Abstract
As the development of the information society takes place worldwide, individuals, groups and organisations face the challenge of taking advantage of information and communication technologies (ICTs). ‘Digital divides’ are emerging: some sections of society are gaining access to information, knowledge and technologies while others are being excluded. There also seems to be an over-concentration on the use of ICTs for organisational purposes, with traditional information systems (IS) planning approaches largely ignoring the needs and concerns that people express outside formal organisations. One answer to this problem might be to adopt a systems approach to IS planning. At first sight this appears to be a good idea because of the aspiration of systems approaches to comprehensiveness, presumably looking beyond organisational concerns. However, a review of two popular systems methodologies employed in IS planning suggests that there is potential for their scope to be equally limited by organisational boundaries. There is a need to enhance the critical review of the boundaries of IS planning processes, enabling people to consider family, community and other concerns. In this paper, we use the systems theory of boundary critique to derive a set of questions to help practitioners reflect on different possible boundaries for IS planning exercises. These should be seen as complementary to existing systems approaches rather than as a replacement for them, enabling the latter to be practised more critically. We end by presenting our reflections on using these questions in the context of an IS planning project in a Colombian University.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Ackoff R (1981) Creating the Corporate Future: Plan or to be Planned for. John Wiley and Sons, New York.
Afele JS (2003) Digital Bridges: Developing Countries in the Knowledge Economy. Idea Group Pub, Hershey, PA.
Alvesson M and Willmott H (1992) Critical theory and management studies: an introduction. In Critical Management Studies (ALVESSON M and WILLMOTT H, Eds), pp 1–20, Sage, London.
Alvesson M and Willmott H (1996) Making Sense of Management: A Critical Introduction. Sage, London.
Avgerou C (2001) The significance of context in information systems and organizational change. Information Systems Journal 11, 43–63.
Avison D, Wood-Harper AT, Vidgen RT and Wood JRG (1998) A further exploration into information systems development: the evolution of Multiview2. Information Technology and People 11 (2), 124–139.
Avison DE and Wood-Harper AT (1990) Multiview: An Exploration in Information Systems Development. Alfred Waller (McGraw-Hill Publishing Company), Henley on Thames.
Ball K and Wilson D (2000) Power, control and computer-based performance monitoring: a subjectivist approach to repertoires and resistance. Organization Studies 21 (3), 539–565.
Bangemann M (1994) Europe and the global information society: recommendations to the European Council. Report to the Commission, Commission of the European Communities (CEC), Brussels.
Bannon L (1997) Conceptualising the information society. The Economic and Social Review 28 (3), 301–305.
Beck E, Madon S and Sahay S (2004) On the margins of the ‘Information Society’: a comparative study of mediation. The Information Society 20, 279–290.
Bennetts P, Wood-Harper AT and Hills S (2000) A holistic approach to the management of information systems development: a view using a soft systems approach and multiple viewpoints. Systems Research and Behavioral Science 13 (2), 189–205.
Castells M (1996) The Rise of the Network Society. Blackwell Publishers, Cambridge, MA.
Castells M (2001) The Internet Galaxy: Reflections on Internet, Business and Society. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
CEC (1997) Green paper on the convergence of the telecommunications, media and information technology sectors, and the implications for regulation: towards an information society approach. Commission of the European Communities (CEC), Brussels.
Cecez-Kecmanovic D, Janson M and Brown A (2002) The rationality framework for a critical study of information systems. Journal of Information Technology 17, 215–227.
Champion D and Stowell FA (2001) PEarl: a systems approach to demonstrating authenticity in information systems design. Journal of Information Technology 16, 3–12.
Checkland P (1981) Systems Thinking, Systems Practice. John Wiley and Sons, London.
Checkland P (1984) Seminar at the Department of Systems Science, City University (London, UK).
Checkland P (2006) Seminar at Hull University Business School, 5 April 2006, University of Hull, Hull.
Checkland P and Holwell S (1998) Information, Systems and Information Systems: Making Sense of the Field. John Wiley and Sons, Chichester.
