Abstract
This chapter intends to elucidate the academic heritage and intellectual background of the father of biophysics in China. My central argument is that if we want to learn about biophysics in China, we have to learn more about Bei Shizhang; if we want to understand Bei, we have to pay a visit to his intellectual world. But this world is complex and many-faceted, for Bei is not just an institution builder and a visionary leader, he is also a charismatic leader and a controversial scientist. This chapter explores these various facets of Bei Shizhang by chronicling his early life in China, the correlation between the formation of his scientific worldview and the naturphilosophie of his neo-Lamarckian German teacher, Wilhelm Harms. I also consider Bei’s contested scientific pursuit––the theory of cell reformation which had some parallels with O.B. Lepeshinskaya’s now discredited studies of “the origins of life” in the Soviet Union––within the larger sets of issues involving Soviet-styled biology, the perception of Marxist philosophy, and political patronage of cytology in twentieth-century Communist states.
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Notes
- 1.
There were many news reports, videos, and articles between October and November 2009 on Bei’s death and legacy. See the following for some of the most representative ones: Committee of the Funeral Service of Bei Shizhang (2009), Zhao and Chen (2009), China News (2009), Xinhua News (2009), Science Times (2009), People’s Daily (2009).
- 2.
In chronicling Bei’s life and work, Bei’s student Ying Youmei divided his timeline into three stages: the first stage spanned from his pre-German schooling and German education to his return to China where he was appointed as chair of the biology department at Zhejiang University (Zheda), a position he held from 1930 to 1949. The Zheda period was stage two. In 1950, he moved to Beijing to establish and organize the Institute of Biophysics of the Chinese Academy of Sciences. That was stage three.
- 3.
I thank Raffael Himmelsbach for his help with the German translation.
- 4.
The English scientific name was coined to capture the fact that this insect is a Nanjing (aka Nanking)-originated species (nankinensis) in the family of chirocephalus. The Chinese name was given by a folklore belief that the appearance of this shrimp in wintertime, along with heavy snowstorms, is a harbinger of a productive year as summarized in the Chinese proverb “heavy snow forecasts a good harvest year” (瑞雪兆丰年).
- 5.
Between 1988 and 2003, two Chinese volumes by the title of Cell reformation I and II were published. The twin volumes contain follow-up and new research on cell reformation under the laboratory guidance of Bei Shizhang. In addition to cell reformation of c. nankinensis yolk granules, sources of experimental data in these studies were broadened to include self-assembly of reforming cells in the early development of chicken embryos, nucleus reformation of cultured bone marrow cells of adult mice, cell proliferation of chlamydia trachomatis, and reconstruction of cells in Rhizobium japonicum in glycine gracilis. However, none of these experiments have been externally reviewed and/or testified by a third party. The figures and data published in these volumes remain less than satisfactory. See Bei, ed. (1988, 2003b).
References
Bei S (Sitsan Pai) (1928) Die Phasen des Lebenscyclus der Anguillula aceti Ehrbgund ihre experimentell-morphologische Beeinflussung. Zeitschrift für wissenschaftliche Zoologie 131:294–344
Bei S (Sitsan Pai) [1942] (1992) Diploide Intersexen Bei Chirocephalus Nankinensis. Science Record, reprinted in Selected writings of Bei Shizhang (SWB), pp 99–100
Bei S (Sitsan Pai) [1943a] (1992) The cellular reformation of yolk granules (卵黄粒与细胞之重建). Ke Xue, reprinted in SWB, pp 110–121
Bei S (Sitsan Pai) [1943b] (1992) Ueber die Transformation der Genitalzellen bei den Chirocephalus-Intersexen. Ke Xue, reprinted in SWB, pp 122–123
Bei S (Sitsan Pai) (ed) (1988) Cell reformation I (细胞重建第一集). Science Press, Beijing
Bei S (Sitsan Pai) (1992) Selected writings of Bei Shizhang (SWB) (贝时璋文选). Zhejiang Science and Technology Press, Hangzhou
Bei S (Sitsan Pai) (2003a) Seventy-year research on cell reformation (七十年的细胞重建研究). PIBB 30(5):I–VII
Bei S (Sitsan Pai) (ed) (2003b) Cell reformation II (细胞重建第二集). Science Press, Beijing
Burkhardt R Jr (1984) The zoological philosophy of J. B. Lamarck. In: Lamarck JB (ed) Zoological philosophy: an exposition with regard to the natural history of animals, The University of Chicago Press, Chicago, pp xv–xxxix
China News (2009) Various sectors in China wave goodbyes to the oldest academician Bei Shizhang (中国各界送别中院最年长院士贝时璋). China News, 4 November
Committee of Funeral Service for Bei Shizhang (贝时璋先生治丧委员会) (2009) Mourning for Bei Shizhang: an obituary (沉痛悼念贝时璋先生: 讣告), 29 October
Conklin EG (1897) The embryology of Crepidula: a contribution to the cell lineage and early development of some marine gasteropods. J Morphol 13(1):1–226. http://archive.org/stream/embryologycrepi00conkgoog/. Accessed 21 Dec 2014
FlorCruz J (2010) ‘Sea Turtles’ reverse China’s brain drain, CNN World, 28 October
Graham L (1974) Science and philosophy in the Soviet Union. Vintage Books, New York
