Abstract
The purpose of this study is to examine the practice of Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) Disclosure in a Saudi Arabian context. This study has two particular objectives. First, it aims to measure the level of CSR disclosure quantity and quality. Second, it aims to investigate the determinants of CSR disclosure quantity and quality in a Saudi Arabian context. The study examined a sample from Saudi non-financial listed firms covering the period of 2013–2014. In addition, it develops CSR disclosure indices to measure the level of quantity and quality of CSR disclosure. The study found that Saudi Arabian firms provided higher levels of CSR disclosure quantity; however, the quality of the disclosure was relatively low. In addition, the study found that CSR disclosure quantity was positively associated with board size and the size of audit committee. However, it is negatively associated with percentage of governmental ownership and size of remuneration committee. In contrast, the quality of CSR disclosure was positively associated with the board size and the percentage of managerial ownership. However, the study found a negative association with the percentage of independent directors. The results suggest that Saudi Arabia provides higher levels of disclosure with a lower quality. In addition, the levels of CSR disclosure quantity and quality have different drivers.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
This is the same governance code applied to companies in Saudi Arabia.
Definition of each characteristics is included in Appendix B.
Multicollinearity (also, multicolinearity or colinearity) exists when two or more variables are highly correlated, meaning that one can be linearly predicted from the other (Tabachnick and Fidell, 2007; Gujarati and Porter, 2009).
References
Abbas, J., Ali, S. and Al-Aali, A. (2012) Corporate social responsibility in Saudi Arabia. Middle East Policy I(4): 1–14.
Abd-Elsalam, O.H. and Weetman, P. (2003) Introducing international accounting standards to an emerging capital market: Relative familiarity and language effect in Egypt. Journal of International Accounting, Auditing and Taxation 12(1): 63–84.
Abdul Nasser, A.T., Wahid Abdul, E., Nazri Syed Mustapha, S.N.F. and Hudaib, M. (2006) Auditor client relationship: The case of audit tenure and auditor switching in Malaysia. Managerial Auditing Journal 21(7): 724–737.
Abdurouf, M. (2011) The corporate social responsibility disclosure: A study of listed companies in Bangladesh. Business and Economics Research Journal 2(3): 19–32.
Acock, A. (2008) A gentle introduction to Stata', Second edition, Stata Press, US. Advisory Committee on Improvements to Financial Reporting to SEC. (2008), ‘Final Report of the Advisory Committee on Improvements to Financial Reporting to the United States Securities and Exchange Commission’, pp.1–172, http://www.sec.gov/about/offices/oca/acifr/acifr-finalreport.pdf, accessed 17 April 2015.
Adams, A. (2002) Organisational factors influencing corporate social and ethical reporting. Accounting Auditing and Accountability Journal 15(2): 223–250.
Ahmed, K. and Nicholls, D. (1994) The impact of non-financial company characteristics on mandatory disclosure compliance in developing countries: The case of Bangladesh. The International Journal of Accounting 29: 62–77.
Al-Janadi, Y., Rahman, R.A. and Omar, N.H. (2013) Corporate governance mechanisms and voluntary disclosure in Saudi Arabia. Research Journal of Finance & Accounting 4(4): 25–36.
Al-Moataz, E. and Hussainey, K. (2012) Determinants of corporate governance disclosure in Saudi Arabia. Journal of Economics and Management 5(1): 52–84.
Al-Moataz, E. and Lakhal, F. (2012) Corporate Governance Disclosure and Corporate Governance Mechanisms: The Case e of Saudi Listed Companies. Conference Paper; Saudi Accounting Association, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia.
Albassam, W.M. (2014) Corporate governance, voluntary disclosure and financial performance: An empirical analysis of Saudi listed firms using mixed-methods of research design. PhD Thesis, University of Glasgow, UK, http://theses.gla.ac.uk/5280/.
Allegrini, M. and Greco, G. (2013) Corporate boards, audit committees and voluntary disclosure: Evidence from Italian listed companies. Journal of Management and Governance 17(1): 187–216.
Alsaeed, K. (2006) The association between firm-specific characteristics and disclosure: The case of Saudi Arabia. Managerial Auditing Journal 21(5): 476–496.