Checkland P and Poulter J (2006) Learning for Action: A Short Definitive Account of Soft Systems Methodology and Its Use for Practitioners, Teachers and Students. John Wiley, Chichester.
Checkland P and Scholes P (1990) Soft Systems Methodology in Action. John Wiley and Sons, Chichester.
Christopher M (2005) Logistics and Supply Chain Management: Creating Value-Added Networks. Prentice-Hall, Harlow, UK.
Churchman CW (1968) The Systems Approach. Delacorte Press, New York.
Churchman CW (1970) Operations research as a profession. Management Science 17, b37–b53.
Churchman CW (1971) The Design of Inquiring Systems. Basic Books, New York.
Churchman CW (1979) The Systems Approach and its Enemies. Basic Books, New York.
Ciborra C (1994) The grassroots of IT strategy. In Strategic Information Systems: A European Perspective (CIBORRA C and JELASSI T, Eds), pp 3–24, John Wiley, Chichester, UK.
Ciborra C (2001) From Control to Drift: The Dynamics of Corporate Information Infrastructures. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Clarke S (2007) Information Systems Strategic Management: An Integrated Approach. Routledge, London.
Córdoba JR (2002) A critical systems thinking approach for the planning of information technology in the information society. PhD Thesis, Centre for Systems Studies, University of Hull.
Córdoba JR (2006) Using Foucault to analyse ethics in the practice of problem structuring methods. Journal of the Operational Research Society 57 (9), 1027–1034.
Córdoba JR and Midgley G (2003) Addressing organisational and societal concerns: an application of critical systems thinking to information systems planning in Colombia. In Critical Reflections on Information Systems: A Systemic Approach (CANO J, Ed), pp 159–208, Idea Group Publishing, Hershey, PA.
Córdoba JR and Midgley G (2006) Broadening the boundaries: an application of critical systems thinking to IS planning in Colombia. Journal of the Operational Research Society 57 (9), 1064–1080.
DOT Force (2000) Okinawa charter on global information society, declaration of the G8. Japanese Government, Okinawa, http://www.dotforce.org/reports/it1.html, February 2003.
Dunleavy P, Margetts H, Bastow S and Tinkler J (2006) Digital Era Governance: IT Corporations, the State, and E-Government. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Earl M (1998) An organizational approach to IS strategy making. In Information Management: The Organizational Dimension (EARL M, Eds), pp 136–170, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Evans K (2004) Maintaining Community in the Information Age. Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke.
Flood RL (1995) Total systems intervention (TSI): a reconstitution. Journal of the Operational Research Society 46, 174–191.
Flood RL and Jackson MC (1991a) Creative Problem Solving: Total Systems Intervention. John Wiley and Sons, Chichester.
Flood RL and Jackson MC (1991b) Critical Systems Thinking: Directed Readings. John Wiley and Sons, Chichester.
Flood RL and Romm N (1996) Diversity Management: Triple Loop Learning. John Wiley and Sons, Chichester.
Fuenmayor R (2000) A brief crack of light? Systemic Practice and Action Research 13 (6), 757–772.
Galliers R (1993) IT strategies: beyond competitive advantage. Journal of Strategic Information Systems 2 (4), 283–291.
Galliers R (1995) Re-orienting information systems strategy: integrating information systems into the business. In Information Systems Provision: The Contribution of Soft Systems Methodology (STOWELL F, Eds), pp 51–74, McGraw-Hill, London.
Galliers R (1999) Towards the integration of e-business, knowledge management and policy considerations within an information systems strategy framework. Journal of Strategic Information Systems 8 (3), 229–234.
Galliers R (2004) Reflections on information systems strategizing. In The Social Study of Information and Communication Technology: Innovation, Actors and Contexts (AVGEROU C, et al., Eds), pp 231–262, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Habermas J (1976) Communication and the Evolution of Society. Heinemann, London.
Habermas J (1984) The Theory of Communicative Action – Volumes One and Two. Polity Press, Cambridge, UK.
