, D.T.: 1994, ‘Sensory Disorganization and Perceptual Plasticity after Limb Amputation: A Follow-up Study’, Neuroreport 5(11), 1341-1345.
Hardin, C.L.: 1997, ‘Reinverting the Spectrum’, in A. Byrne and D.R. Hilbert (eds), Readings on Color: Volume 1, The Philosophy of Color, MIT Press, Cambridge, pp. 289-301.
Harris, C.: 1965, ‘Perceptual Adaptation to Inverted, Reversed, and Displaced Vision’, Psychological Review 72(6), 419-444.
Harris, C.: 1980, ‘Insight or Out of Sight?: Two Examples of Perceptual Plasticity in the Human Adult’, in Charles S. Harris (ed.), Visual Coding and Adaptability, Erlbaum, Hillsdale, NJ, pp. 95-149.
Hurley, S.L.: 1998a, Consciousness in Action, Harvard University Press, Cambridge.
Hurley, S.L.: 1998b, ‘Vehicles, Contents, Conceptual Structure, and Externalism’, Analysis 58(1), 1-6.
Knecht, S., Henningsen, H., Hohling, C., Elbert, T., Flor, H., Pantev, C. and Taub, E.: 1998, ‘Plasticity of Plasticity? Changes in the Pattern of Perceptual Correlates of Reorganization after Amputation’, Brain 121(4), 717-724.
Kohler, I.: 1951, ‘Ñber Aufbau und Wandlungen der Wahrnehmungswelt’, Österreichische Akademie der Wissenschaften. Sitzungsberichte, philosophish-historische Klasse 227, 1-118.
Kohler, I.: 1964, The Formation and Transformation of the Perceptual World. Published as a monograph in Psychological Issues vol. 3 (monograph 12), New York International University Press. [This is a translation of Kohler 1951.]
Kujala, T., Alho, K. and Naatenen, R.: 2000, ‘Cross-modal Reorganization of Human Cortical Functions’, Trends in Neuroscience 23(3), 115-120.
Levine, J.: 1993, ‘On Leaving out What It's Like’, in Martin Davies and Glyn Humphreys (eds), Consciousness, Blackwell, Cambridge, pp. 121-136.
Marks, L.E.: 1987, ‘On Cross-modal Similarity: Auditory-visual Interactions in Speeded Discriminations’, Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance 13(3), 384-394.
Mattingley, J.B., Rich, A.N., Yelland, G. and Bradshaw, J.L.: 2001, ‘Unconscious Priming Eliminates Automatic Binding of Colour and Alphanumeric form in Synaesthesia’, Nature 410, 580-582.
Maudlin, T.: 1989, ‘Computation and Consciousness’, Journal of Philosophy, 407-432.
Meijer, P.B.L.: 1992, ‘An Experimental System for Auditory Image Representations’, IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering 39(2), 112-121. Reprinted in the 1993 IMIA Yearbook of Medical Informatics, pp. 291–300.
Merzenich, M.: 2000, ‘Seeing in the Sound Zone’, Nature 404, 820-821.
Mueller, J.: 1838, Handbuch der Physiologie des Menschen (Vol. V), Hölscher, Coblenz.
Myin, E.: 2001, ‘Color and the Duplication Assumption’, Synthese 129, 61-77.
Noë, A.: 2002, ‘On What We See’, Pacific Philosophical Quarterly 83(1), 57-80.
Noë, A.: forthcoming, Action in Perception, The MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.
Noë, A. and O'Regan, K.: 2000, ‘Perception, Attention, and the Grand Illusion’, Psyche 6(15). URL:http://psyche.cs.monash.edu.au/v6/psyche-6-15-noe.html.
Noë, A. and O'Regan, K.: 2002, ‘On the Brain-basis of Visual Consciousness: A Sensorimotor Account’, in A. Noë and E. Thompson (eds), Vision and Mind: Selected Readings in the Philosophy of Perception, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.
Noë, A. and Thompson, E.: forthcoming, ‘Are there Neural Correlates of Consciousness?’ Journal of Consciousness Studies.
Nunn, J.A., Gregory, L.J., Brammer, M., Williams, S.C.R., Parslow, D.M., Morgan, M.J., Morris, R., Bullmore, E., Baron-Cohen, S. and Gray, J.A.: 2002, ‘Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging of Synesthesia: Activation of Color Vision Area V4/V8 by Spoken Words’, Nature Neuroscience 5(4), 371-374.
O'Regan, K. and Noë, A.: 2001a, ‘A Sensorimotor Account of Vision and Visual Consciousness’, Behavioral and Brain Sciences 24(5), 883-917.
O'Regan, K. and Noë, A.: 2001b, ‘Acting out Our Sensory Experience’, Behavioral and Brain Sciences 24(5), 955-975.
O'Regan, K. and Noë, A.: 2001c, ‘What It Is Like to See: A Sensorimotor Theory of Perceptual Experience’, Synthese 129(1): 79-103.