Alshehri, A. and Solomon, J. (2012) The evolution of corporate governance in Saudi Arabia. Conference Paper; British Accounting and Finance Association (BAFA), Brighton, UK.
Aly, D., Simon, J. and Hussainey, K. (2010) Determinants of corporate internet reporting: Evidence from Egypt. Managerial Auditing Journal 25(2): 182–202.
Anis, R., Fraser, I. and Hussainey, K. (2012) A new measure for disclosure quality. Working paper, Stirling University, UK.
Anwar, S., Siti, H. and dan, G. (2010) Pengaruh Pengungkapan Corporate Social Responsibility terhadap Kinerja Keuangan Perusahaan dan Harga Saham. Journal. Makassar: Program Pascasarjana. Universities’ Hasanuddin..
Arcay, R. and Vazquez, F. (2005) Corporate characteristics, governance rules and the extent of voluntary disclosure in Spain. Advances in Accounting 21(2): 299–331.
Arvidsson, S. (2010) communication of corporate social responsibility: A study of the views of management teams in large companies. Journal of Business Ethics 96(3): 339–354.
ASB. (2006) Reporting Statement (RS) 1, The Operating and Financial Review. Reporting Statemen. London: ASB Publications.
Barako, D.G., Hancock, P. and Izan, H.Y. (2006) Relationship between corporate governance attributes and voluntary disclosures in annual reports: The Kenyan experience. Financial Reporting, Regulation and Governance 5(1): 1–25.
Barth, M.E., Clinch, G. and Shibano, T. (1999) International accounting harmonization and global equity markets. Journal of Accounting and Economics 26(3): 201–235.
Baydoun, N., Maguire, W., Ryan, N. and Willett, R. (2013) Corporate governance in five Arabian Gulf countries. Managerial Auditing Journal 28(1): 7–22.
Beak, H.Y., Johnson, D.R. and Kim, J.W. (2009) Managerial ownership, corporate governance, and voluntary disclosure. Journal of Business and Economic Studies 15(2): 44–61.
Beest, F. and Braam, G. (2013) Conceptually-Based Financial Reporting Quality Assessment. An Empirical Analysis on Quality Differences Between UK Annual Reports and US 10-K Reports. NiCE Working Paper, November, pp. 13–106.
Beest, F.V., Braam, G. and Boelens, S. (2009) Quality of Financial Reporting: Measuring qualitative characteristics. Working paper, Radboud University Nijmegen.
Belal, A. and Cooper, S. (2011) The absence of corporate social responsibility reporting in Bangladesh. Critical perspectives on accounting 1(1): 1–14.
Beretta, S. and Bozzolan, S. (2004) A framework for the analysis of firm risk communication. The International Journal of Accounting 39(3): 265–288.
Boesso, G. and Kumar, K. (2007) Drivers of corporate voluntary disclosure: A framework and empirical evidence from Italy and the United States. Accounting, Auditing and Accountability Journal 20(2): 269–296.
Bolton, P. and Thadden, V. (1998) Blocks, liquidity, and corporate control. The Journal of Finance 53(1): 1–25.
Botosan, C. (1997) Disclosure level and the cost of equity capital. The Accounting Review 72(3): 323–350.
Botosan, C. (2004) Discussion of a framework for the analysis of firm risk communication. The International Journal of Accounting 39(3): 289–295.
Boubaker, S., Lakhal, F. and Nekhili, M. (2011) The determinants of web-based corporate reporting in France. Managerial Auditing Journal 27(2): 126–155.
Brammer, S. and Pavelin, S. (2006) Voluntary environmental disclosures by large UK companies. Journal Business Finance Accounting 33(7 & 8): 1168–1188.
Brammer, S. and Pavelin, S. (2008) Factors influencing the quality of corporate environmental disclosure. Business Strategy and the Environment 17(2): 120–136.
Brickley, J., Coles, J. and Jarrell, G. (1997) Leadership structure: Separating the CEO and chairman of the board. Journal of Corporate Finance 3(3): 189–220.
Bruton, G., Fried, V. and Hisrich, R. (1997) Venture capitalists and CEO dismissal. Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice 21(3): 41–54.
Carroll, A.B. (1983) Corporate social responsibility: Will industry respond to cut-backs in social program funding? Vital Speeches of the Day, 49, pp. 604–608.