Hagedoorn J and Duysters G (2002) External sources of innovative capabilities: the preference for strategic alliances or merges and acquisitions. Journal of Management Studies 39 (2), 167–188.
Hammer M and Champy J (1995) Re-Engineering the Corporation: A Manifesto for Business Revolution. Nicholas Brealey, London.
Hawkins R (1995) Enhancing the user role in the development of technical standards for telecommunications. Technology Analysis and Strategic Management 1, 21–40.
Henderson J and Venkatraman N (1999) Strategic alignment: leveraging information technology for transforming organisations. IBM Systems Journal 38 (2&3), 472–484.
Hirschheim R and Klein H (1989) Four paradigms of information systems development. Communications of the ACM 32 (10), 1199–1216.
Hirschheim R and Klein H (1994) Realising emancipatory principles in information systems development: the case for ETHICS. MIS Quarterly 18 (1), 83–105.
Howcroft D and Wilson M (2003) Participation: ‘Bounded freedom’ or hidden constraints on user involvement. New Technology Work and Employment 18 (1), 2–19.
Information Society Commission (1999) Information society Ireland: discussion document on IT access for all. Information Society Commission, Dublin. http://www.isc.ie, accessed in March 2000.
Ivanov K (1991) Critical systems thinking and information technology: some summary reflections, doubts and hopes through critical thinking critically considered, and through hyper systems. Journal of Applied Systems Analysis 18, 39–55.
Jackson MC (1982) The nature of soft systems thinking: the work of Churchman, Ackoff and Checkland. Journal of Applied Systems Analysis 9, 17–29.
Jackson MC (1991) Systems Methodology for the Management Sciences. Plenum, New York.
Jackson MC (2000) Systems Approaches to Management. Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers, London.
Jackson MC (2003a) Creative Holism: Systems Thinking for Managers. John Wiley and Sons, Chichester.
Jackson MC (2003b) Deeper complementarism: a brief response to Ulrich. Journal of the Operational Research Society 54 (11), 1225–1226.
Japanese Government (2000) First meeting of the digital opportunity task force (dotforce). G8, Okinawa. http://www.glocom.ac.jp/dotforce/TokyoPlen.doc, accessed on the 14 January 2002.
Jasperson JS, Carte T, Saunders CS, Butler BS, Croes HJP and Zheng W (2002) Power and information technology research: a metatriangulation review. MIS Quarterly 26 (4), 397–459.
Jermier J (1998) Introduction: critical perspectives on organizational control. Administrative Science Quarterly 43 (2), 235–256.
Keen PGW (1991) Shaping the Future: Business Design through Information Technology. Harvard Business School Press, Harvard, MA.
Klein H and Huynh MQ (2004) The critical social theory of Jurgen Habermas and its implications for IS research. In Social Theory and Philosophy for Information Systems (MINGERS J and WILLCOCKS L, Eds), pp 157–237, John Wiley and Sons, Chichester.
Klein H and Lyytinen K (1985) The poverty of scientism in information systems. In Research Methods in Information Systems: Proceedings of the IFIP 8.2 Colloquium (MUMFORD E, Ed), pp 131–161, North Holland, Amsterdam.
Lewis P (1994) Information Systems Development: Systems Thinking in the Field of Information Systems. Pitman Publishing, London.
Linstone H (1999) Decision Making for Technology Executives: Using Multiple Perspectives to Improve Performance. Artech House, Boston, MA.
Lyytinen K (1992) Information systems and critical theory. In Critical Management Studies (ALVESSON M and WILLMOTT H, Eds), pp 159–180, Sage, London.
Lyytinen K and Klein HK (1985) The critical theory of Jurgen Habermas as a basis for a theory of information systems. In Research Methods in Information Systems (MUMFORD E, Ed), pp 219–236, Elsevier, Amsterdam.
Mansell R (2002) Inside The Communication Revolution: Evolving Patterns of Social and Technical Interaction. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Mansell R and Steinmueller W (2000) Mobilizing the Information Society: Strategies for Growth and Opportunity. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Mattelart A (2003) The Information Society: An Introduction. Sage, London.