Gould SJ (2002) The structure of evolutionary theory. Belknap Harvard Press, Cambridge
Harms W (1909) Postembryonale Entwicklungsgeschichte der Unioniden. Zoologische Jahrbücher: Abteilung für Anatomie und Ontogenie der Tiere 28:325–386
Harms W (1926) Körper und Keimzellen vol 1 & 2. Springer, Berlin
Harms W (1939) Ders.: Lamarckismus und Darwinismus als historische Theorien. Ein Kampf um Überlebtes. Zeitschrift für Medizin und Naturwissenschaft 73:1–27
Harris H (1999) The birth of the cell. Yale University Press, New Haven
Hu WG (胡文耕) (1982) Philosophical questions in molecular biology (分子生物学中的哲学问题). Tianjin Renmin Press, Tianjin
Hull D (1984) Lamarck among the anglos. In: Lamarck JB (ed) Zoological philosophy: an exposition with regard to the natural history of animals. The University of Chicago Press, Chicago, pp xl–lxvi
Institute of Biophysics, Chinese Academy of Sciences (IBP-CAS) (2003) Bei Shizhang and biophysics: a festschrift (《贝时璋与生物物理学》纪念文集). http://www.ibp.cas.cn/sqzj/45zn/qdxlcbw/jnwc/. Accessed 21 Dec 2014
LaFraniere S (2010) Fighting trend, China is luring scientists home. The New York Times, 6 January
Lepeshinskaya OB (1936) Zur Frage nach der Neubildung von Zellen im tierischen Organismus. 1. Bildung von Zellen und Blutinseln aus Dotterkugeln beim Hühnerembryo. Hnerembryo. Cytologia 7:54–81
Lepeshinskaya OB (1937) Zur Frage nach der Neubildung von Zellen im tierischen Organismus. 2. Mitteilung Neuere Ergebnisse über die Bildung von Zellen und Blutinseln aus den Dotterkugeln des Hühnerembryos, hnerembryos. Cytologia 8:15–39
Luk MYL (1990) The origins of Chinese Bolshevism: an ideology in the making, 1920–1928. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Maienschein J (1978) Cell lineage, ancestral reminiscence, and the biogenetic law. J Hist Bio 11(1):129–158
Mao Z (1964) Talk on Sakata’s article. In: Selected works of Mao Tse-tung, vol IX. http://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/mao/selected-works/volume-9/mswv9_28.html. Accessed 30 Jan 2014
Nature (2012) John Maddox Prize: two strong-minded individuals are the first winners of an award for standing up for science. Nature 491:160, 8 November
People’s Daily (2009) Founder of China’s biophysics and academician of Chinese academy of science Bei Shizhang passed away (我国生物物理学奠基人中国科学院院士贝时璋逝世). People’s Daily, 1 November
Potthast T, Hoßfeld U (2010) Vererbungs- und Entwicklungslehren in Zoologie, Botanik and Rassenkunde/Rassenbiologie: Zentrale Forschungsfelder der Biologie an der Universität Tübingen im Nationalsozialismus. In: Wiesing U et al (eds) Die Universität Tübingen im Nationalsozialismus. Franz Steiner Verlag, Stuttgart, pp 435–482
Rao Y (饶议) (2007) In memory of Zou Chenglu. Commentary Sci Cult 4(2):38–45
Rao Y (饶议) (2009) Rao discussed science (饶议科学). Shanghai Science and Technology Education Press, Shanghai
Rapoport Y (1991) The doctor’s plot of 1953: a survivor’s memoir of Stalin’s last act of terror, against jews and science. Harvard University Press, Cambridge
Science Times (2009) Founder of Chinese biophysics Bei Shizhang died at 107 (中国生物物理学奠基人贝时璋逝世 享年107岁). Science Times, 30 October
Science Times (2010) Bei Shizhang: researching life science with his life (贝时璋:用自己的生命研究生命). Science Times, 11 November
The New Threads (2005) http://www.xys.org/forum/db/208/210.html, 9 November. Accessed 10 April 2015
Wang J (王静) (2009) Remembering academician Bei Shizhang: pioneering the field of biology, expressing the passion of science (记贝时璋院士:创生物伟业 抒科学豪情). Science Times, 2 November
Wang GY (王谷岩) (2010a) Bei Shizhang: a biography (贝时璋传). Science Press, Beijing
Wang GY (王谷岩) (2010b) Shizhang Bei (Sitsan Pai) and his theory of cell reformation. Protein Cell 1(4):315–318
Xinhua News (2009) Thousands farewell Bei Shizhang (千人送别贝时璋). Xinhua News, 5 November
Young D (1911) The implantation of the glochidium on the fish. The Univ Mo Bull: Sci Ser 1(1):1–20
Ying YM (应幼梅) (1992) The life, work and thought of Professor Bei Shizhang (贝时璋教授的生活、工作和思想). In: SWB, pp 1–39
Zhang QQ (张青棋) (1996) The history and reality of research in the philosophy of biology in China after 1949 (建国以来我国生物哲学研究的历史与现状). Studies in Dialectics of Nature. http://hps.pku.edu.cn/2003/06/616. Accessed 21 Dec 2014
Zhang JJ (张坚军) (2002) A biography of Bei Shizhang (贝时璋传). Ningbo Press, Hangzhou
Zhao YH (赵亚辉), Chen XX (陈星星) (2009) The oldest academician Bei Shizhang worked to the last moment: ‘We Have to Fight For Our Country.’ (最高龄院士贝时璋打拼到最后一刻: ‘我们要为国家争口气’). People’s Daily, 2 November
Zhinkin LN, Mikhailov VP (1958) On ‘The New Cell Theory’: two soviet authors critically review recent soviet work on the origin of the cell. Science 128(3317):182–186
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2015 The Author(s)
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Luk, C.Y.L. (2015). The Father of Biophysics in China. In: A History of Biophysics in Contemporary China. SpringerBriefs in History of Science and Technology. Springer, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-18093-9_2
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-18093-9_2
Published:
Publisher Name: Springer, Cham
Print ISBN: 978-3-319-18092-2
Online ISBN: 978-3-319-18093-9
eBook Packages: Humanities, Social Sciences and LawPhilosophy and Religion (R0)