Cerbioni, F. and Parbonetti, A. (2007) Exploring the effects of corporate governance on intellectual capital disclosure: An analysis of European biotechnology companies. European Accounting Review 16(4): 791–826.
Chakroun, R. and Hussainey, K. (2014) Disclosure quality in Tunisian annual reports. Corporate Ownership and Control 11(4): 58–80.
Chau, G. and Gray, S. (2002) Ownership structure and corporate voluntary disclosure in Hong Kong and Singapore. The International Journal of Accounting 37(1): 247–265.
Chen, C.J.P. and Jaggi, B. (2000) Association between independent nonexecutive directors, family control and financial disclosures in Hong Kong. Journal of Accounting and Public Policy 19(3): 285–310.
Chen, S., Sun, Z., Tang, S. and Wu, D. (2011) Government intervention and investment efficiency: Evidence from China. Journal of Corporate Finance 17(2): 259–271.
Cheng, C.M.E. and Courtenay, S.M. (2006) Board composition, regulatory regime and voluntary disclosure. The International Journal of Accounting 41(3): 262–289.
Christensen, J., Kent, P. and Routledge, J. (2014a) Do corporate governance recommendations improve the performance and accountability of small listed companies? Accounting and Finance 55(1): 133–164.
Christensen, L., Mackey, A. and Whetten, D. (2014b) Taking responsibility for corporate social responsibility: The role of leaders in creating, implementing, sustaining, or avoiding socially responsible firm behaviors. The Academy of Management Perspectives 28(2): 164–178.
Cleary, S. (1999) The relationship between firm investment and financial status. Journal of Finance 54(2): 673–692.
Conyon, M. and He, L. (2011) Executive compensation and corporate governance in China. Journal of Corporate Finance 17(4): 1158–1175.
Cornett, M., McNutt, J., Strahan, P. and Tehranian, H. (2010) Liquidity risk management and credit supply in the financial crisis. Journal of Financial Economics 101(2): 297–312.
Daub, H. (2007) Assessing the quality of sustainability reporting: An alternative methodological approach. Journal of Cleaner Production 15(1): 75–85.
Davidson IIIW.N., Pilger, T. and Szakmary, A. (1998) Golden parachutes, board and committee composition, and shareholder wealth. Financial Review 33(3): 17–32.
Davis, G. and Greve, H. (1997) Corporate elite networks and governance changes in the 1980s. American Journal of Sociology 103(1): 1–37.
Donaldson, L. and Davis, J.H. (1991) Stewardship theory or agency theory: CEO governance and shareholder returns. Australian Journal of management 16(1): 49–64.
Eisenhardt, K. (1989) Agency theory: An assessment and review. Academy of Management Review 14(1): 57–74.
Elshandidy, T., Fraser, I. and Hussainey, K. (2013) Aggregated, voluntary, and mandatory risk disclosure incentives: Evidence from UK FTSE all-share companies. International Review of Financial Analysis 30(1): 320–333.
Elzahar, H. (2013) Determinants and Consequences of Key Performance Indicator (KPI) Reporting by UK Non-financial Firms. PhD thesis, University of Stirling, UK.
Elzahar, H., Hussainey, K., Mazzi, F. and Tsalavoutas, I. (2015) Economic consequences of key performance indicators' disclosure quality. International Review of Financial Analysis 39(2): 96–112.
Eng, L.L. and Mak, Y.T. (2003) Corporate governance and voluntary disclosure. Journal of Accounting and Public Policy 22(4): 325–345.
Ezzamel, M. and Watson, R. (1997) Wearing two hats: The conflicting control and management roles of non -executive directors. Corporate governance: 54–79.
Fama, E.F. and Jensen, M.C. (1983) Separation of ownership and control. Journal of Law and Economics 26(2): 301–326.
Felo, A.J., Krishnamurthy, S. and Solieri, S.A. (2009) Are all audit committee financial experts created equally? International Journal of Disclosure and Governance 6(2): 150–166.
Field, A. (2009) Discovering Statistics using SPSS. London: Sage.
Financial Reporting Council, (FRC). (2008) The UK Corporate Governance Code. UK: Financial Reporting Council, (FRC).
Forker, J.J. (1992) Corporate governance and disclosure quality. Accounting and Business Research 22(86): 111–124.