O'Regan, J.K., Myin, E. and Noë, A.: submitted, ‘What It's Like to Feel: An Explanation in Terms of Bodiliness and Grabbiness’, Trends in Cognitive Sciences.
Pallas, S.L.: 2001, ‘Intrinsic and Extrinsic Factors that Shape Neocorticial Specification’, Trends in Neuroscience 24(7), 411-423.
Pallas, S.L. and Sur, M.: 1993, ‘Visual Projections Induced into the Auditory Pathway of Ferrets: II. Coriticocoritical Connections of Primary Auditory Cortex’, Journal of Comparative Neurology 337(2), 317-333.
Pettit, P.: in press, ‘Looks Red’, Philosophical Issues 13.
Ramachandran, V.S., Rogers-Ramachandran, D. and Cobb, S.: 1995, ‘Touching the Phantom Limb’, Nature 377, 490-491.
Ramachandran, V.S. and Rogers-Ramachandran, D.: 1996, ‘Synaesthesia in Phantom Limbs Induced with Mirrors’, Proceedings of the Royal Society 263, 377-386.
Ramachandran, V.S. and Blakeslee, S.: 1998, Phantoms in the Brain, Fourth Estate, London.
Ramachandran, V.S. and Hirstein, W.: 1998, ‘The Perception of Phantom Limbs’, Brain 121(9), 1603-1630.
Ramachandran, V.S. and Hubbard, E.M.: 2001, ‘Synaesthesia – A Window into Perception, Thought and Language’, Journal of Consciousness Studies 8(12), 3-34.
Rauschecker, J.P.: 1996, ‘Substitution of Visual by Auditory Inputs in the Cat's Anterior Ectosylvian Cortex’, Prog. Brain Research 112, 313-323.
Rich, A. N. and Mattingley, J.: 2002, ‘Anomalous Perception in Synaesthesia’, Nature Reviews: Neuroscience 3, 43-52.
Roe, A.W., Pallas, S.L., Hahm, J. and Sur, M.: 1990, ‘A Map of Visual Space Induced in Primary Auditory Cortex’, Science 250 (4982), 818-820.
Roe, A.W., Pallas, S.L., Kwon, Y.H. and Sur, M.: 1992, ‘Visual Projections Routed to the Auditory Pathway in Ferrets’, Journal of Neuroscience 12(9), 3651-3664.
Sadato, N., Pascual-Leone, A., Grafman, J., Ibanez, V., Deiber, M.P., Dold, G. and Hallett, M.: 1996, ‘Activation of the Primary Visual Cortex by Braille Reading in Blind Subjects’, Nature 380(6574), 526-528.
Sadato, N., Pascual-Leone, A., Grafman, J., Deiber, M.P., Ibanez, V. and Hallett, M.: 1998, ‘Neural Networks for Braille Reading by the Blind’, Brain 121(7), 1213-1229.
Sampaio, E., Maris, S. and Bach-y-Rita, P.: 2001, ‘Brain Plasticity: ‘Visual’ Acuity of Blind Persons via the Tongue’, Brain Res 908(2), 204-207.
Sharma, J., Angelucci, A. and Sur, M.: 2000, ‘Induction of Visual Orientation Modules in Auditory Cortex’, Nature 404(6780), 841-847.
Stratton, G.M.: 1897, ‘Vision Without Inversion of the Retinal Image’, Psychological Review 4, 341–360, 463–481.
Sur, M., Angelucci, A. and Sharma, J.: 1999, ‘Rewiring Cortex: The Role of Patterned Activity in Development and Plasticity of Neocortical Circuits’, Journal of Neurobiology 41(1), 33-43.
Taylor, J.: 1962, The Behavioral Basis of Perception, Yale University Press, New Haven and London.
Teller, D.Y. and Pugh, E.N. Jr.: 1983, ‘Linking Propositions in Color Vision’, in J.D. Mollon and L.T. Sharpe (eds), Colour Vision, Academic Press, London, pp. 577-589.
Tootell, R.B.H. and Hadjikhani, N.: 1998, ‘Has a New Color Area Been Discovered? Reply to Zeki’, Nature Neuroscience 1(5), 335-336.
Thompson, E.: 1995, Color Vision, Routledge, London.
van Gulick, R.: 1993, ‘Understanding the Phenomenal Mind’, in M. Davies and G. Humphreys (eds), Consciousness, Blackwell, Oxford, pp. 137-154.
von Melcher, L., Pallas, S.L. and Sur, M.: 2000, ‘Visual Behaviour Mediated by Retinal Projections Directed to the Auditory Pathway’, Nature 404(6780), 871-876.
Zeki, S., McKeefry, D.J., Bartels, A. and Frackowiak, R.S.J.: 1998, ‘Has a New Color Area Been Discovered?’ Nature Neuroscience 1(5), 335-336.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Hurley, S., Noë, A. Neural Plasticity and Consciousness. Biology & Philosophy 18, 131–168 (2003). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1023308401356
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1023308401356