Menzies H (1996) Whose Brave New World? The Information Highway and the New Economy. Between the Lines, Toronto.
Midgley G (1992) The sacred and profane in critical systems thinking. Systems Practice 5, 5–16.
Midgley G (1996) What is this thing called CST?. In Critical Systems Thinking: Current Research and Practice (FLOOD RL and ROMM N, Eds), pp 11–24, Plenum Press, New York.
Midgley G (1997) Mixing methods: developing systemic intervention. In Multimethodology: The Theory and Practice of Combining Management Science Methodologies (MINGERS J and GILL A, Eds), pp 249–290, John Wiley and Sons, Chichester.
Midgley G (2000) Systemic Intervention: Philosophy, Methodology and Practice. Kluwer Academic/Plenum, New York.
Midgley G (2003) Introduction and overview of systems thinking. In Systems thinking volume 1 General systems theory, cybernetics and complexity (MIDGLEY G, Eds), pp xvii–liii, Sage, London.
Midgley G and Ochoa-Arias A (2004) An introduction to community operational research. In Community Operational Research: OR and Systems Thinking for Community Development (MIDGLEY G and OCHOA-ARIAS A, Eds), pp 1–36, Plenum, New York.
Midgley G, Munlo I and Brown M (1998) The theory and practice of boundary critique: developing housing services for older people. Journal of the Operational Research Society 49, 467–478.
Mingers J (1980) Towards an appropriate social theory for applied systems thinking: critical theory and soft systems methodology. Journal of Applied Systems Analysis 7, 41–50.
Mingers J (1984) Subjectivism and soft systems methodology: a critique. Journal of Applied Systems Analysis 11, 85–113.
Mingers J (1992) Technical, practical and critical OR: past, present and future?. In Critical Management Studies (ALVESSON M and WILLMOTT H, Eds), pp 90–112, Sage, London.
Mingers J (2001) Combining IS research methods: towards a pluralist methodology. Information Systems Research 12 (3), 240–259.
Mingers J (2005) ‘More dangerous than an unanswered question is an unquestioned answer’: a contribution to the Ulrich debate. Journal of the Operational Research Society 56 (4), 468–474.
Mingers J and Brocklesby J (1996) Multimethodology: towards a framework for critical pluralism. Systemist 18, 101–131.
Mumford E (1983) Designing Human Systems for New Technology: The ETHICS Method. Manchester Business School, Manchester.
Munro I (1999) Man-machine systems: people and technology in OR. Systemic Practice and Action Research 12, 513–532.
Negroponte N (1995) Being Digital. MIT Press, Boston, MA.
NTIA (1999) Falling through the net: Defining the digital divide. National Telecommunications and Information Administration, US Department of Commerce, http://www.ntia.doc.gov/ntiahome/digitaldivide/, February 2000.
Ormerod R (1996) Information systems strategy development at Sainsbury's supermarket using ‘soft’ OR”. Interfaces 16 (1), 102–130.
Ormerod R (2005) Putting soft OR methods to work: the case of IS strategy development for the UK Parliament. Journal of the Operational Research Society 56 (12), 1379–1398.
Panagiotidis P and Edwards J (2001) Organisational learning – a critical systems thinking discipline. European Journal of Information Systems 10 (3), 136–145.
Peppard J and Ward J (2004) Beyond strategic systems: towards an IS capability. Journal of Strategic Information Systems 13 (2), 167–194.
Perelman M (1998) Class Warfare in the Information Age. Macmillan Press Ltd, London.
Piccoli G and Ives B (2005) IT-dependent strategic initiatives and sustained competitive advantage: a review and synthesis of the literature. MIS Quarterly 29 (4), 747–776.
Reponen T (1998) The role of learning in information systems planning and implementation. In Information Technology and Organisational Transformation (GALLIERS RD and BAETS WRJ, Eds), pp 133–149, John Wiley and Sons, Chichester.