Galbreath, J. (2010) Drivers of corporate social responsibility: The role of formal strategic planning and firm culture. British Journal of Management 21(2): 511–525.
Golob, U. and Bartlett, J. (2007) Communicating about corporate social responsibility: A comparative study of CSR reporting in Australia and Slovenia. Public Relations Review 33(1): 1–9.
Gray, R., Owen, D. and Adams, M. (1996) Accounting and Accountability: Social and Environmental Accounting in a Changing World, London. Hemel Hempstead, UK: Prentice Hall.
Gujarati, D.N. and Porter, D.C. (2009) Basic Econometrics, 5th edn. New York: McGraw-Hill.
Gul, A. and Leung, S. (2004) Board leadership, outside directors’ expertise and voluntary corporate disclosures. Journal of Accounting and Public Policy 23(5): 351–379.
Habbash, M., Hussainey, K. and Alsayed, A. (2015) The determinants of voluntary disclosure in Saudi Arabia: An empirical study. Working paper.
Hackston, D. and Milne, J. (1996) Some determinants of social and environmental disclosure in New Zealand companies. Accounting, Auditing and Accountability Journal 18(1): 77–108.
Hail, L. (2002) The impact of voluntary corporate disclosures on the ex-ante cost of capital for Swiss firms. Available at SSRN 279276.
Haji, A.A. (2013) Corporate social responsibility disclosures over time: Evidence from Malaysia. Managerial Auditing Journal 28(7): 647–676.
Halme, M. and Huse, M. (1997) The influence of corporate governance, industry and country factors on environmental reporting. Scandinavian Journal of Management 13(2): 137–157.
Haniffa, R. and Cooke, T. (2002) Culture, corporate governance and disclosure in Malaysian corporations. Abacus 38(3): 317–349.
Hassan, O. and Marston, C. (2010) Disclosure measurement in the empirical accounting literature: A review article’, working paper, Economics and Finance’, Brunel University, Working Paper Series, http://www.brunel.ac.uk/about/acad/sss/depts/economics, https://www.brunel.ac.uk/__data/assets/pdf_file/0003/82047/1018.pdf.
Hassanein, A. and Hussainey, K. (2015) ‘Is forward-looking financial disclosure really informative? Evidence from UK narrative statements’. International Review of Financial Analysis 41(4): 52–61.
Healy, P. and Palepu, K. (2001) Information asymmetry, corporate disclosure practice, and the capital markets: A review of empirical literature. Journal of Accounting and Economics 31(1–3): 405–440.
Ho, C.A. and Williams, S.M. (2003) International comparative analysis of the association between board structure and the efficiency of value added by a firm from its physical capital and intellectual capital resources. The International Journal of Accounting 38(4): 465–491.
Ho, S. and Wong, K. (2001) A study of the relationship between corporate governance structures and the extent of voluntary disclosure’. Journal of International Accounting, Auditing and Taxation 10(2): 139–156.
Hoitash, U., Hoitash, R. and Bedard, J.C. (2009) Corporate governance and internal control over financial reporting: A comparison of regulatory regimes. The Accounting Review 84(3): 839–867.
Hooghiemstra, R. (2000) Corporate communication and impression management. New perspectives why companies engage in corporate social reporting’. Journal of Business Ethics 27(1): 55–68.
Hossain, M., Perera, M. and Rahman, A. (1995) Voluntary disclosure in the annual reports of New Zealand Companies. Journal of International Financial Management and Accounting 6(1): 69–87.
Hussainey, K. and Al-Najjar, B. (2011) Future-oriented narrative reporting: Determinants and use. Journal of Applied Accounting Research 12(2): 123–138.
Hussainey, K., Mgbame, C.O. and Chijoke-Mgbame, A.M. (2011) Dividend policy and share price volatility: UK evidence. The Journal of Risk Finance 12(8): 57–68.
IASB (2010) Management Commentary: A Framework for Presentation. London: International Accounting Standard Board.
IFRS (2010a) Practice Statement, MC, A Framework for Presentation. London, International Financial Reporting Standard.
International Accounting Standards Board (IASB) (2008) Exposure Draft on an improved Conceptual Framework for Financial Reporting: The Objective of Financial Reporting and Qualitative Characteristics of Decision-Useful Financial Reporting Information. London.
ISO 9001 (2008) Sets out the criteria for a quality management system and is the only standard in the family that can be certified to (although this is not a requirement).
Jensen, M. (1993) The modern industrial revolution, exit and the failure of internal control systems. The Journal of Finance 48(3): 831–880.
Jensen, M. and Meckling, W. (1976) Theory of the firm: Management behaviour, agency costs and ownership structure. Journal of Financial Economics 3(3): 305–360.
Jiang, H. and Habib, A. (2009) The impact of ownership concentration on voluntary disclosure practices in New Zealand. Accounting Research Journal 22(3): 275–304.
Jonas, G.J. and Blanchet, J. (2000) Assessing quality of financial reporting. Accounting Horizons 14(3): 353–363.
Karamanou, I. and Vafeas, N. (2005) The association between corporate boards, audit committees, and management earnings forecasts: An empirical analysis. Journal of Accounting research 43(3): 453–486.
Konijn, S.J.J., Kräussl, R. and Lucas, A. (2011) Blockholder dispersion and firm value. Journal of Corporate Finance 17(5): 1330–1339.
Krause, R., Semadeni, M. and Cannella, A. (2014) CEO duality A review and research agenda. Journal of Management 40(1): 256–286.
Lakhal, F. (2005) Voluntary earnings disclosures and corporate governance: Evidence from France. Review of Accounting and Finance 4(3): 64–85.
Laksmana, I. (2008) Corporate board governance and voluntary disclosure of executive compensation practices. Contemporary Accounting Research 25(4): 1147–1182.
Li, J., Mangena, M. and Pike, R. (2012) The effect of audit committee characteristics on intellectual capital disclosure. The British Accounting Review 44(2): 98–110.
Li, J., Pike, R. and Haniffa, R. (2008) Intellectual capital disclosure and corporate governance structure in UK firms. Accounting and Business Research 38(2): 137–159.
Linsley, P.M. and Shrives, P.J. (2006) Risk reporting: A study of risk disclosures in the annual reports of UK companies. The British Accounting Review 38(4): 387–404.
Lipton, M. and Lorsch, J.W. (1992) A modest proposal for improved corporate governance. The business lawyer: 59–77.
Liu, C., Uchida, K. and Yang, Y. (2014) Controlling shareholder, split-share structure reform and cash dividend payments in China. International Review of Economics and Finance 29: 339–357.
Luo, X. and Bhattacharya, C.B. (2006) Corporate social responsibility, customer satisfaction, and market value. Journal of marketing 70(4): 1–18.
Makhija, A.K. and Patton, J.M. (2004) The impact of firm ownership structure on voluntary disclosure: Empirical evidence from Czech annual reports. The Journal of Business 77(3): 457–491.
Mandurah, S., Khatib, J. and Al-Sabaan, S. (2012) Corporate social responsibility among Saudi Arabian firms: An empirical investigation. The Journal of Applied Business Research 28(5): 234–246.
Mashayekhi, B. and Bazaz, M. (2008) Corporate governance and firm performance in Iran. Journal of Contemporary Accounting and Economics 4(2): 156–172.
McWilliams, A. and Siegel, D. (2001) Corporate social responsibility: A theory of the firm perspective. Academy of management review 26(1): 117–127.
Milne, M. and Adler, R. (1999) ‘Exploring the reliability of social and environmental disclosures content analysis’. Accounting. Auditing and Accountability Journal 12(2): 237 256.
Morris, R. (1987) Signalling, agency theory and accounting policy choice. Accounting and Business Research 18(69): 47–56.
Nalband, A. and Al-Amri, M. (2013) Corporate social responsibility perception, practices and performance of listed companies of Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. International Business Journal 23(3): 284–295.
Newson, M. and Deegan, C. (2002) Global expectations and their associations with corporate social disclosure practice in Australia, Singapore and South Korea. The International Journal of Accounting 37(2): 183–213.
Ng, L.W. (1985) Social Responsibility Disclosures of Selected New Zealand Companies for 1981–1983, Faculty of Business, Massey University. Occasional Paper No. 54.
Nicholson, G.J. and Kiel, G.C. (2007) Can directors impact performance? A case based test of three theories of corporate governance. Corporate Governance: An International Review 15(4): 585–608.