Robey D and Boudreau M (1999) Accounting for the contradictory organizational consequences of information technology: theoretical directions and methodological implications. Information Systems Research 10 (2), 167–185.
Sabherwal R, Hirschheim R and Goles T (2001) The dynamics of alignment: insights from a punctuated equilibrium model. Organization Science 12 (2), 179–197.
Salmela H, Lederer A, Reponen T (2000) Information systems planning in a turbulent environment. European Journal of Information Systems 9 (1), 3–15.
Santhanam R and Hartono E (2003) Issues in linking information technology capability to firm performance. MIS Quarterly 27 (1), 125–165.
Schecter D (1991) Critical systems thinking: a connective summary. In Critical Systems Thinking: Directed Readings (FLOOD RL and JACKSON MC, Eds), pp 213–226, John Wiley and Sons, Chichester.
Stowell F (1995) Empowering the client: the relevance of SSM and interpretivism in client-led design. In Information Systems Provision: The Contribution of Soft Systems Methodology (STOWELL F, Eds), pp 118–139, McGraw-Hill, London.
Strijbos S and Basden A (2006) In Search of an Integrative Vision for Technology: Interdisciplinary Studies in Information Systems. Springer, New York.
Taylor J and Moynihan E (2002) Analysing IT ethics. Systems Research and Behavioral Science 19, 49–60.
Ulrich W (1983) Critical Heuristics of Social Planning: A New Approach to Practical Philosophy. Haupt, Berne.
Ulrich W (1987) Critical heuristics of social systems design. European Journal of Operational Research 31, 276–283.
Ulrich W (1993) Some difficulties of ecological thinking, considered from a critical systems perspective: a plea for critical holism. Systems Practice 6 (6), 583–611.
Ulrich W (1996) Critical systems thinking for citizens: a research proposal. Research Memorandum, University of Hull, Hull, UK.
Ulrich W (2000) Reflective practice in the civil society: the contribution of critically systemic thinking. Reflective Practice 1, 247–268.
Ulrich W (2001) Critically systemic discourse: a discursive approach to reflective practice in ISD (part 2). Journal of Information Technology Theory and Application 3 (3), 85–106.
Ulrich W (2003) Beyond methodology choice: critical systems thinking as critically systemic discourse. Journal of the Operational Research Society 54 (4), 325–342.
UNESCO (1992) Science and Technology in Developing Countries: Strategies for the 1990's. United Nations Educational Scientific and Cultural Organization, Paris.
Walsham G (2001) Making a World of Difference: IT in a Global Context. John Wiley, Chichester.
Ward J and Griffiths P (2002) Strategic Planning for Information Systems. John Wiley and Sons, Chichester, UK.
Webster F (2002) Theories of the Information Society. Routledge, London.
Wilcox D and Pearl M (2002) Civic and community technology. The Journal of The Communications Network 1 (1), 1–9.
Willmott H (1993) Strength is ignorance; slavery is freedom: managing culture in modern organizations. Journal of Management Studies 30 (4), 515–562.
Willmott H (1997) Management and organization studies as science? Organization 4 (3), 309–344.
Wilson B (1984) Systems: Concepts, Methodologies, and Applications. John Wiley and Sons, Chichester, UK.
Wilson B (2002) Soft Systems Methodology: Conceptual Model and its Contribution. John Wiley and Sons, Chichester.
Wood-Harper AT, Corder S, Wood JG and Watson H (1996) How we profess: the ethical systems analyst. Communications of the ACM 39 (3), 69–77.
Wresch W (1996) Disconnected: Have and Have-nots in the Information Age. Rutgers University Press, New Brunswick, NJ.
Zuboff S (1988) In the Age of the Smart Machine: The Future of Work and Power. Heinemann Professional, Oxford.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Córdoba, JR., Midgley, G. Beyond organisational agendas: using boundary critique to facilitate the inclusion of societal concerns in information systems planning. Eur J Inf Syst 17, 125–142 (2008). https://doi.org/10.1057/ejis.2008.4
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1057/ejis.2008.4