Ntim, C., Opong, K., Danbolt, J. and Thomas, D. (2012a) Voluntary corporate governance disclosures by post-apartheid South African corporations. Journal of Applied Accounting Research 13(2): 122–144.
Oyeler, P., Laswad, F. and Fisher, R. (2003) Determinants of internet financial reporting by New Zealand companies. Journal of International Management and Accounting 14(1): 26–63.
O’Sullivan, M., Percy, M. and Stewart, J. (2008) Australian evidence on corporate governance attributes and their association with forward looking information in the annual report. Journal of Management and Governance 12(1): 5–35.
Raffournier, B. (1995) The determinants of voluntary financial disclosure by Swiss listed companies. European Accounting Review 4(2): 261–280.
Report on the Observance of Standards and Codes (ROSC) (2009) A Corporate Governance Country Assessment for The Arab Republic of Egypt, http://www.worldbank.org/ifa/rosc_cg_egy.pdf, accessed 17 August 2014.
Rose, J.M. (2007) Corporate directors and social responsibility: Ethics versus shareholder value. Journal of Business Ethics 73(3): 319–333.
Samaha, K. and Dahawy, K. (2011) An empirical analysis of corporate governance structures and voluntary corporate disclosure in volatile capital markets: The Egyptian experience. International Journal of Accounting, Auditing and Performance Evaluation (IJAAPE) 7(1–2): 61–93.
Schiehll, E., Terra, P. and Victor, F. (2013) Determinants of voluntary executive stock option disclosure in Brazil. Journal of Management and Governance 19(4): 333–343.
Shleifer, A. (1998) State versus private ownership: National bureau of economic research.
Siebels, J. and Knyphausen‐Aufseb, D. (2012) A review of theory in family business research: The implications for corporate governance. International Journal of Management Reviews 14(3): 280–304.
Sun, N., Salama, A., Hussainey, K. and Habbash, M. (2010) Corporate environmental disclosure, corporate governance and earnings management. Managerial Auditing Journal 25(7): 679–700.
Tabachnick, B. and Fidell, L. (2007) Using Multivariate Statistics. 5th edn. London: Pearson Education.
Tauringana, V. and Mangena, M. (2009) Association between reportable segments and key performance indicators disclosure, British Accounting Association (BAA) Annual Conference, Dundee, Scotland.
The Saudi Stock Exchange (Tadawul) http://www.Tadawul.com.sa, accessed 7 December 2014.
Wallace, R., Nasser, K. and Mora, A. (1994) The relationship between the comprehensive of corporate annual reports and firm characteristics in Spain. Accounting & Business Research 25(97): 41–53.
Wang, M. and Hussainey, K. (2013) Voluntary forward-looking statements driven by corporate governance and their value relevance. Journal of Accounting and Public Policy 32(3): 26–49.
Watson, A., Shrives, P. and Martson, C. (2002) Voluntary disclosure of accounting ratios in the UK. British Accounting Review 34(4): 289–313.
Xiao, J., Yang, H. and Chow, C. (2004) The determinants and characteristics of voluntary internet based disclosures by listed Chinese companies. Journal of Accounting & Public Policy 23(3): 191–225.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Appendices
Appendix A
Appendix B
Relevance
Information is considered to be relevant when it has high ability of making difference in many of the decisions taken by users (. IASB, 2010, p. 17). IFRS progress that ‘Financial information is able to make a difference in decision-making’.
Faithful representation
For information to be faithfully representative, it should be complete, natural and free of material misstatement (IASB, 2010).
Understandability
The IASB (2010) define the understandability as understanding of knowledge regarding the quality of the information that enabled users to understand their meaning. IASB (2010) suggest that understandability is enhanced when information is classified, characterised and presented clearly and concisely.
Comparability
The Comparability is considered to be the quality of information that enables users to identify similarities in, and differences between, two sets of economic phenomena characteristic (IASB, 2010). In addition, it helps users to identify the key trends and analyse the performance of the company over time (ASB, 2006).
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Omair Alotaibi, K., Hussainey, K. Determinants of CSR disclosure quantity and quality: Evidence from non-financial listed firms in Saudi Arabia. Int J Discl Gov 13, 364–393 (2016). https://doi.org/10.1057/jdg.2016.2
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1057/jdg.2016.2